Advisory opinion on Western Sahara

Advisory opinion on Western Sahara
CourtInternational Court of Justice
Decided1975

The International Court of Justice Advisory Opinion on Western Sahara was a 1975 advisory, non-binding opinion by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) of two questions presented to it by the UN General Assembly under Resolution 3292[1] regarding the disputed territory of Western Sahara (then Spanish Sahara). Morocco had approached the UN to adjudicate its and Mauritania's claims over the territory.

The ICJ deliberated between 13 December 1974 and 16 October 1975. The final ruling by the Court stated that:

The materials and information presented to it [the ICJ] do not establish any tie of territorial sovereignty between the territory of Western Sahara and the Kingdom of Morocco or the Mauritanian entity. Thus the Court has not found legal ties of such a nature as might affect the application of resolution 1514 (XV) in the decolonization of Western Sahara and, in particular, of the principle of self-determination through the free and genuine expression of the will of the peoples of the Territory (ICJ Reports 16 October 1975, 162).[2]

Background

Morocco gained independence in 1956, and the Istiqlal Party presented its vision of a Western Sahara state that would be part of Morocco, with suggested boundaries.[3] The Moroccan nationalists supported the idea of a Greater Morocco, based upon the territory of the Sharifian empire which preceded French and British colonization. The proposed "Greater Morocco" area included what was at the time Spanish Sahara, French West Africa, and French Algeria. The Kingdom of Morocco formally adopted the 'Greater Morocco' vision under Mohammed V in 1958.[3] After Mauritanian and Algerian independence in the early 1960s, Morocco renounced its claims to most of Greater Morocco, but maintained its irredentist claim over Western Sahara.

Following the establishment of the Special Committee on Decolonization, the Spanish Sahara was included in 1963 in the preliminary list of territories to which the declaration on the granting of independence to colonial peoples and countries applied, and from that year on the question of Western Sahara had been regularly considered by the Special Committee and in the General Assembly.[4] On 20 December 1966, United Nations General Assembly Resolution 2229[5] called on Spain to hold a referendum on self-determination in the territory.

After initially resisting all claims by Morocco and Mauritania (which also started laying claims to parts of the region), Spain announced on 20 August 1974 that a referendum on self-determination would be held in the first six months of 1975.[6]

Morocco declared it could not accept a referendum which would include an option for Saharan independence, and renewed its demands for the integration of the remaining provinces of Saguia el-Hamra and Rio de Oro to the Morocco's sovereignty.[citation needed] In Mauritania, a smaller movement claimed some of the territory, and suggested partitioning it with Morocco.[citation needed]

Algeria–Morocco relations had been strained since Algeria's independence in 1962, culminating in the Sand War, and a lack of normalized relations.[citation needed] Algeria, after initially supporting Morocco and Mauritania in their demands, started in 1975 to support the independence of the Spanish Sahara.[citation needed] Algeria officially supported the right of self-determination of the people of the former Spanish colony, as it had supported the right of self-determination of the peoples of the rest of the African colonized countries. The Polisario Front, created in 1973, engaged in several attacks against Spanish garrisons and patrols, and attacked the Fosbucraa conveyor belt, which exported the rich local phosphates to the El Marsa port.

On 17 September 1974, King Hassan II announced his intention to bring the issue to the World Court.[citation needed] In December, Spain agreed to delay the referendum pending the opinion of the court, and supported submission to the World Court so long as the decision would be non-binding and advisory only, rather than a "contentious issue", where the ruling would oblige the affected states to act in a particular manner.[citation needed]

On 13 December 1974, the United Nations General Assembly approved UN General Assembly Resolution 3292, defining the wording of the questions to be submitted. Algeria was among the nations voting in favor, and several Third World nations abstained.[who?][citation needed]

Submission

UN General Assembly Resolution 3292[1] requested that the International Court give an advisory opinion on the following questions:

I. Was Western Sahara (Río de Oro and Sakiet El Hamra) at the time of colonization by Spain a territory belonging to no one (terra nullius)?

And, should the majority opinion be "no", the following would be addressed:

II. What were the legal ties between this territory and the Kingdom of Morocco and the Mauritanian entity?

In the meantime, Morocco and Mauritania jointly agreed to not contest the issue of partition or sovereignty. On 16 January 1975, Spain officially announced the suspension of the referendum plan, pending the opinion of the court. From 12 to 19 May, a small investigative team made of citizens from Cuba, Iran, and Côte d'Ivoire was sent into the region to assess public support for independence. They also performed inquiries in Algeria, Mauritania, Morocco, and Spain.

In the summer, the questions were submitted by King Hassan II and Spain. Algeria, Mauritania, Morocco, and Spain were all given permission to present evidence at the hearings (the Polisario was locked out as only internationally recognized states have a right to speak - Algeria largely represented the Sahrawis). Twenty-seven sessions were held in June and July before the Court called the proceedings final.

The arguments presented by Morocco and Mauritania were essentially similar: that either one had a sovereign right over the territory. In the case of Morocco, the kingdom of Morocco claimed the allegiance of a variety of tribes in surrounding territory. In the case of Mauritania, there was no clearly defined state that existed at the time. Instead, Mauritania argued that a similar entity existed which they called "bilad Chinguetti". Spain argued against Moroccan sovereignty, citing the relationship that Spanish explorers and colonizers had established with the sultan, none of which ever recognized his authority over the region. Algeria also defended the position that the Sahrawis were a distinct people[citation needed], and not under the subjection of Morocco or Mauritania.

The opinion

On 15 October, a UN visiting mission sent by the General Assembly to tour the region and investigate the political situation published its findings, showing that the Sahrawi population were "overwhelmingly" in favor of independence from both Spain and Morocco/Mauritania. These findings were submitted to the Court, who published their opinion the next day.

For the former question, the Court decided by a vote of 13 to three that the court could make a decision on the matter, and unanimously voted that at the time of colonization (defined as 28 November 1884), the territory was not terra nullius (that is, the territory, did belong to someone).

For the latter question, the Court decided by a vote of 14 to two that it would decide. It was of the opinion, by 14 votes to two, that there were legal ties of allegiance between this territory and the Kingdom of Morocco. Furthermore, it was of opinion, by 15 votes to one, that there were legal ties between this territory and the "Mauritanian entity". However, the Court defined the nature of these legal ties in the penultimate paragraph of its opinion, and declared that neither legal tie implied sovereignty or rightful ownership over the territory. These legal ties also did not apply to "self-determination through the free and genuine expression of the will of the peoples of the Territory." (ICJ Reports (1975) p. 68, para. 162)

Results

The opinion of the Court was interpreted differently by the different parties, and each focused on what it sees as supporting its claims.

While Morocco and Mauritania found in the answers to the two questions a recognition that their claims are legitimate and historically based, Algeria and the Polisario Front focused on the penultimate paragraph that stated that the court's decision was not to hinder the application of self-determination through the ongoing Spanish referendum.

King Hassan II declared the organisation of a peaceful march to force Spain to start negotiations on the status of the territory, to which Spain finally agreed. A round of talks between Spain, Morocco and Mauritania were held in Madrid and culminated in a tripartite agreement, becoming known as the Madrid Accords. On 16 November 1975, where Spain agreed to the temporary administration of the northern two thirds of the territory by Morocco, while the southern third was to be temporarily administered by Mauritania; sovereignty was not ceded and both administrations were subject to a subsequent referendum. Algeria protested against the agreement, and president Boumédiène retaliated by expelling all Moroccans living in Algeria.

In consequence, the Court's decisions were largely disregarded by the interested parties. On 31 October 1975 the first Moroccan troops invaded Western Sahara from the north-east. Algeria sent its troops into the territory of Western Sahara to help in the logistics of the evacuation of the Sahrawi refugees who have been bombarded by Moroccan air forces, which led to the first and last direct military confrontation between units of the Moroccan armed forces and the Algerian national army in the First Battle of Amgala (1976). The Algerian army suffered hundreds of deaths and more than a hundred soldiers were made prisoners by the Moroccan army.[citation needed] Diplomatic intervention from Saudi Arabia and Egypt prevented the situation from escalating further.

The Spanish government withdrew its troops from Spanish Sahara on January 12, 1976, and formally ended any presence in the territory on February 26, 1976.[7] The next day, the Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic was declared by Polisario Front representatives.[8] Morocco intensified its military presence in the region, and by the end of the year, Mauritania and Morocco had partitioned the territory. Mauritania was too weak militarily and economically to compete against Polisario, though, and was forced to renounce its claims in 1979.[citation needed] Morocco immediately annexed that territory. Morocco has continued to administer most of Western Sahara, and its sovereignty has been recognized by the United States.[9] At the same time, 82 governments have recognized the Sahrawi Republic as the legitimate government of Western Sahara.[10]

See also

References

  1. ^ a b "General Assembly Resolutions 30th Session". www.un.org.
  2. ^ Suarez, David (21 October 2016). "The Western Sahara and the Search for the Roots of Sahrawi National Identity". Florida International University: 16–17. doi:10.25148/etd.FIDC001212.
  3. ^ a b Campos-Serrano, Alicia; Rodríguez-Esteban, José Antonio (January 2017). "Imagined territories and histories in conflict during the struggles for Western Sahara, 1956–1979". Journal of Historical Geography. 55: 47. doi:10.1016/j.jhg.2016.11.009. hdl:10486/686245.
  4. ^ "Decolonization A publication of the United Nations Department of Political Alf airs, Trusteeship and Decolonization" (PDF). United Nations. October 1980. p. 4. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2020-07-12.
  5. ^ "Decolonization A publication of the United Nations Department of Political Alf airs, Trusteeship and Decolonization" (PDF). United Nations. 15 April 2021 [October 1980]. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2020-07-12. Retrieved 15 April 2021.
  6. ^ "Letter dated August 20, 1974 from the Permanent Representative of Spain to the United Nations to the Secretary-General, U.N. Doc. A/9714". United Nations General Security Assembly Council. 1976. Archived from the original on 2021-04-15.
  7. ^ "35. Spanish Sahara (1965-1976)". uca.edu. Retrieved 2022-02-09.
  8. ^ "Landmark anniversary in W Sahara". Al Jazeera. 26 February 2006. Retrieved 29 January 2024.
  9. ^ Mundy, Jacob (December 11, 2020). "The U.S. recognized Moroccan sovereignty over the disputed Western Sahara. Here's what that means". Washington Post.
  10. ^ Mello, Michele de (17 January 2023). "Direct from Western Sahara: learn about the struggle of the last colony in Africa". Peoples Dispatch. Retrieved 29 January 2024.

Further reading

Read other articles:

This is a list of current and former cinemas in Hong Kong. Broadway Circuit PALACE ifc Former Broadway Olympian City cinema In addition to operating its own brand, Broadway Circuit also operates the B+, PALACE, Premiere Elements, MOViE MOViE and MY CINEMA chains. It previously run AMC-branded cinema in Pacific Place.[1] Broadway Cinematheque Broadway Hollywood, at Plaza Hollywood Broadway Kingswood Ginza, at Kingswood Ginza Broadway Kwai Fong, at Metroplaza Broadway Mongkok, on Sai Y...

 

وانستيدمعلومات عامةالتقسيم الإداري London Borough of Redbridge (en) البلد  المملكة المتحدة شبكة المواصلات مترو لندن الخطوط الخط المركزي المحطات المجاورة Leytonstone tube station (en) [1]على الخط: الخط المركزيباتجاه: إيلينغ برودوي، ‏غرب روسليب — ريدبريج[1]على الخط: الخط المركزيباتجاه: وود...

 

Artikel ini tidak memiliki referensi atau sumber tepercaya sehingga isinya tidak bisa dipastikan. Tolong bantu perbaiki artikel ini dengan menambahkan referensi yang layak. Tulisan tanpa sumber dapat dipertanyakan dan dihapus sewaktu-waktu.Cari sumber: Diskografi SM Entertainment – berita · surat kabar · buku · cendekiawan · JSTOR Ini adalah daftar album yang dirilis di bawah SM Entertainment. 1990-an 1996 H.O.T. - We Hate All Kinds of Violence 1997 H....

ييمنون   تقسيم إداري البلد اليونان  [1] خصائص جغرافية إحداثيات 38°26′10″N 23°52′49″E / 38.436111111111°N 23.880277777778°E / 38.436111111111; 23.880277777778   الارتفاع 135 متر  السكان التعداد السكاني 1753 (إحصاء السكان) (2021)1739 (resident population of Greece) (2021)1953 (resident population of Greece) (2001)1884 (resident population of ...

 

Zang Dhok Palri Phodong monastère de Kalimpong. Le monastère Zang Dhok Palri Phodang est un monastère bouddhique de Kalimpong dans l'État indien du Bengale-Occidental. Consacré lors d'une visite du dalaï-lama en 1976, il comporte des ouvrages rares, apportés en Inde du Tibet après le soulèvement tibétain de 1959[1]. Références ↑ Aruna Deshpande, Buddhist India Rediscovered, p. 304 Portail du monachisme Portail de l’Inde Portail du bouddhisme Portail du Tibet

 

Titanium trisulfide Names Other names Titanium(IV) sulfide Identifiers CAS Number 12423-80-2 Y 3D model (JSmol) Interactive imageInteractive image ChemSpider 50645119 InChI InChI=1S/3S.TiKey: HOZYDKBKUUVYKD-UHFFFAOYSA-NInChI=1S/S2.S.Ti/c1-2;;/q2*-2;+4Key: KVFIBOBJNNMQLV-UHFFFAOYSA-N SMILES [S][S].[S].[Ti][S-][S-].[S-2].[Ti+4] Properties Chemical formula TiS3 Molar mass 144.062 g/mol Appearance Black whiskers Band gap 1 eV (indirect)[1][2] Ele...

State in which the rate of mortality from senescence is stable or decreasing Not to be confused with immortalised cell line. Biological immortality (sometimes referred to as bio-indefinite mortality) is a state in which the rate of mortality from senescence is stable or decreasing, thus decoupling it from chronological age. Various unicellular and multicellular species, including some vertebrates, achieve this state either throughout their existence or after living long enough. A biologically...

 

Thai fashion and lifestyle magazine owned by Haemarit Co., Ltd. Kazz MagazineKazz Magazine Vol. 10, Issue No. 117CategoriesFashionLifestyleFrequencyMonthlyPublisherHaemarit Co., Ltd.[1][2]CountryThailandBased inBangkokLanguageThaiWebsitekazz-magazine.comISSN1686-8471 Kazz Magazine (sometimes stylized as KAZZ Magazine) is a Thai monthly fashion and lifestyle magazine owned by Haemarit Co., Ltd.[2] covering topics about entertainment personalities and celebrities. The ma...

 

تاي مو شان الموقع منتصف الأقاليم الجديدة، هونغ كونغ المنطقة هونغ كونغ  إحداثيات 22°24′42″N 114°07′23″E / 22.4118°N 114.123°E / 22.4118; 114.123   الارتفاع 957 متر (3,140 قدم) تعديل مصدري - تعديل   تاي مو شان (بالصينية: 大帽山، وتعني جبل القبعة الكبيرة) هو أعلى جبل في منطقة هونغ كو�...

DC Comics comic book event Future StateThe cover of Future State: Justice League #1 (January 2021, DC Comics), featuring new characters introduced during the storyline. Art by Dan Mora.Publication informationPublisherDC ComicsFormatMultiple limited seriesGenre Superhero Publication dateJanuary – March 2021Creative teamWritten byMultipleArtist(s)Multiple Future State is a comic book storyline published by DC Comics in January and February 2021,[a] consisting of multiple limited ...

 

Duta Besar Yordania untuk IndonesiaPetahanaSudqi Atallah Abdel Qader Al Omoushsejak 2023 Berikut adalah daftar duta besar Kerajaan Hasyimiyah Yordania untuk Republik Indonesia. Nama Kredensial Selesai tugas Ref. Kamel Al Sharef 3 Juni 1972 [1] Riyad Sobri 15 Juli 1978 [1] Majed Al Haj Hasan 4 Desember 1982 [1] Nayef Khalid Mawla 29 November 1986 [1] Lu'ai Muhammad Al Khashman 11 Agustus 1992 [1] Walid Abdel Rahman Jaffal Al Hadid 19 November 2013 &...

 

Logographs in shared East Asian written tradition For help with CJK character display, see Help:Multilingual support (East Asian). Translation of That old man is 72 years old in Vietnamese, Cantonese, Mandarin (in simplified and traditional characters), Japanese, and Korean. In internationalization, CJK characters is a collective term for graphemes used in the Chinese, Japanese, and Korean writing systems, which each include Chinese characters. The term CJKV also includes Vietnamese, which wa...

此條目没有列出任何参考或来源。 (2012年2月7日)維基百科所有的內容都應該可供查證。请协助補充可靠来源以改善这篇条目。无法查证的內容可能會因為異議提出而被移除。 伊凡一世 伊凡一世·丹尼洛维奇(钱袋)(Ива́н I Дани́лович Калита́,1288年—1340年3月31日),是莫斯科大公(约1325年-1340年3月31日在位),亚历山大·涅夫斯基幼子丹尼尔·亚历山德罗维奇�...

 

この存命人物の記事には、出典がまったくありません。信頼できる情報源の提供に、ご協力をお願いします。存命人物に関する出典の無い、もしくは不完全な情報に基づいた論争の材料、特に潜在的に中傷・誹謗・名誉毀損あるいは有害となるものはすぐに除去する必要があります。出典検索?: 手塚悠介 – ニュース · 書籍 · スカラー · CiNii �...

 

RunSingel oleh Vampire Weekenddari album ContraDirilis13 Desember 2010Genre Indie pop baroque pop afropop Durasi3:52LabelXLPencipta Rostam Batmanglij Ezra Koenig[1] ProduserRostam BatmanglijKronologi singel Vampire Weekend White Sky (2010) Run (2010) Diane Young (2013) Run adalah lagu oleh band indie asal Amerika Serikat, Vampire Weekend. Ini adalah single keenam dan terakhir dari album kedua mereka Contra, dan dirilis di Inggris pada 13 Desember 2010.[2] Tidak ada musik video...

Election for the governorship of the U.S. state of Ohio 1875 Ohio gubernatorial election ← 1873 October 12, 1875 1877 →   Nominee Rutherford B. Hayes William Allen Party Republican Democratic Popular vote 297,817 292,273 Percentage 50.25% 49.31% County resultsHayes:      40–50%      50–60%      60–70%      70–80%Allen:      50–6...

 

Former French subscription television company You can help expand this article with text translated from the corresponding article in French. (December 2023) Click [show] for important translation instructions. View a machine-translated version of the French article. Machine translation, like DeepL or Google Translate, is a useful starting point for translations, but translators must revise errors as necessary and confirm that the translation is accurate, rather than simply copy-pasting ...

 

British-German racialist philosopher (1855–1927) Houston Stewart ChamberlainChamberlain in 1886Born(1855-09-09)9 September 1855Southsea, Hampshire, EnglandDied9 January 1927(1927-01-09) (aged 71)Bayreuth, Bavaria, Weimar RepublicCitizenshipUnited KingdomGermanySpouses Anna Horst ​ ​(m. 1878; div. 1905)​ Eva von Bülow-Wagner ​ ​(m. 1908⁠–⁠1927)​ FatherWilliam Charles Chamberlain (1818...

This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: WLQQ – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2018) (Learn how and when to remove this message) This artic...

 

Compagnie des forges et aciéries de la marine et d'HomécourtIndustryIron and steel manufacturePredecessorCompagnie des Fonderies, Forges et Aciéries de Saint-Etienne FoundedSaint-Chamond, Loire, France (14 November 1854 (1854-11-14))HeadquartersSaint-Chamond, Loire, FranceProductsIron and steel The Compagnie des forges et aciéries de la marine et d'Homécourt (FAMH) (Company of marine forges and steelworks and of Homécourt) was a French industrial enterprise that made...