Провокационный вопрос

Провокацио́нный вопро́с, или вопрос с зара́нее за́данным отве́том (англ. loaded question) — пример логической уловки; вопрос, в постановке которого заведомо содержится противоречивое, необоснованное или очевидно ложное предположение, которое существенно затрудняет получение на него прямого ответа («да» или «нет»)[1].

Как правило, подобные вопросы используются в качестве риторического инструмента, ставящего собеседника в тупик либо заставляющего его подтвердить или опровергнуть скрытое в вопросе утверждение, которое может быть ложным[2].

Классическим примером может служить провокационный вопрос «перестали ли вы бить свою жену?». Очевидно, что отвечая «да», собеседник невольно подтверждает, что ранее он избивал жену, а отвечая «нет», он утверждает, что избивает её до сих пор; при этом и то, и другое утверждение могут быть ложными. Впрочем, этот же вопрос, заданный при определённых обстоятельствах, уже не сможет считаться провокационным; например, если вышеуказанный вопрос задан не в ходе неформального общения, а во время судебного разбирательства, где муж сознался в избиениях жены[2].

См. также

Примечания

  1. ↑ Gregory Bassham (2004), Critical Thinking, McGraw-Hill, Архивировано из оригинала 31 августа 2018, Дата обращения: 3 октября 2017
  2. ↑ 1 2 Douglas N. Walton, Informal logic: a handbook for critical argumentation, Cambridge University Press, 1989, ISBN 0-521-37925-3, Google Print, p.36-37

Read other articles:

Bad Bramstedt

Bad Bramstedt Roland statue in Bad Bramstedt Lambang kebesaranLetak Bad Bramstedt di Segeberg NegaraJermanNegara bagianSchleswig-HolsteinKreisSegeberg Pemerintahan • MayorHans-Jürgen Kütbach (FDP)Luas • Total24,14 km2 (932 sq mi)Ketinggian9 m (30 ft)Populasi (2013-12-31)[1] • Total13.576 • Kepadatan5,6/km2 (15/sq mi)Zona waktuWET/WMPET (UTC+1/+2)Kode pos24576Kode area telepon04192Pelat kendaraanSESitu...

 

Arena Judo Olimpiade Los Angeles

Artikel ini sebatang kara, artinya tidak ada artikel lain yang memiliki pranala balik ke halaman ini.Bantulah menambah pranala ke artikel ini dari artikel yang berhubungan atau coba peralatan pencari pranala.Tag ini diberikan pada Februari 2023. Arena Judo Olimpiade Los Angeles dapat mengacu pada Arena yang digunakan untuk acara judo pada Olimpiade Los Angeles; Arena Eagle's Nest, digunakan pada Olimpiade Los Angeles 1984. Paviliun Pauley, digunakan pada Olimpiade Los Angeles 2028. Halaman di...

 

1928 United States presidential election in Minnesota

Main article: 1928 United States presidential election 1928 United States presidential election in Minnesota ← 1924 November 6, 1928 1932 →   Nominee Herbert Hoover Al Smith Party Republican Democratic Home state California New York Running mate Charles Curtis Joseph T. Robinson Electoral vote 12 0 Popular vote 560,977 396,451 Percentage 57.77% 40.83% County Results Hoover   40-50%   50-60%   60-70%   70-8...

Table tennis at the 2006 Asian Games

Table tennis at the 2006 Asian GamesVenueAl-Arabi Indoor HallDates29 November – 7 December 2006Competitors144 from 22 nations← 20022010 → Table Tennis was contested by men and women at the 2006 Asian Games in Doha, Qatar from November 29 to December 7. It was one of six sports to begin prior to the Opening Ceremonies on December 1. Singles, Doubles, and Team events were held with all competition taking place at the Al-Arabi Indoor Hall. Schedule P ...

 

Kebudayaan Longshan

Cangkir dari cangkang telur dari kebudayaan Longshan Kebudayaan Longshan (Hanzi sederhana: 龙山文化; Hanzi tradisional: 龍山文化; Pinyin: Lóngshān wénhuà; Wade–Giles: Lung-shan wen hua) adalah kebudayaan Neolitik akhir di Cina yang terpusat di bagian tengah dan hilir Sungai Kuning antara 3000 SM hingga 2000 SM. Kebudayaan ini dinamai menurut kota Longshan di bagian timur wilayah kota Jinan, Shandong, tempat penemuan arkeologis pertama (pada 1928) dan ekskavasi (p...

 

Exoplanetary Circumstellar Environments and Disk Explorer

Planned space telescope This article needs to be updated. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information. (February 2021) Exoplanetary Circumstellar Environments and Disk ExplorerMission typeSpace observatoryWebsitesoweb.as.arizona.edu/~gschneider/EXCEDE_OVERVIEW.htmlMission duration3 years nominal (proposed)[1] Orbital parametersReference systemGeocentricRegimeSun SynchronousSemi-major axis2,000 kmInclination105°Period127 min MainDi...

The 51st State

2001 film by Ronny Yu This article is about the film. For the hypothetical US state, see 51st state. For the song, see 51st State (song). The 51st StateTheatrical release posterDirected byRonny YuWritten byStel PavlouProduced by David Pupkewitz Malcolm Kohll Andras Hamori Mark Aldridge Starring Samuel L. Jackson Robert Carlyle Emily Mortimer Sean Pertwee Ricky Tomlinson Rhys Ifans Meat Loaf CinematographyPoon Hang-sangEdited byDavid WuMusic by Headrillaz Casper Kedros Darius Kedros Distribute...

 

コルク

この記事は検証可能な参考文献や出典が全く示されていないか、不十分です。出典を追加して記事の信頼性向上にご協力ください。（このテンプレートの使い方）出典検索?: コルク – ニュース · 書籍 · スカラー · CiNii · J-STAGE · NDL · dlib.jp · ジャパンサーチ · TWL（2017年4月） コルクを打ち抜いて作った瓶の栓 コルク（木栓、�...

 

Fujian Motors Group

Fujian Motors Group Logo Création 1992 Siège social Porvince de Fujian Chine Activité Automobile Produits Automobile Filiales Fujian Tractor Fujian Benz (50%) Soueast Motors (50%) King Long (13%) Site web www.fjmotor.com.cn modifier - modifier le code - voir Wikidata  Le Fujian Motors Group est un constructeur automobile basé dans la province du Fujian, en Chine et a été fondé en 1992. Les sociétés du groupe comprennent Fujian Tractor (fabricant de tracteurs et d'équipeme...

Daylight (Jimmy Barnes song)

1985 single by Jimmy Barnes DaylightSingle by Jimmy Barnesfrom the album Bodyswerve B-side Paradise Resurrection Shuffle (live) (Limited edition side two only) ReleasedJanuary 1985StudioRhinoceros StudiosLabelMushroomSongwriter(s)Jimmy BarnesProducer(s)Jimmy Barnes, Mark OpitzJimmy Barnes singles chronology Promise Me You'll Call (1984) Daylight (1985) I'd Die to Be with You Tonight (1985) Alternative coverLimited edition cover Daylight is a song by Australian rock musician, Jimmy Barnes. Rel...

 

Рассеянный склероз

Эту статью предлагается удалить.Пояснение причин и соответствующее обсуждение вы можете найти на странице Википедия:К удалению/24 сентября 2022.Пока процесс обсуждения не завершён, статью можно попытаться улучшить, однако следует воздерживаться от переименований или нем...

 

England Lions cricket team

Second-tier national team England Lions cricket teamPersonnelOwnerEngland and Wales Cricket Board (ECB)Team informationFounded1982Official websiteOfficial Website The England Lions (formerly England A) cricket team is England and Wales' second-tier team, below the full England cricket team. It is largely intended as a way for promising young cricketers to gain experience of playing international cricket. England B and England A Although primarily intended as a touring team, for several years ...

Querida Amazonia

Querida AmazoniaSpanish : Amazon tercintaSurat ensiklik dari Paus Fransiskus Tanggal02 Februari 2020 (2020-02-02)ArgumenUntuk wilayah Pan-AmazonNomor ensiklik5 dari 7 dari kepausanNaskahDalam bahasa Inggris←Christus vivit Laudate Deum → Querida Amazonia (Amazonia Tercinta) adalah anjuran apostolik dari Paus Fransiskus pasca-sinode tahun 2020, yang ditulis sebagai tanggapan terhadap Sinode Para Uskup untuk wilayah Pan-Amazon diadakan di Roma pada bulan Oktober 2019. Berfokus pada wila...

 

جزء محجري للعظم الجبهي

الجزء المحجري للعظم الجبهي الاسم العلميpars orbitalis ossis frontalis السطح الخارجي من العظم الجبهي. الجزء المحجري الثالث من الأسفل السطح الداخلي من العظم الجبهي. الجزء المحجري الثالث من الأسفلالسطح الداخلي من العظم الجبهي. الجزء المحجري الثالث من الأسفل تفاصيل جزء من عظم جبهي  معر�...

 

2022 Tour de France, Stage 12 to Stage 21

The 2022 Tour de France is the 109th edition of the Tour de France. It started in Copenhagen, Denmark on 1 July[1] and ended with the final stage at Champs-Élysées, Paris on 24 July.[2] Classification standings Legend Denotes the leader of the general classification Denotes the leader of the mountains classification Denotes the leader of the points classification Denotes the leader of the young rider classification Denotes the leader of the team classification Denotes the w...

One-way traffic

Traffic that moves in a single direction One way road redirects here. For other uses, see One Way Road (disambiguation). One way street redirects here. For the 1950 film, see One Way Street. One-way system redirects here. For the band, see One Way System. One-way street sign in New York City No trucks over 5 tons, nonstandard lettering Cullom Ave, One way signs in Chicago, Illinois One-way traffic (or uni-directional traffic) is traffic that moves in a single direction. A one-way street is a ...

 

List of programs broadcast by The WB

This article may require cleanup to meet Wikipedia's quality standards. The specific problem is: Needs cleanup per WP:NOTTVGUIDE. Please help improve this article if you can. (January 2024) (Learn how and when to remove this message) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: List of programs broadcast by The WB – news �...

 

BRITA-Arena

Questa voce sull'argomento stadi di calcio della Germania è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. BRITA-Arena Informazioni generaliStato Germania UbicazioneWiesbaden Inizio lavori2007 Inaugurazione11 ottobre 2007 Costo16 milioni € ProprietarioBrita Informazioni tecnichePosti a sedere12 560 Mat. del terrenoErboso Uso e beneficiariCalcio Wehen Wiesbaden Mappa di localizzazione Modifica dati su Wikidata · Manuale La BRITA-A...

2006 Swedish general election

2006 Swedish general election ← 2002 17 September 2006 2010 → ← outgoing memberselected members →All 349 seats in the Riksdag175 seats needed for a majority   First party Second party Third party   Leader Göran Persson Fredrik Reinfeldt Maud Olofsson Party Social Democrats Moderate Centre Alliance The Alliance (Sweden) The Alliance Last election 144 55 22 Seats won 130 97 29 Seat change 14 42 7 Popular vote 1,942,625 ...

 

Dammar gum

Tree resin obtained from the family Dipterocarpaceae Dammar resin Dammar, also called dammar gum, or damar gum, is a resin obtained from the tree family Dipterocarpaceae in India and Southeast Asia, principally those of the genera Shorea or Hopea (synonym Balanocarpus). The resin of some species of Canarium may also called dammar. Most is produced by tapping trees; however, some is collected in fossilised form on the ground. The gum varies in colour from clear to pale yellow, while the fossil...