關於這棵樹有各種各樣的傳說。一種常見的說法是,伯納德鎮(英语:Bernards Township, New Jersey)是紐澤西州三K黨的核心總部之一,自殖民時代以來,這棵樹就被用來私刑處死非裔美國人和叛逆的奴隸[2][3][4]。另一種說法是,一名農民在殺死家人後在樹上上吊自殺,任何試圖砍倒這棵樹的人都會「夭折」[5]。其他傳說稱,距離這棵樹太近的遊客會被一輛黑色福特皮卡車追趕,然後卡車會在某個時刻消失,或者任何觸摸這棵樹的人如果嘗試在餐館吃飯,就會發現自己的手變成黑色[4][6]。其中關於皮卡車的傳說,源自魔鬼樹是青少年測試勇氣的熱門地點,導致樹幹留下了塗鴉、燒傷、砍痕之類的損傷,曾有當地的一戶人家開著皮卡車趕走遊客,以保護這棵樹[7]。
^ 1.01.11.2Moran, Mark; Sceurman, Mark. Weird NJ: Your Travel Guide to New Jersey's Local Legends and Best-Kept Secrets. Barnes & Noble. 2003: 14-16. ISBN 978-1402766855.
^Day 81: The Devil's Tree. nj.com (New Jersey On-Line LLC). 2008-08-25 [2009-05-24]. (原始内容存档于2018-12-07). It is said that during colonial times, unruly slaves were hanged from the branch that runs almost parallel to the ground
^"Tales from the Devil's Tree", Weird NJ, May 2006.
^Nutt, Bill. Lost Souls: The Spirits of Central Jersey Live On. Courier News(英语:Courier News) (Gannett Company). 2001-10-07. If you put your hand on it, even in the dead of winter, the tree itself is warm.