PROFILPELAJAR.COM

1996 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship final replay
Date	29 September 1996
Venue	Croke Park, Dublin
Man of the Match	Tommy Dowd
Referee	Pat McEnaney (Monaghan)
Attendance	65,802
	1997 →

1996 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship final
Event	1996 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship
Date	15 September 1996
Venue	Croke Park, Dublin
Man of the Match	Liam McHale
Referee	Pat McEnaney (Monaghan)
Attendance	65,898
	← 1995

The 1996 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship final was the 109th All-Ireland Final and the deciding match of the 1996 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship, an inter-county Gaelic football tournament for the top teams in Ireland. It went to a replay and was eventually won by Meath, with Mayo losing. Neither team was expected to make the final as the competition got underway; Meath were expected to lose to Carlow in their first game of the Leinster Senior Football Championship.^[1] However, it would be for the most significant breach of on-field discipline in the sport's history that the 1996 All-Ireland final would be remembered.^[1]

The brawl

Tommy Dowd got a goal and Brendan Reilly^[3] got the winning point but none of this matters: all is forgotten now apart from the infamous brawl which broke out over by the Cusack Stand in the shadow of Hill 16. Every man on the pitch soon found himself in the middle of the melee, apart from Meath's Brendan Reilly, Mayo goalkeeper John Madden and his full-back Kevin Cahill.^[1] Almost 30 players joined in a brawl that will go down in history as one of the worst ever seen at a GAA match.

Referee Pat McEnaney sought to punish those he deemed the worst offenders. He decided he would send off Mayo's Liam McHale and Meath's John McDermott. "When it all settled down my gut instinct was to send off McDermott with McHale. I had my mind made up on that", McEnaney later said.^[1]

Then he consulted with umpire Francie McMahon, who had witnessed something dreadful. "Pat," he said. "You're going to have to send off Colm Coyle. He's after dropping about six of them".^[1] One of the linesmen, Kevin Walsh, intervened to also highlight Coyle's indiscretions.^[1]

McEnaney sent off McHale and Coyle. McHale has never claimed not to have been involved in the brawl that day; indeed, he is on record as saying: "I was right in the middle right from the start".^[1] Coyle had arrived later.^[1]

The games

Ray Dempsey's 45th-minute goal gave Mayo a lead of six points; however, a Meath comeback, culminating in a last-minute Colm Coyle long-range point, saw the game end in a draw on a scoreline of 1–9 to 0–12.

The final ended in a draw, Meath getting last-minute point when Colm Coyle pumped the ball in that was allowed to bounce and ended up over the bar. As is customary, a replay followed. Meath won by a point, with goals by Trevor Giles (penalty) and Tommy Dowd.^[4] Meath's Mark O'Reilly was just a boy that day.^[5]

Brendan Reilly scored the winning point.^[2]

It was the first of two All-Ireland football titles for Meath that decade, followed by success in 1999.

This was the second consecutive All-Ireland Senior Football Championship Final replay in which at least at least one player sent off; Gerry McEntee was sent off in the 1988 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship Final replay.^[2]

Drawn game

Details

15 September 1996

15:30 IST (UTC+1)

Meath	0–12 – 1–9	Mayo
Trevor Giles 0–6, Brendan Reilly 0–3, Graham Geraghty 0–1, Colm Coyle 0–1, John McDermott 0–1		Maurice Sheridan 0–4, Ray Dempsey 1–0, James Horan 0–3, Colm McManamon 0–1, P. J. Loftus 0–1

Croke Park, Dublin

Attendance: 65,898

Referee: Pat McEnaney (Monaghan)

Meath

Mayo


1	Conor Martin
2	Mark O'Reilly
3	Darren Fay
4	Martin O'Connell
5	Colm Coyle
6	Enda McManus
7	Paddy Reynolds
8	Jimmy McGuinness
9	John McDermott
10	Trevor Giles
11	Tommy Dowd (c)
12	Graham Geraghty
13	Evan Kelly
14	Brendan Reilly
15	Barry Callaghan
Substitutes:
16	Ronan Finnegan
17	Jody Devine
18	Donal Curtis
19	Ollie Murphy
20	Kevin Cahill
21	Stephen O'Rourke
22	John Brady
23	Colm Brady
24	Cathal Sheridan
Manager:
Seán Boylan


1	John Madden
2	Kenneth Mortimer
3	Kevin Cahill
4	Dermot Flanagan
5	Pat Holmes
6	James Nallen
7	Noel Connelly (c)
8	Liam McHale
9	David Brady
10	James Horan
11	Colm McManamon
12	Maurice Sheridan
13	David Nestor
14	John Casey
15	Ray Dempsey
Substitutes:
16	Barry Heffernan
17	Peter Butler
18	Pat Fallon
19	Gary Ruane
20	Kevin O'Neill
21	Anthony Finnerty
22	P. J. Loftus
23	Michael Gardiner
24	Anthony McGarry
Manager:
John Maughan

Replay

Details

29 September 1996

15:30 IST (UTC+1)

Meath	2-9 – 1-11	Mayo
Trevor Giles 1–4, Tommy Dowd 1–3, Barry Callaghan 0–1, Brendan Reilly 0–1		Maurice Sheridan 0–5, James Horan 0–5, P. J. Loftus 1–0, John Casey 0–1

Croke Park, Dublin

Attendance: 65,802

Referee: Pat McEnaney (Monaghan)

Meath

Mayo


1	Conor Martin
2	Mark O'Reilly
3	Darren Fay
4	Martin O'Connell
5	Colm Coyle	SO
6	Enda McManus
7	Paddy Reynolds
8	Jimmy McGuinness
9	John McDermott
10	Trevor Giles
11	Tommy Dowd (c)
12	Graham Geraghty
13	Colm Brady
14	Brendan Reilly
15	Barry Callaghan
Substitutes:
16	Ronan Finnegan
17	Jody Devine
18	Evan Kelly
19	Donal Curtis
20	Ollie Murphy
21	Kevin Cahill
22	Stephen O'Rourke
23	John Brady
24	Cathal Sheridan
Manager:
Seán Boylan


1	John Madden
2	Kenneth Mortimer
3	Kevin Cahill
4	Dermot Flanagan
5	Pat Holmes
6	James Nallen
7	Noel Connelly (c)
8	Liam McHale	SO
9	David Brady
10	James Horan
11	Colm McManamon
12	Maurice Sheridan
13	Anthony Finnerty
14	John Casey
15	Ray Dempsey
Substitutes:
16	Barry Heffernan
17	Peter Butler
18	Pat Fallon
19	Gary Ruane
20	David Nestor
21	Tom Reilly
22	P. J. Loftus
23	Michael Gardiner
24	Anthony McGarry
Manager:
John Maughan

Post-match

Inaccurate stories spread afterwards that McEnaney had received hate mail at his home, but, McEnaney later said, the only letter he received (from a Meath supporter) praised McEnaney for how he had handled the brawl.^[1]

The teams did not meet again the championship until 2009.^[1]

McHale and McEnaney had not spoken, as of 2009.^[1]

References

^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h ⁱ ^j ^k ^l Keys, Colm (8 August 2009). "Thirteen years after infamous Mayo-Meath melee the shockwaves have not yet settled". Irish Independent. Independent News & Media. Retrieved 8 August 2009. The thing about the '96 final was that Meath and Mayo were so far off the radar that neither were expected to even contest their provincial finals, never mind an All-Ireland final in September... If Meath were reading the script in '96, they shouldn't have got past Carlow in the opening round in Leinster that summer... their semi-final dismissal of favourites Tyrone, when head injuries to Brian Dooher and Ciaran McBride and an ankle injury sustained by Peter Canavan led to accusations of a 'heavyhanded' approach... 'all hell broke loose', according to McHale... 'I was right in the middle right from the start'... Coyle was slow to get involved initially, but eventually did and made quite an impact with the officials watching on.
^ ^a ^b ^c Fogarty, John (12 September 2019). "Replay readings suggest this will be tight, with a busy referee". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 12 September 2019. In 1996, Colm Coyle and Liam McHale was ushered to the line following a mass brawl while in '88 Gerry McEntee was sent off early... Brendan O'Reilly lofted over the winner in 1996 and eight years previous it was a Colm O'Rourke point that gave Meath the cushion before Cork's late fight-back... Michael Fitzsimons (2016), Seamus Moynihan (2000) and Martin O'Connell (1988). Tommy Dowd was given the 1996 award but the honour has become the preserve of the defender.
^ "Royal welcome home for Meath team". The Irish Times. Retrieved 10 November 2020.
^ High Ball magazine, issue No. 6, 1998.
^ Mooney, Brendan (1999). "O'Reilly joins list of great Meath wing backs". Irish Examiner.^{[permanent dead link‍]}