Allt om Naomi Kleins nakenchock

Allt om Naomi Kleins nakenchock
Naomi Klein med den polska utgåvan av Chockdoktrinen. Foto: Mariusz Kubik
Naomi Klein med den polska utgåvan av Chockdoktrinen. Foto: Mariusz Kubik
FörfattareJohan Norberg, Boris Benulic
Förlag för förstautgåvanVoltaire
Utgivningsår2008

Allt om Naomi Kleins nakenchock (ISBN 9197691763) är en bok av Johan Norberg och Boris Benulic från 2008, utgiven på Voltaire Publishing. Den är en kritik av boken Chockdoktrinen av den kanadensiska vänsterdebattören Naomi Klein.

Johan Norbergs del av boken inriktar sig på vad han anser är faktafel från Kleins sida. Norberg är kritisk till hur Milton Friedman framställs i boken och menar att Klein tagit citat ur sitt sammanhang för att tillskriva Friedman åsikter han aldrig haft. Norberg argumenterar till exempel för att Friedman var emot Irakkriget, vilket Klein hävdade att han stödde.[1] Norberg hävdar också att Klein förväxlat libertarianism med korporativism och neokonservatism.[2]

Norberg har även givit ut en kritik av Chockdoktrinen på engelska under titeln The Klein Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Polemics (Cato Institute). Denna rapport har översatts till spanska.[3]

Kritik mot boken

Lars Pålsson Syll, professor i nationalekonomi, skriver om boken: "I sin iver att ärerädda idolen/hjälten Friedman skyr Norberg inga som helst medel" och "den som hoppats på seriös kritik och analys blir snart besviken".[4] Tidningen Arbetaren menar att "det kvardröjande intrycket av Norbergs bok är den grova sexismen".

Naomi Klein har bestridit det mesta av kritiken av boken på sin hemsida.[5] I sin tur gav Johan Norberg svar på tal via Cato Institute ett par dagar efter Kleins inlägg via Cato Institute.[6]

Referenser

  1. ^ ”Timbro: Johan Norberg recenserar Kleins "Chockdoktrinen"”. Arkiverad från originalet den 24 december 2007. https://web.archive.org/web/20071224003537/http://www.timbro.se/text.aspx?id=212. 
  2. ^ ”Cato.org: Naomi Klein's The Shock Doctrine is based on shocking distortions”. Arkiverad från originalet den 12 februari 2009. https://web.archive.org/web/20090212071221/http://www.cato.org/pressroom.php?display=news&id=150. 
  3. ^ La doctrina Klein: El auge de la polémica del desastre, elcato.org
  4. ^ ”Vargarnas frihet leder till fårens död”. dn.se. 25 juni 2008. http://www.dn.se/arkiv/kultur/vargarnas-frihet-leder-till-farens-dod. Läst 19 april 2017. 
  5. ^ Klein, Naomi (2008), "One Year After the Publication of The Shock Doctrine, A Response to the Attacks" Arkiverad 10 november 2008 hämtat från the Wayback Machine., naomiklein.org 2 september. Läst 5 april 2009
  6. ^ "Three Days After Klein's Response, Another Attack" Uppladdat till www.cato.org: 4 September 2008: [1]

Externa länkar

v • r
Johan Norberg (f. 1973)
Böcker
Filmer
Relaterat

Read other articles:

Bank Ganesha

PT Bank Ganesha TbkJenisPublikKode emitenIDX: BGTGIndustriJasa keuanganDidirikan1991KantorpusatWisma Hayam Wuruk, Jakarta, IndonesiaTokohkunciLisawati (Presiden Direktur)ProdukperbankanPendapatanRp 388 miliar (2017), Rp 386 miliar (2018) Laba bersihRp 51 miliar (2017), Rp 5 miliar (2018) Karyawan308 orang (2018)Situs webwww.bankganesha.co.id Bank Ganesha merupakan perusahaan publik yang bergerak dalam bidang perbankan dan bermarkas di Jakarta, Indonesia. Perusahaan ini didirikan pada tahun 19...

 

Basilika Bunda Maria dari Penyelenggaraan, Poponguine

Basilika Bunda Maria dari PenyelenggaraanBasilika Minor Bunda Maria dari PenyelenggaraanPrancis: Basilique Notre-Dame de la DélivranceBasilika Bunda Maria dari PenyelenggaraanLokasiPopenguineNegaraSenegalDenominasiGereja Katolik RomaArsitekturStatusBasilika minorStatus fungsionalAktifAdministrasiKeuskupan AgungKeuskupan Agung Dakar Basilika Bunda Maria dari Penyelenggaraan (Prancis: Basilique Notre-Dame de la Délivrance) adalah sebuah gereja basilika minor Katolil yang terletak di P...

 

Makaka jepang

Monyet jepang[1] Macaca fuscata Rekaman Status konservasiRisiko rendahIUCN12552[2] TaksonomiKerajaanAnimaliaFilumChordataKelasMammaliaOrdoPrimatesFamiliCercopithecidaeGenusMacacaSpesiesMacaca fuscata (Blyth, 1875[3]) Tata namaEjaan asliInuus fuscatus ProtonimInuus fuscatus SubspesiesMacaca fuscata fuscata Macaca fuscata yakuiDistribusiPersebaran monyet jepang lbs Monyet jepang (Macaca fuscata) adalah salah satu spesies monyet dari familia Cercopithecidae yang endemik d...

Notre Dame Educational Association

Notre Dame Educational AssociationNotre Dame Educational AssociationTypeEducational AssociationEstablished1963Religious affiliationRoman CatholicPresidentSister Maria Fe Gerodias, RVMLocationTacurong City, Philippines CampusMultiple campusesMembersMarist (FMS), Oblates of Mary Immaculate (OMI), Augustinian Recollect Sisters (AR), Dominican Sisters of St. Catherine of Siena (OP), Oblates of Notre Dame (OND), Religious of the Virgin Mary (RVM), Sisters of Paul of Chartres (SPC), Sisters of the ...

 

Charles Edward Stuart

Charles Edward Stuart Charles Edward Louis John Casimir Silvester Maria Stuart (31 Desember 1720-31 Januari 1788) merupakan seorang pembuangan penuntut singgasana ke Inggris, Skotlandia, dan Irlandia, dan biasanya dipanggil Bonnie Prince Charlie. Charles merupakan putera dari James Francis Edward Stuart, dia dipecat saat Revolusi 1868. Dia meninggal dunia di Roma pada tahun 1788 Bibiliografi Frank J. MacLynn: Charles Edward Stuart: a tragedy in many acts, London [u.a.]: Routledge, 1988 Susan ...

 

Boris Zilber

British logician Boris ZilberZilber in Oberwolfach 2010Born1949 (age 74–75)Tashkent, UzbekistanAlma materNovosibirsk State UniversitySaint Petersburg State UniversityAwardsTarski Lectures (2002) Gödel Lecture (2003) Senior Berwick Prize (2004) Pólya Prize (2015)Scientific careerFieldsMathematics, Logic, Model theoryInstitutionsUniversity of OxfordThesis Groups and Rings with Categorical Theories  (1975)Doctoral advisorMikhail Taitslin Boris Zilber (Russian: Борис �...

Imogen Stuart

Irish sculptor (1927–2024) Imogen StuartImogen Stuart in 2011BornImogen Werner1927Berlin, GermanyDied24 March 2024(2024-03-24) (aged 96)Dublin, IrelandOccupationSculptorNotable work Stations of the Cross, wood, 1957, The Curragh Main Doors and Reliefs 1963–4, Galway Cathedral Altar carvings, Honan Chapel, 1988 Penal Cross, wood, 1988, Lough Derg Monument to Pope John Paul II, late 1980s[1] Portrait bust of Sean McBride, bronze, 1990 President Mary Robinson, bronze, 1998[2...

 

Phillipa Soo

American actress Phillipa SooSoo at the White House in 2016BornPhillipa Anne Soo (1990-05-31) May 31, 1990 (age 33)[1]Libertyville, Illinois, U.S.Other namesPippa SooEducationJuilliard School (BFA)OccupationsActresssingerYears active2012–presentSpouse Steven Pasquale ​(m. 2017)​ Phillipa Anne Soo[a] (born May 31, 1990) is an American actress and singer. Known for her leading roles on Broadway primarily in musicals, she has received...

 

Renegade (serie televisiva)

RenegadeTitolo originaleRenegade PaeseStati Uniti d'America Anno1992-1997 Formatoserie TV Generedrammatico, poliziesco Stagioni5 Episodi110 Durata42 min Lingua originaleinglese Rapporto16:9 CreditiIdeatoreStephen J. Cannell Interpreti e personaggi Lorenzo Lamas: Reno Raines/Vince Black Branscombe Richmond: Robert Bobby John Sixkiller Kathleen Kinmont: Cheyenne Phillips (st. 1-4) Sandra Ferguson: Sandy Carruthers (st. 5) Stephen J. Cannell: Tenente Donald Dutch Dixon Ron Johnson: Sergente ...

Pavlos Melas Museum

Military museum in Macedonia, GreecePavlos Melas MuseumΜουσείο Παύλου ΜελάOutside viewEstablished1970sLocation Melas, Macedonia, GreeceCoordinates40°42′14″N 21°15′54″E / 40.70383473894858°N 21.26487001817638°E / 40.70383473894858; 21.26487001817638TypeMilitary museum The Pavlos Melas Museum is located in the village of Melas, in the north part of the regional unit of Kastoria, Macedonia, Greece.[1] Description The building belonged ...

 

Administration for Security and Counterintelligence

Counterintelligence and security agency of North Macedonia Administration for Security and CounterintelligenceУправа за безбедност и контраразузнавање (УБК)Uprava za bezbednost i kontrarazuznavanje (UBK) Administrata për siguri dhe kundërzbulim (ASK)Agency overviewFormed1995[1]Preceding agenciesState Security AdministrationUDBADissolved2019JurisdictionWorldHeadquartersSkopje, North MacedoniaEmployeesClassifiedAnnual budgetClassifiedMinisters re...

 

Paper shredder

Device used to cut paper into pieces This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Paper shredder – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (May 2021...

Orcas Island

Largest of the San Juan Islands, in Washington state, USA Orcas IslandNickname: Gem of the San Juan IslandsLocation of Orcas Island in the San Juan IslandsOrcas IslandShow map of Washington (state)Orcas IslandShow map of the United StatesGeographyLocationPacific NorthwestCoordinates48°39′15″N 122°56′18″W / 48.65417°N 122.93833°W / 48.65417; -122.93833ArchipelagoSan Juan IslandsArea57.3 sq mi (148 km2)Highest elevation2,409 ft (734.3...

 

شريط بروكا القطري

هذه المقالة تحتاج للمزيد من الوصلات للمقالات الأخرى للمساعدة في ترابط مقالات الموسوعة. فضلًا ساعد في تحسين هذه المقالة بإضافة وصلات إلى المقالات المتعلقة بها الموجودة في النص الحالي. (مارس 2021) Diagonal band of Broca الاسم العلميstria diagonalis قاعدة الدماغ. (شريط بروكا القطري غير موصوف، ول...

 

Birchfield Ladbroke Stadium

For the Perry Barr Stadium, see Perry Barr Stadium. Former greyhound racing track in Birmingham Birchfield Ladbroke Stadium (old Perry Barr Stadium)LocationRegina Drive, Walsall Road, Birmingham, EnglandCoordinates52°31′06″N 1°54′18″W / 52.51833°N 1.90500°W / 52.51833; -1.90500ConstructionOpened1928Renovated1970Closed1984TenantsGreyhound racingBirmingham Brummies The Birchfield Ladbroke Stadium, also known as the old Perry Barr Greyhound Stadium or Alexande...

What's Up Superdoc!

1978 British film by Derek Ford What's Up Superdoc!Directed byDerek FordScreenplay byDerek FordProduced byMichael L. GreenStarringHarry H. CorbettChristopher MitchellMelvyn HayesJulia GoodmanHughie GreenBill PertweeAngela GrantChic MurrayBeth PorterSheila SteafelCinematographyGeoff GloverEdited byDavid CamplingMusic byFrank BarberPaul FishmanRelease date 21 March 1978 (1978-03-21) [1]Running time89 minutesCountryUnited KingdomLanguageEnglish What's Up Superdoc! is a 197...

 

Crawley, Western Australia

Suburb of Perth, Western AustraliaCrawleyPerth, Western AustraliaCrawley Edge BoatshedCoordinates31°59′10″S 115°49′19″E / 31.986°S 115.822°E / -31.986; 115.822Population3,975 (SAL 2021)[1]Postcode(s)6009Area1.4 km2 (0.5 sq mi)[2]Location5.8 km (4 mi) SW of the Perth CBDLGA(s)City of PerthState electorate(s)NedlandsFederal division(s)Curtin Suburbs around Crawley: Nedlands Kings Park Perth Nedlands Crawley Matil...

 

Gorka Elustondo

Gorka Elustondo Informasi pribadiNama lengkap Gorka Elustondo UrkolaTanggal lahir 18 Maret 1987 (umur 37)Tempat lahir Beasain, SpanyolTinggi 182 cm (6 ft 0 in)Posisi bermain Bek tengah, gelandang bertahanKarier junior Aitzgorri2004–2005 Real SociedadKarier senior*Tahun Tim Tampil (Gol)2005–2007 Real Sociedad B 64 (6)2006–2015 Real Sociedad 144 (7)2015–2017 Athletic Bilbao 13 (1)2017 Atlético Nacional 8 (0)2018–2019 Rayo Vallecano 19 (0)Tim nasional2006 Spanyol ...

Divination

Attempt to gain insight into a question or situation For other uses, see Divination (disambiguation). Divining redirects here. For pseudoscientific attempts to find water or other things, see Dowsing. Part of a series onAnthropology of religionThis man in Rhumsiki, Cameroon, attempts to tell the future by interpreting the changes in position of various objects as caused by a freshwater crab through the practice of nggàm.[1] Basic concepts Afterlife Animism Augury Communitas Comparati...

 

Bipin Chandra Joshi

17th Chief of Army Staff of the Indian Army GeneralBipin Chandra JoshiPVSM, AVSM, ADC16th Chief of the Army StaffIn office1 July 1990 – 30 June 1993PresidentRamaswamy VenkataramanShankar Dayal SharmaPrime MinisterV. P. SinghChandra ShekharP. V. Narasimha RaoPreceded bySunith Francis RodriguesSucceeded byShankar Roy Chowdhary Personal detailsBorn5 December 1935[1]Pithoragarh, United Provinces, British India (now Uttarakhand, India)Died19 November 1994(1994-11-19) (aged 58)New De...