Burrow-Giles Lithographic Co. v. Sarony

Burrow-Giles Lithographic Co. v. Sarony
Submitted December 13, 1883
Decided March 17, 1884
Full case nameBurrow-Giles Lithographic Company v. Napoleon Sarony
Citations111 U.S. 53 (more)
4 S. Ct. 279; 28 L. Ed. 349; 1884 U.S. LEXIS 1757
Case history
PriorJudgment for plaintiff, 17 F. 591 (S.D.N.Y. 1883); affirmed, C.C.S.D.N.Y.
Holding
It is within the constitutional power of Congress to extend copyright protection to photographs that are a representation of an author's original intellectual conceptions. Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York affirmed.
Court membership
Chief Justice
Morrison Waite
Associate Justices
Samuel F. Miller · Stephen J. Field
Joseph P. Bradley · John M. Harlan
William B. Woods · Stanley Matthews
Horace Gray · Samuel Blatchford
Case opinion
MajorityMiller, joined by unanimous
Laws applied
U.S. Const. art. I; U.S. Rev. Stat. §§ 4952, 4965 (Copyright Act of 1870)

Burrow-Giles Lithographic Co. v. Sarony, 111 U.S. 53 (1884), was a case decided by the Supreme Court of the United States that upheld the power of Congress to extend copyright protection to photography.[1]

Background of the case

The subject of the lawsuit: Oscar Wilde No. 18 by Napoleon Sarony (1882)

Photographer Napoleon Sarony filed a copyright infringement suit against the Burrow-Giles Lithographic Company, which had marketed unauthorized lithographs of Sarony's photograph of writer Oscar Wilde, entitled "Oscar Wilde No. 18." The company argued that photographs could not qualify as "writings" or as the production of an "author", in the language of the grant of power to Congress under article I, section 8, clause 8 of the United States Constitution to protect copyrights, and so § 4952 of the Copyright Act of 1865, which explicitly extended protection to photographs, was unconstitutional. The federal trial court for the Southern District of New York, though expressing some doubt over the constitutionality of § 4952, declined to invalidate it and awarded a $610 judgment ($21,000 in modern dollars[2]) to Sarony. It was affirmed by the U.S. Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York, and then appealed to the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court's decision

Regarding the interpretation of "writings" in the Constitution, Justice Miller's unanimous opinion for the Supreme Court wrote that Congress has "properly declared these to include all forms of writing, printing, engraving, etching, &c., by which the ideas in the mind of the author are given visible expression." The Court noted that "maps and charts" were among the subjects of the first Copyright Act of 1790, and that etchings and engravings were added when it was first amended in 1802. The members of Congress that passed these first copyright acts were contemporaries of the Framers of the Constitution, and many of them attended the Constitutional Convention itself. As such, their interpretation of the Constitution, Justice Miller wrote, "is of itself entitled to very great weight, and when it is remembered that the rights thus established have not been disputed during a period of nearly a century, it is almost conclusive."

Even if other visual works could be copyrighted, Burrow-Giles argued, photography was merely a mechanical process rather than an art, and could not embody an author's "idea". The Court accepted that this may be true of "ordinary" photographs, but this was not in the case of Sarony's image of Wilde. The trial court had found that Sarony had "by posing the said Oscar Wilde in front of the camera, selecting and arranging the costume, draperies, and other various accessories in said photograph, arranging the subject so as to present graceful outlines, arranging and disposing the light and shade, suggesting and evoking the desired expression, and from such disposition, arrangement, or representation, made entirely by the plaintiff, he produced the picture in suit."[3] This control that Sarony exercised over the subject matter, in the view of the Court, showed that he was the "author" of "an original work of art" and thus within the "class" of things for which the Constitution intended Congress to grant him exclusive rights under the copyright laws.[4]

See also

References

  1. ^ Burrow-Giles Lithographic Co. v. Sarony, 111 U.S. 53 (1884).
  2. ^ 1634–1699: McCusker, J. J. (1997). How Much Is That in Real Money? A Historical Price Index for Use as a Deflator of Money Values in the Economy of the United States: Addenda et Corrigenda (PDF). American Antiquarian Society. 1700–1799: McCusker, J. J. (1992). How Much Is That in Real Money? A Historical Price Index for Use as a Deflator of Money Values in the Economy of the United States (PDF). American Antiquarian Society. 1800–present: Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis. "Consumer Price Index (estimate) 1800–". Retrieved February 29, 2024.
  3. ^ 111 U.S. at 55, 60.
  4. ^ 111 U.S. at 60.

Read other articles:

AgemochiJenisMakanan ringanTempat asalJepangBahan utamaMochiSunting kotak info • L • BBantuan penggunaan templat ini Agemochi (揚げ餅code: ja is deprecated ) adalah makanan ringan dari Jepang terkenal yang terbuat dari mochi yang digoreng. Mochi yang sudah kering kemudian dijadikan potongan-potongan kecil, sekitar 1 cm, dipotong dadu dan digoreng. Hal ini biasanya dimakan asin, tetapi ada juga berbagai rasa versi, seperti shichimi agemochi, agemochi ditutupi dengan bumbu...

 

Ōkura 大蔵村DesaKantor Desa Ōkura BenderaEmblemLokasi Ōkura di Prefektur YamagataŌkuraLokasi di JepangKoordinat: 38°42′15″N 140°13′49.3″E / 38.70417°N 140.230361°E / 38.70417; 140.230361Koordinat: 38°42′15″N 140°13′49.3″E / 38.70417°N 140.230361°E / 38.70417; 140.230361Negara JepangWilayahTōhokuPrefektur YamagataDistrikMogamiPemerintahan • WalidesaMasami KatōLuas • Total211,59...

 

Military component for the state of Tennessee; includes National Guard and State Guard Tennessee Military DepartmentSeal of the Tennessee Military DepartmentAgency overviewJurisdictionTennesseeHeadquartersNashville, Tennessee36°05′57″N 86°45′25″W / 36.099207°N 86.756892°W / 36.099207; -86.756892MottoAlways there when you need us.Employees2,800+ full-time federal employees 390+ state employees 13,000+ traditional Guard membersAnnual budget$114,796,200Agency ...

Royal mandate or decree issued by a sovereign in an Islamic state For the surname, see Firman (surname). Ferman redirects here. For the surname or given name, see Ferman (name). A Fat'h Ali Shah Qajar firman in Shikasta Nastaʿlīq script, January 1831 Look up firman in Wiktionary, the free dictionary. A firman (Persian: فرمان, romanized: farmân; Turkish: ferman),[1] at the constitutional level, was a royal mandate or decree issued by a sovereign in an Islamic state. During...

 

Almost LoveSingel oleh Sabrina Carpenterdari album Singular: Act IDirilis06 Juni 2018 (2018-06-06)DirekamAwal tahun 2018StudioThe Stellar House (Venesia, California)Genre Dance-pop Pop elektro Durasi3:31LabelHollywoodPencipta Sabrina Carpenter Steph Jones Nate Campany Mikkel Eriksen Produser Stargate Kronologi singel Sabrina Carpenter Alien (2018) Almost Love (2018) Sue Me (2018) Video musikAlmost Love di YouTube Almost Love adalah lagu yang direkam oleh penyanyi Amerika Sabrina Carpente...

 

Синелобый амазон Научная классификация Домен:ЭукариотыЦарство:ЖивотныеПодцарство:ЭуметазоиБез ранга:Двусторонне-симметричныеБез ранга:ВторичноротыеТип:ХордовыеПодтип:ПозвоночныеИнфратип:ЧелюстноротыеНадкласс:ЧетвероногиеКлада:АмниотыКлада:ЗавропсидыКласс:Пт�...

Gold discovery triggering an onrush of miners seeking fortuneFor other uses of the term gold rush, see Gold Rush (disambiguation) and California gold rush.The fastest clipper ships cut the travel time from New York to San Francisco from seven months to four months in the 1849 California Gold Rush.[1] A gold rush or gold fever is a discovery of gold—sometimes accompanied by other precious metals and rare-earth minerals—that brings an onrush of miners seeking their fortune. Major go...

 

1988 United States Senate election in New Mexico ← 1982 November 8, 1988 1994 →   Nominee Jeff Bingaman Bill Valentine Party Democratic Republican Popular vote 321,983 186,579 Percentage 63.31% 36.68% County resultsBingaman:      50–60%      60–70%      70–80%      80–90%Valentine:      50–60% U.S. senator before election Jeff ...

 

Ambient pressure diver propulsion vehicle A Sleeping Beauty wet sub used by the Royal Navy during World War II A wet sub is a type of underwater vehicle, either a submarine or a submersible, that does not provide a dry environment for its occupants. It is also described as an underwater vehicle where occupants are exposed to ambient environment during operations.[1] The watercraft is classified as medium-sized or small vessel.[2] This type of submarine differs from other under...

Stockport Branch CanalMany of the canal's structures have survived, including this bridge at Abbey Hey LaneSpecificationsStatustwo fifths a footpathHistoryOriginal ownerAshton Canal CompanyDate of act1793Date of first use1797Date closed1962GeographyStart pointClaytonEnd pointStockportConnects toAshton Canal vteStockport Canal Legend Ashton Canal locks 10 + 11 A635 Ashton Old Road bridge Gorton Stn aqueduct Maintenance arm Abbey Hey Lane bridge Hyde Road station and bridge A57 Hyde Road bridg...

 

Jinn-like being often associated with eating human flesh in Arabian folklore For other uses, see Ghoul (disambiguation). This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Ghoul – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (November 2023) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Amine Discovered with the Go...

 

Stauning II35th Cabinet of DenmarkMembers of the Stauning II CabinetDate formed30 April 1929 (1929-04-30)Date dissolved4 November 1935 (1935-11-04)People and organisationsHead of stateChristian XHead of governmentThorvald StauningTotal no. of members13Member partySocial DemocratsSocial LiberalsStatus in legislatureCoalitionHistoryElection(s)19291932Outgoing election1935PredecessorMadsen-MygdalSuccessorStauning III The Second Cabinet of Stauning was the government...

Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento Spagna non cita le fonti necessarie o quelle presenti sono insufficienti. Puoi migliorare questa voce aggiungendo citazioni da fonti attendibili secondo le linee guida sull'uso delle fonti. Comunità Valencianacomunità autonomaComunitat ValencianaComunidad Valenciana (dettagli) Comunità Valenciana – VedutaIl Palau de la Generalitat Valenciana, sede della comunità autonoma LocalizzazioneStato Spagna AmministrazioneCapoluogo Valencia Presiden...

 

خوسيه خوسيه   معلومات شخصية اسم الولادة (بالإسبانية: José Rómulo Sosa Ortiz)‏  الميلاد 17 فبراير 1948 [1]  الوفاة 28 سبتمبر 2019 (71 سنة) [2]  هومستيد  سبب الوفاة سرطان البنكرياس  مواطنة المكسيك  الزوجة آنيل (1974–1992)  الأولاد خوسيه جويل  [لغات أخرى]‏  عدد ال...

 

Adobe Content ServerDeveloper(s)Adobe SystemsStable release6.0.0 / September 3, 2014; 9 years ago (2014-09-03) Operating systemCross-platformTypeDigital rights management, content serverLicenseAdobe EULA / ProprietaryWebsitewww.adobe.com/solutions/ebook/content-server.html Adobe Content Server is software developed by Adobe Systems to add digital rights management to e-books. It is designed to protect and distribute Adobe e-books in PDF or EPUB format through Adobe Digital E...

American football player and coach Brice TaylorTaylor at USC, c. 1925Biographical detailsBorn(1902-07-04)July 4, 1902Seattle, Washington, U.S.DiedSeptember 18, 1974(1974-09-18) (aged 72)Downey, California, U.S.Playing career1924–1926USC Position(s)Fullback, guardCoaching career (HC unless noted)1927Claflin1928–1931Southern1932–1933Claflin1934–1935Bishop1936–1938Samuel Huston Accomplishments and honorsAwards First-team All-American (1925) 2× First-team All-PCC (1925, 1926...

 

  هذه المقالة عن أكرم حوراني. لمعانٍ أخرى، طالع الحوراني. أكرم الحوراني معلومات شخصية الميلاد 1912حماة الوفاة 1996عمان مواطنة سوريا  الحياة العملية المدرسة الأم جامعة دمشق  المهنة سياسي  الحزب الحزب العربي الاشتراكي، حزب البعث العربي الاشتراكي اللغات العربية  ...

 

Pour les articles homonymes, voir Audience. Si ce bandeau n'est plus pertinent, retirez-le. Cliquez ici pour en savoir plus. Cet article ne cite pas suffisamment ses sources (février 2013). Si vous disposez d'ouvrages ou d'articles de référence ou si vous connaissez des sites web de qualité traitant du thème abordé ici, merci de compléter l'article en donnant les références utiles à sa vérifiabilité et en les liant à la section « Notes et références ». En pratique&...

2007 2017 Élections législatives de 2012 dans le Pas-de-Calais 12 sièges de députés à l'Assemblée nationale 10 et 17 juin 2012 Corps électoral et résultats Inscrits 1 084 424 Votants au 1er tour 623 512   57,5 %  3,6 Votes exprimés au 1er tour 610 076 Votants au 2d tour 558 167   56,12 % Votes exprimés au 2d tour 529 504 Majorité présidentielle Liste Parti socialisteEurope Écologie Les VertsParti radical de gaucheMouvem...

 

Expansion of the Islamic state (622–750) For later military territorial expansion of Islamic states, see Spread of Islam. Early Muslim conquests  Expansion under Muhammad, 622–632  Expansion under the Rashidun Caliphate, 632–661  Expansion under the Umayyad Caliphate, 661–750Date622–750 CELocation Middle East and North Africa Mediterranean Europe Central Asia South Asia[a] Result Muslim victoryTerritorialchanges Arab dominion (caliphate) establi...