The All-American Rejects självbetitlade debutalbum släpptes den 15 oktober 2002.

1. "My Paper Heart" – 3:49
2. "Your Star" – 4:21
3. "Swing, Swing" – 3:53
4. "Time Stands Still" – 3:31
5. "One More Sad Song" – 3:03
6. "Why Worry" – 4:17
7. "Don't Leave Me" – 3:28
8. "Too Far Gone" – 4:05
9. "Drive Away" – 3:00
10. "Happy Endings" – 4:25
11. "The Last Song" – 5:02
12. "The Cigarette Song" (bonusspår i Storbritannien) - 3:36

1. My Paper Heart
2. Swing, Swing
3. Time Stands Still
4. The Last Song

• The All-American Rejects - arrangör, art direction
• Laura Echler - A&R-assistans
• Michael Goldstone - A&R
• Dirk Hemsath - A&R
• Emily Lazar - mastering
• Tim O'Heir - producer, engineer, mixing
• Tyson Ritter - all sång, bas, slagverk
• Nick Wheeler - gitarrer, programmering
• Mike Kennerty - gitarr
• Chris Gaylor - trummor, slagverk

Album - Billboard (Nordamerika)

Singlar - Billboard (Nordamerika)