Rob Doyle of The Observer called Carrère "a great pornographer of his own torments" and his books "wantonly self-referential", and wrote that despite the disparate material that Yoga contains, Carrière turns it into an insightful story.[1]
Upon the French publication, the book created discussions as Carrère's ex-wife Hélène Devynck [fr] accused him of violating a legal agreement to not write about her in his books. This led to discussions about how much the content in Yoga diverged from Carrère's real experiences due to all instances where he had removed material about his marriage.[2] Randy Rosenthal of the Los Angeles Times wrote that the omissions leave "a black hole" at the book's centre that becomes "an unforgivable flaw".[3]