Polvara played for the New York City FC academy during his high school years, and was a regular starter for four years in the academy. Polvara helped NYCFC win back-to-back US Soccer Development Academy National Championships, captaining the team for their second championship. While with NYCFC Academy, Polvara played three years of high school soccer for the Brunswick School in Connecticut, where he served as captain for the program his junior year.[1]
During his second year, Polvara became a starter for the Hoyas, making 14 appearances for the program. He had his first multi-goal game on February 27, 2021, against Villanova University.[6] He finished the 2020 season with eight goals, and was named the Big East Midfielder of the Year.[7]
Polvara replicated his success from 2020 in the 2021 season, making 22 appearances, scoring seven times, including three goals in the 2021 NCAA Division I Men's Soccer Tournament. His success earned him the Big East Midfielder of the Year Award and First-Team All-Conference. Additionally, Polvara earned the Hermann Trophy, which is an annual award given to the top college soccer player in the country.[8] Polvara concurrently won the TopDrawerSoccer.com Men's National Player of the Year Award.[9]
On March 6, 2022, Polvara made his professional debut coming on in the 84th minute in a 0–1 loss at Rangers. He made his first start for the club in a league game against Hibernian in May 2022.[13]
On September 21, 2023, Polvara scored his first goal for the club against in the UEFA Europa Conference League against Eintracht Frankfurt[17] and again in the same competition against PAOK. Polvara scored his first domestic league goal in 4–0 win against Hibernian in May 2024.[18]
Career statistics
match played May 19, 2024
Appearances and goals by club, season and competition[19]