↓ Skip to lists ↓ Shortcuts WP:GANWP:GAN WP:GACWP:GAC A good article nomination (GAN) is a Wikipedia article that is to be evaluated against the good...

Documentation[view] [edit] [history] [purge] Example: {{Wikipedia:Good article criteria/GAC|1a}} yields: the prose is clear, concise, and understandable to an appropriately...

Reporting statistics of link gac-corp.com; 0 records. gac-corp.com: Linksearch en (insource) - meta - de - fr - simple - wikt:en - wikt:fr • Spamcheck...

‎ The result was delete. MBisanz talk 03:53, 14 November 2012 (UTC) Ian Gac (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)...

this article: Articles for deletion/Brocagh Emmetts GAC Articles for deletion/Brocagh Emmetts GAC (2nd nomination) [Hide this box] New to Articles for...

Example: {{Wikipedia:Good article criteria/GAC|1a}} yields: the prose is clear, concise, and understandable to an appropriately broad audience; spelling...

Reporting statistics of link gac.edu; 0 records. gac.edu: Linksearch en (insource) - meta - de - fr - simple - wikt:en - wikt:fr • Spamcheck • blacklist...

result was delete. MBisanz talk 01:41, 6 June 2016 (UTC) Zhengzhou Esli GAC (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)...

The result was delete. Nakon 23:29, 10 April 2015 (UTC) Brocagh Emmetts GAC (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)...

page.‎ The result was keep. LFaraone 05:14, 17 May 2013 (UTC) All Saints GAC (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)...

let it be written So let it be done 01:19, 15 August 2015 (UTC) Ardmore GAC (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)...

Bessbrook bombing in Omagh, Northern Ireland. Geograph Aghaloo O'Neills GAC in or near Omagh, Northern Ireland. Geograph Ballygawley bus bombing in Omagh...

Fianna GAC in Dungannon, Northern Ireland. Geograph Derrylaughan Kevin Barrys GAC in Dungannon, Northern Ireland. Geograph Derrytresk Fir An Chnoic GAC in...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

required a peer view and a failed GAC/FLC.—Chris! ct 02:10, 29 September 2008 (UTC) Right. I suggest submitting to GAC and if it fails because the subject...

with the exception of The Principal and the Pauper, which is currently a GAC. -- Scorpion0422 23:33, 26 January 2008 (UTC) Co-nominators: Xihix, Gran2...

a current GAC, I don't think this should also be considered at Peer Review. I don't know if there is a formal prohibition, but I think GACs and FACs ought...

with the exception of The Principal and the Pauper, which is currently a GAC. -- Scorpion0422 23:33, 26 January 2008 (UTC) Co-nominators: Xihix, Gran2...

District Council in Cookstown, Northern Ireland. Geograph Cookstown Fr. Rock's GAC in Cookstown, Northern Ireland. Geograph Cookstown High School in Cookstown...

and studio of American architect Frank Lloyd Wright. I hope to take it to GAC and perhaps even FAC in the future, but its been a loooong time (six years)...

will require only three "hits" on the Wikipedia server: one to retrieve the GAC page, a second to write a results page after processing, and a third to update...

important) and GAC is an acronym for the criteria. By deprecation, I mean that editors should be encouraged to replace raw occurences of "WP:GAC" by piped...

Douglas Bridge in Strabane, Northern Ireland. Geograph Dregish Pearse Og GAC in Strabane, Northern Ireland. Geograph Finn Park in or near Strabane, Northern...

Eoghan GAC (2022 PROD) Brocagh Emmetts GAC (2022 Afd) Naomh Colum Cille GAC (2022 PROD) Duiche Neill GAC, Benburb (2022 PROD) Strabane Shamrocks GAC (2022...

municipalities of France have been edited in a semi-automatic way by User:Gac and uploaded by User:Gac and User:Paginazero. The municipalities of China have been uploaded...

deletion (glossary) Help, my article got nominated for deletion! List of GAC vehicles with joint venture (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links |...

(UTC) Once the article was made, I put it up for GAC and I been waiting ever since. (Honestly, I believe GAC is slow, since I have an article there from the...

football club is [[CLUB GAC|CLUB]]. CLUB has won the [[COUNTY Senior Football Championship]] on fifteen occasions. [[CLUB GAC|CLUB]] has won the COUNTY...

article at GAC and FAC at the same time? SandyGeorgia (Talk) 16:43, 18 April 2007 (UTC) Sorry, nominated for GAC before FAC and forgot to remove GAC nomination...

(UTC) Taking over the award-giving task of the project coordinator in the GAC backlog elimination drive showed a terrible lack of judgement.[1] Prematurely...

Mirzazade leading the first panel. GAC: The Grants Advisory Committee is calling for applications. According to the call, "The GAC are community volunteers who...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyeditors are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

between the FDC for eligible chapters and the Grant Advisory Committee (GAC) for other chapters and affiliated groups. Individual engagement grants (IEGs)...

contribs) To re/assess articles to its proper class To send articles to WP:GAC or WP:FAC if needed. Assess articles listed in Category:Unassessed rail transport...

UserReport - it:Special:Contributions/Mennato. 09:43:40, Sat Oct 06, 2007 it:user:Gac <-> senato.it (27%/12.5%/3.3% - Monitored link www.senato.it/japp/bgt/showdoc/showtext...

I have undertaken in the last few weeks , I now feel a GAC is due. This will be my second GAC and one that I have thoroughly enjoyed working on. I would...

The article is now nominated for WP:GAC. Though the GAC reviewers have not commented about copyediting, the issue is sooner or latter going to be raised...

Plaza from Cloud Gate due to complaints at WP:FAC. I will post both at WP:GAC and see how they are received.--TonyTheTiger (t/c/bio/WP:CHICAGO/WP:LOTM)...

three GACs out of 40 selected articles/biographies. — Crisco 1492 (talk) 10:13, 2 September 2012 (UTC) Sudirman has been promoted, leaving two GACs of 40...

criteria perspective. You'll want to come back for an FAC review once it passes GAC. Lead Your writing has a lot of adverbs like "originally" "primarily" "mainly"...

2011 (UTC) Come by and help us prepare as many articles as possible for WP:GAC and WP:FAC. Whether or not you can come, you can still encourage other available...

review is a good idea; I was exposed to GAC and the review process by submitting the articles I worked on to GAC and seeing how other editors did it. Then...

may have to wait ages, I suggest GAC. Alientraveller 16:07, 14 May 2007 (UTC) And thus one could almost nominate at GAC, then proceed to make better a given...

copyedit. Daniel 02:41, 29 November 2007 (UTC) Phanto282 (talk · contribs) Lindsay Hassett WP:GAC: Ian Craig and Brian Booth Our future featured topic:...

The article has repeatedly failed GAC because of the grammar, as it was written by non-native English speakers. I feel the article would benefit greatly...

of Featured and Good material? TonyTheTiger: I have reviewed a lot of WP:GACs for the project. Many of these have been promoted (Grey's Anatomy, 24, Sesame...

I've listed this article for peer review because it is close to being a WP:GAC and would like additional edits/comments it to that level. Thanks, RyguyMN...

stays for at least that time, to give the Campus article time to go through GAC, and hopefully academics at least nom'd. If we can get all but spartans up...

at Wikipedia:WikiProject League of Copyeditors/proofreading#Requests for GAC and GAR articles. For articles that do not meet the above criteria, requests...

Geograph Carnlough Fault in Ballymena, Northern Ireland. Geograph Clooney Gaels GAC in Ballymena, Northern Ireland. Geograph Crosskeys Inn in Ballymena, Northern...

stays for at least that time, to give the Campus article time to go through GAC, and hopefully academics at least nom'd. If we can get all but spartans up...

Ballinderry Shamrocks GAC (May 2008) Greenlough GAC (May 2008) Limavady GAC (May 2008) Newbridge GAC (May 2008) Seán Dolans GAC (May 2008) Antrim GAA...

Shortcuts WP:GANWP:GAN WP:GACWP:GAC A good article nomination (GAN) is a Wikipedia article that is to be evaluated against the good article criteria in...

nominate the article at GAC now seeing that most of the problems seem easy to fix and we should try to get ahead of the GAC backlog. - Caribbean~H.Q...

few, and maybe submit it to GAC instead- I'm looking for something like 40, not 6. --01:36, 4 September 2006 (UTC) What's "GAC" -- please don't use acronyms...

—Celithemis 01:08, 25 September 2006 (UTC) Very nice! I think it will pass GAC. "Literary portraits" seemed a bit listy too me-I think pure prose would...

5%/50%/31.2% - calculated overlap Derry Boi <-> derrygaa.ie) - en:Ardmore_GAC - diff (undo) - COIBot UserReport - en:Special:Contributions/Derry_Boi. 23:15:28...

flag) and to get rid of the three citation needed tags. If I saw this on GAC today I'd leave a note on the talk page to address those details and invite...

this system. Instead, an article must be reviewed first at WP:FAC or WP:GAC. A-Class assessments are not currently used by WikiProject Pharmacology....

or not editing the page it will take a while but the article should be at GAC in around two weeks after Puerto Rican Amazon is nominated, thanks a lot...

listed this article for peer review because I'd like to get it up toward GAC and then FAC. I had briefly submitted it (I guess ahead of schedule) to FAC...

for peer review because I am planning to take it to WP:GAC. This article would be my third GAC attempt. Feel free to construct and edit the article. Thanks...

Aaron north (T/C) 05:51, 7 December 2010 (UTC) This article was failed at WP:GAC in violation of WP:WIAGA. The reviewer statesd that the article was failed...

September 2007 (UTC) Ah, well, then I'll support upon the live album passing GAC (which I'm confident it will). NSR77 TC 23:52, 2 September 2007 (UTC) Weak...

Ardtrea North in Magherafelt, Northern Ireland. Geograph Ballinascreen GAC in Magherafelt, Northern Ireland. Geograph Ballynagalliagh in Magherafelt,...

considerable amounts of content seem to be WP:UNDUE. I think compliance with GAC#3b would be obtained with some trimming of low-relevance info, esp. in the...

on quotes. I don't mind too much, and I can't see it being a problem for GAC, but something to think on. "Lyrically, the song talks" That's not what "lyrically"...

try. So I'd probably oppose its inclusion until it either passes a GAC, or fails a GAC for this very reason. But yes, I'd agree that the two demos and the...

March 2007 (UTC) Sent to GAC to get more comments. Titoxd(?!? - cool stuff) 22:16, 16 March 2007 (UTC) I removed it from GAC and sent it to FAC, as I...

I've listed this article for peer review because I'd like to see it as a GAC. I think this article is ready but I need additional input to pass. Thanks...

Hi! I want to put this article up for WP:GAC soon and would greatly appreciate someone with an eye for 'good English' taking a look at it. I'm pretty...

review is a good idea; I was exposed to GAC and the review process by submitting the articles I worked on to GAC and seeing how other editors did it. Then...

April 2010 (UTC) Comments by H1nkles I think the article is ready for WP:GAC. I'll make a couple of suggestions but for the most part I think it's pretty...

benefit from an objective review, with the view to eventual submission to WP:GAC. -- Ohc ¡digame! 07:16, 13 January 2014 (UTC) Thanks,  Ohc ¡digame! 07:16...

Bright Halt railway station in Down, Northern Ireland. Geograph Bryansford GAC in Down, Northern Ireland. Geograph Castleward Forest in Down, Northern Ireland...

or at the very least-acceptable, fashion. I've been to WP:CVG/PR and WP:GAC, and tried to address all their concerns, though I'm not always the best...

Cycling Trinity Racing Team Sky Team UK Youth Rapha Condor-Sharp Team Raleigh-GAC Node 4-Giordana Racing Team IG-Sigma Sport Madison-Genesis ANC-Halfords Cycling...

Ireland. Geograph Bendooragh in Ballymoney, Northern Ireland. Geograph Dunloy GAC in Ballymoney, Northern Ireland. Geograph Leitrim, County Antrim in Ballymoney...

review/Charles Manson/archive1 This article was recently put up for a WP:GAC nom, which caused a flurry of editing activity and discussion on the talk...

(edit | history) · Watch • Watch peer review References : First PR, FAC, GAC This article is suffering from the The Man, His Son, And the Donkey syndrome...

2007 (UTC) Proofread by Finetooth (talk) – 05:54, 13 December 2007 (UTC) <GAC written by a non-native speaker. English language expert read through and...

I list it at WP:GAC. Thanks in advance! PC78 22:26, 9 June 2007 (UTC) Comment It surpasses GA standard and should be submitted to GAC right now. LuciferMorgan...

writing isn't my greatest skill, so I'd very much appreciate if an experienced copyeditor took a look. It's currently a GAC. JACOPLANE • 2007-09-24 13:22...

Basic paragraph-forming is required at the GAC reviewer's recommendation. WBOSITG (talk)...

GAC reviewer requested a copyedit; the principal author (me) is not a native English speaker.--Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus| talk 05:16, 27 March...

closed. I've listed this article for peer review because its been a two time GAC and one FAC but failed. I am hoping to take the article to FA level. Thanks...

I would like this to be copyedited because there is a lot of text and some of it may be worded wrong. It is currenntly a GAC....

Tasks Unreferenced BLPs Departments Assessment Things to do FAC: FAR: FARC: GAC: GAR: Article statistics This list is generated automatically every night...

GAC written by a non-native speaker. English language expert read through and possible style corrections would be appreciated.  Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul...

I'm placing this request with the League because the article is a GAC, and needs to meet WP:MOS better than it currently does. Thank you. Macduffman (talk)...

article, which I've been working on for quite some time, finally passed GAC. Candide is on its way to FAC, and I'd like your input before I nominate...

promoted to GA back in 2007. However, it was soon delisted due to failing the GAC and relisted in 2009 and then delisted yet again for sourcing problems in...

article has had more work done on it since its last peer review, FLC, & GAC. I would like to know if it's finally ready for anything. Thanks, Voices...

external native English speaker copy-editor (as I almost always do!). For GAC ... I do not know any more! Link properly your online sources. Check Template:Cite...

approaching WP:GAC. Then another peer review before approaching FAC again. SandyGeorgia (Talk) 15:37, 8 April 2007 (UTC) You sure about recommending GAC Sandy...

This concludes my review. Please consider reviewing an article here or a WP:GAC to alleviate the ever-present backlog. If you have specific questions please...

well referenced with expand dates included and is well watched. Current at GAC, but this may take a while and I don't see it as a bar to its nomination/passing...

WP:GAC. I intended to and thought I did, however, so I appreciate your listing it for me. I also hope it gets a review soon, but you're right about GAC,...

At the behest of a GAC reviewer, I look for a "third party" to copyedit this article before it is re-nominated. I am too close to the article, having...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

December 2007 (UTC) Proofread by Galena11 (talk) – 19:11, 5 February 2008 (UTC) GAC written mainly by non-native speakers. A check by an experienced English...

like a newspaper headline, but maybe that's fine. After expanding the lead, I would consider WP:GAC. -- bcasterline • talk 17:39, 6 September 2006 (UTC)...

further edits should be made to this discussion. The article just passed GAC and I think that it is up to A-class level. All comments appreciated. Kyriakos...

I would like to be able to get this to be able to be nominated as a WP:GAC. Thanks, Clarkcj12 (talk) 18:57, 4 December 2013 (UTC) This article needs...

injunction was sought to prevent our GAC dealing with the matter, all for the very same reasons, i.e., that the council's GAC acted correctly and in a fair and...

a nice article here and I commend you for your work to bring this to WP:GAC. I'll give feedback based on the GA Criteria. Lead The lead needs to comply...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

needs inline citations per WP:CITE and WP:FOOTNOTES, if you intend to go for GAC or FAC.--Yannismarou 21:26, 15 January 2007 (UTC) Please see automated peer...

other articles will be added. (I currently have two more MA-articles at GAC.) I mean that with a large topic such as this, and with Angelou continuing...

Individuals and smaller organizations could rely on two other schemes: the GAC-backed Wikimedia grant program and participation grants. However, no comparable...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

passed an individual audit for quality." - My Sister, My Sitter did fail its GAC because of limited content, so wouldn't it be excuseable? -- Scorpion0422...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

passing the corresponding candidacy WP:FAC for Featured Article class, and WP:GAC for Good Article class. The complete level breakdown is explained in detail...

a big deal, and we have no pictures of the event? This article fails WP:GAC #s 3 and 6. – Muboshgu (talk) 01:01, 28 November 2018 (UTC) 100% agree, this...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

a bit on the album on Jessica Andrews GAC biography page. http://www.gactv.com/gac/ar_artists_a-z/article/0,,GAC_26071_4885839,00.html Does this help?...

irc-online.org/fpif/pdf/gac/0211power.pdf www.whitehouse.gov/nsc/nss.pdf www.state.gov/p/inl/rls/fs/47759.htm www.irc-online.org/fpif/pdf/gac/0211power.pdf www...

passed an individual audit for quality." - My Sister, My Sitter did fail its GAC because of limited content, so wouldn't it be excuseable? -- Scorpion0422...

stubby. Expand it or merge it with "Early Years" (I'd also suggest that for GAC). "He then studied at Sidney Sussex College, Cambridge, which was then a...

Tasks Unreferenced BLPs Departments Assessment Things to do FAC: FAR: FARC: GAC: GAR: Article statistics This list is generated automatically every night...

article, and where you think I should go from here, whether it be WP:FAC, WP:GAC, or more work. Thanks for your input. Cirt 16:28, 26 October 2007 (UTC)....

your input be heard, and perhaps think about giving us a hand over at WP:GAC (the history area in general could use help). I wouldn't say do some RCp...

This article has been thrice rejected at WP:GAC. Critical review would be appreciated. TonyTheTiger (talk/cont/bio/tcfkaWCDbwincowtchatlotpsoplrttaDCLaM)...

have relisted back the article at WP:GAC. Now, my question is: what editors would do? Nominate the article at WP:GAC or here as GA COTW? If you want to...

review is a good idea; I was exposed to GAC and the review process by submitting the articles I worked on to GAC and seeing how other editors did it. In...

three GACs out of 40 selected articles/biographies. — Crisco 1492 (talk) 10:13, 2 September 2012 (UTC) Sudirman has been promoted, leaving two GACs of 40...

Quality=C to Quality=FA, and I agree with Funkmonk. It would benefit from a WP:GAC review first, which is still a major achievement in itself. The article attracts...

Withdrawn by nominator. Redrose64 (talk) 13:28, 28 June 2016 (UTC) WP:GACWP:GAC → Wikipedia:Good article nominations  (links · history ·...

impression. By and large, in my opinion, this would automatically fail the WP:GAC in its current state. Some of the most noticeable issues: The lead is very...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

here. Thanks, APR t 23:29, 10 May 2007 (UTC) Why don't you nominate it for GAC before you try for FA again? I can see two citation needed tags. And the...

review is a good idea; I was exposed to GAC and the review process by submitting the articles I worked on to GAC and seeing how other editors did it. Then...

It shouldn't be much trouble to add it later, but for now, Saomai's on GAC. --Coredesat talk! 00:26, 18 September 2006 (UTC) Given that it's a few months...

Geograph Slieve True in Newtownabbey, Northern Ireland. Geograph St Enda's GAC in Newtownabbey, Northern Ireland. Geograph Whitehouse Primary School in...

this could be a problem for FAC; I do not think it is a major problem for GAC. Since you have "References", there is no reason to have all these details...

that it's a good idea; I was exposed to GAC and the review process by submitting the articles I worked on to GAC and seeing how other editors did it. In...

the citations at the end of the sentences. As a conclusion, I believe that the article will easily pass GAC.--Yannismarou 11:32, 5 February 2007 (UTC)...

this simply is not ready for FAC; indeed, I would not pass this article at GAC in its current state. The first thing that jumps out as a problem is the...

(UTC) Once the article was made, I put it up for GAC and I been waiting ever since. (Honestly, I believe GAC is slow, since I have an article there from the...

Archived discussion. Current status: {{GA-Class}} So, GAC has stalled, and the peer review hasn't been necessarily elucidating for this article. What...

2018 (UTC) The articles themselves are all very short, and already passed GAC. I can take another look and verify they summarized the articles well. Kees08...

best I can do is state what my concerns are, and perhaps guess what the GAC reviewer will look at. Very likely, he'll take the technical aspects quite...

their plot sections so this should be added before you take the article to GAC. Not knowing the game at all I have no suggestions for additional information...

This is a failed WP:GAC. I would like further critical review before renominating. TonyTheTiger (talk/cont/bio/tcfkaWCDbwincowtchatlotpsoplrttaDCLaM)...

review in question is apparently reproduced from a defunct website called GAC, what was that exactly? Devonian Wombat (talk) 21:39, 2 April 2020 (UTC)...

by H1nkles All I'll say regarding this is that prior to nominating at WP:GAC you may want to add a bit about the French performance at this year's world...

the points raised in the previous peer review. Before submitting it as a GAC or FAC, I'd like one more round of comments to try to make that process go...

Much of its work has been done in the last month or so and having passed WP:GAC, I would like to know what more can be added, if applicable. Thanks, Lemonade51...

passing the corresponding candidacy WP:FAC for Featured Article class, and WP:GAC for Good Article class. The complete level breakdown is explained in detail...

20:15, 14 February 2007 (UTC) Comment - You're supposed to go in order at GAC, but you technically don't have to, so, as I'm not affiliated with WP:TROPIC...

of the last century (kidding!)! The article is good and well-placed for GAC. My major concern is its length. it is a bit short. But I suppose FACs are...

19 November 2007 (UTC) Who are you to say it is? It's in the middle of a GAC, it's currently undergoing a huge rewrite. We've both been working on the...

GAC. That was done by User:Dom497. You still might not be able to support/oppose it but I just wanted to point out that you didn't review it for GAC.--...

fr.wikipedia, needs to be copyedited. Update: The article is now up for GAC and peer review. Awadewit (talk) 12:38, 3 August 2008 (UTC) Update: This...

personally done; I am sending the article about the national constitution to GAC right now and I am working up the article on capital punishment in the country...

1 January 2009 (UTC) FYI I just nominated Washington Park Subdivision at GAC.--TonyTheTiger (t/c/bio/WP:CHICAGO/WP:LOTM) 03:37, 1 January 2009 (UTC) FYI...

August 2019 (UTC) I finished improving Fred Rogers for GAC! The goal was to at least get it through GAC before the Tom Hanks movie comes out in November, since...

career section has not been updated since 2018. I believe it is an immediate GAC fail since it needs a large update tag. BinaryBrainBug (talk) 19:31, 11 March...

the fair use ones, possibly the Fran Katzenjammer one. But everything is referenced so it probably would pass a GAC. Gran2 14:56, 17 June 2007 (UTC)...

current GAC candidate, and we all know that the two processes rarely offer advise that overlaps. I think it better to close this early and let the GAC run...

com/aerlingus-drm/?_ga=2.90639770.1040053395.1546131346-914607577.1544422097&_gac=1.141902342.1546131346.EAIaIQobChMI-ZDRiKzG3wIVTdbACh0cIwgeEAAYASAAEgKQW_D_BwE...

The Good Article Collaboration of the week works to polish already good articles to the highest of standards. This week's improvement drive is Elvis Presley:...

Username (talk) 05:08, 6 December 2007 (UTC) The article was copyedited as a GAC. After it passed GA, the editors nominated it for FA, received feedback,...

Tasks Unreferenced BLPs Departments Assessment Things to do FAC: FAR: FARC: GAC: GAR: Article statistics This list is generated automatically every night...

detailed list. I think the article needs a bit of work before it could be considered for nomination at WP:GAC. - Shudde talk 23:36, 15 February 2008 (UTC)...

Similar to trying to nominate something at WP:GAC with loads of {{citeneeded}} problems - the WP:GAC process even has "quick fail criteria" specifically...

some unsourced paragraphs and sections. Thus, it fails criteria 2 of the GAC. Spinixster (chat!) 08:07, 15 June 2023 (UTC) The discussion above is closed...

in its entirety and hope to take it to FAC in due time. It's currently at GAC and any comments would be appreciated. Thanks, M3tal H3ad (talk) 11:57, 9...

attention. Article has now been through WP:MILHIST peer review, and is up for GAC. I don't think the citations or factual statements need editing now, but...

and several paragraphs without citations, which fails criteria 2 of the GAC. There may also be some prose problems like unrelated information. Spinixster...

Championship final 2010 Leinster Senior Football Championship final All Saints GAC Pádraig Amond Battle of Omagh Breffni Park Paul Callaghan (Gaelic footballer)...

leftover, so once they're resolved, and the article I have languishing at GAC is reviewed, I'd like to submit it to FAC. Whoo hoo! Christine (Figureskatingfan)...

expansion pack articles exist. I'm looking for any improvements before I go to GAC. Thoughts?--Clyde (talk) 04:23, 11 March 2007 (UTC) I would like to first...

budget, advised in turn by the volunteers of the Grant Advisory Committee (GAC), will allocate $400k in 2012–13 to support organizations and individuals...

17 August - tweeted Clare Palmer - 13 August ( 17 September; nominated at GAC) Josephine Donovan - 12 August Elizabeth Barnes - 28 November (improved as...

2007 (UTC) Proofread by Finetooth (talk) – 03:29, 17 December 2007 (UTC) GAC written mostly by a non-native speakers. English language expert read through...

Crevenish Castle in Fermanagh, Northern Ireland. Geograph Derrygonnelly Harps GAC in Fermanagh, Northern Ireland. Geograph Derrylin in Fermanagh, Northern...

resulted in holes and insufficient broadness. I have concerns with the lead and GAC#3 in this state. PARAKANYAA (talk) 02:46, 22 May 2025 (UTC) The discussion...

issue, there are smaller MOS problems which would hopefully be ironed out at GAC or peer review; for instance, the unecessarily capitalised section titles...

further improve the article. This article is well-cited and I believe it is GAC-ready. RyguyMN 05:17, 6 August 2007 (UTC) The following suggestions were...

pages where the current collaboration needs to be announced eg. This page) {{Gac-summary}} - A summary for the current article and previous articles, for...

give you a few minutes. This article is a long way from being ready for WP:GAC. The most glaring issue to me is WP:V. I would need to see at least one inline...

blacklist hits · user page logs · x-wiki · status · Google · StopForumSpam) Gac User is whitelisted: User is in trusted groups sysop, checkuser on some wikis...

discussions. Hurricanehink (talk) 04:58, 6 December 2006 (UTC) Submit for GAC to get external eyes about technical concerns. Titoxd(?!? - cool stuff) 07:43...

will need to add references to all assertions in order to get it passed GAC. The quote, "Never in the field of human conflict was so much owed by so...

dead. Otherwise the page looks nice, problably GA worthy (maybe even FA?). Good luck with the eventual GAc.--Music26/11 13:10, 23 November 2008 (UTC)...

intructions at WP:FAC; articles can't be simultaneously candidates at WP:GAC and WP:FAC. Removing from FAC. SandyGeorgia (Talk) 01:43, 7 July 2007 (UTC)...

that it's a good idea; I was exposed to GAC and the review process by submitting the articles I worked on to GAC and seeing how other editors did it. In...

consider reviewing someone else's article here at peer review or going to WP:GAC and reviewing an article. There is a significant backlog of articles to be...

unsourced paragraphs not based on an article.) Thus, it fails criteria 2 of the GAC. Spinixster (chat!) 04:34, 20 June 2023 (UTC) Alright, I've added some sources...

review because I and my co-author (Ksy92003) hope to take this article to WP:GAC in the near future. Thanks, TonyTheTiger (t/c/bio/tcfkaWCDbwincowtchatlotpsoplrttaDCLaM)...

at present this is a short one. I suggest before you nominate this for WP:GAC, it must be expanded so I recommend you take the time to look for more information...

owl 17:04, 31 July 2007 (UTC) Request withdrawal: The page is currently a GAC and still needs work before it's FA form. -- Scorpion0422 17:07, 31 July...

03:47, 15 September 2009 (UTC) Before you go for a FAC, IMO go for a WP:GAC (Good article) and evaluate the article in accordance with WP:GA? criteria...

Doctor Sunshine talk 14:42, 23 June 2009 (UTC) Why is this article still listed at WP:GAC?--TonyTheTiger (t/c/bio/WP:CHICAGO/WP:LOTM) 20:54, 25 June 2009 (UTC) The...

Hawaii (still a proposal). Loihi is currently B-Class, and nowhere near a GAC. I have opened a peer review to tackle the issues, and to in general raise...

AfD. July - Tankerness from red link to Start. May - Outer Hebrides - now GAC ready December - Rona - from Start to C November - List of freshwater islands...

out time for reviewing FAC and GAC nominations. I find reviewing at A class as equally rewarding as doing so at FAC and GAC. But the reason I have been working...

Bloomfield railway station in Belfast, Northern Ireland. Geograph Bredagh GAC in Belfast, Northern Ireland. Geograph British–Irish Intergovernmental Conference...

or FA classes should be listed, respectively, at Good article candidates (GAC) and Featured article candidates (FAC) respectively; if those processes confer...

Florea 💬 15:51, 23 December 2025 (UTC) Promoted File:Composition VII - Wassily Kandinsky, GAC.jpg --Armbrust The Homunculus 22:15, 25 December 2025 (UTC)...

everyone complained that I was too picky. They took it to the talk page of GAC, in fact.] And yes, I agree this nom is double-dipping in PR and A-class...

way from FA status, and would certainly benefit from work before going to GAC, though perhaps that is within reach. I agree with the above comments, and...

Panhellenic Council (PHC), Interfraternity Council (IFC), Greek Alliance Council (GAC), and National Panhellenic Council (NPHC), 18% of undergraduates are Greek...

page has been scanned and uploaded by GAC to demonstrate that Songulashvili is indeed found in the encyclopedia. GAC has already been required to go to greater...

review because a lot of new content has been added. Maybe it will go to GAC in the future. Thanks, TonyTheTiger (T/C/BIO/WP:CHICAGO/WP:FOUR) 06:15, 20...

ready for GAC. Either it will immediately pass either they will ask you some further imrovements. But I do not think that a straightaway GAC failure is...

yet received good article status. Since the longest unreviewed articles at GAC have been there since late March, casual editors may have already lost interest...

because eventually I'm looking for FAC, but in the mean time some images and a GAC, so I want to know how I am doing thus far. Thanks, SGGH ping! 13:34, 18...

com/aerlingus-drm/?_ga=2.90639770.1040053395.1546131346-914607577.1544422097&_gac=1.141902342.1546131346.EAIaIQobChMI-ZDRiKzG3wIVTdbACh0cIwgeEAAYASAAEgKQW_D_BwE...

gap. She served on the Wikimedia Foundation's Grant Advisory Committee (GAC) and Affiliations Committee (AffCom), where she was elected Vice-Chair. Alessio...

This article recently passed GAC, and is now a GA. Aside from expanding the storm history section, I'd like to know if there's anything else I can do...

Buc 15:49, 23 June 2007 (UTC) Oppose I think the article should pass a GAC before being nominated for FA. It's not only too short (therefore not broad...

16:54, 16 August 2023 (UTC) De-list too much uncited content, so fails WP:GAC 2b/2c. Note the version approved for GA in 2010 [1] also lacks most of these...

We have one GA in history of silk and a GAC in Palestinian costumes. I'm hoping to raise Navajo rug to GAC soon. Half of the top-importance articles...

quickest removal physically possible. Not ready for FAC, its still only a GAC. It won't be FA ready until the DVD is released, which won't be for months...

enjoy paying more attention to the high-culture aspects of Wikipedia at WP:GAC and WP:FAC, or click "Featured content" on the left sidebar. I wish you good...

closed. I've listed this article for peer review because it has failed at WP:GAC for the third time this year. Although many of the most recent reviewer arguments...

Smith/ECAG User:Drew R. Smith/ETAG User:Drew R. Smith/FRET User:Drew R. Smith/GAC User:Drew R. Smith/NEWBAK User:Drew R. Smith/PCS User:Drew R. Smith/POW User:Drew...

not really impressed. I could immediately tell that criteria 1a and 1b of GAC needed attention. I also uploaded a new logo, added two {{citation needed}}...

and several sentences that lack citations, which fails criteria 2 of the GAC. Spinixster (chat!) 13:18, 17 July 2023 (UTC) Delist No improvements, and...

08:04, 13 November 2024 (UTC) If I'm not mistaken, I'm the one who reviewed GAC for this piece. I seriously did not think it was anywhere near or fit for...

controversial or challenged. Kurt Weber (Go Colts!) 16:37, 15 August 2007 (UTC) as a GAC, GAR, and FAC reviewer, i concur that the inclusion of a broad set of reputable...

done. To me, it looks so good, I just can't decide whether to put it up for GAC or FAC. What do you film fans make of it? --Slgrandson (page - messages -...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

would like to continue improving this article, possibly even sending it to GAC, but I'm at a loss for what to do next. Any help apprecitated. —Quasirandom...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

storm section (either in lede or a season summary section); nominated at WP:GAC and passed A class — Season summary as well as an appropriately-long lead...

else steps up you're free to close it (I do agree that it does not meet the GAC in its current state). If I ever get back to it I'll renom :). Thanks, GoldRomean...

list. I imagine that there is precedent on rivalry articles. I'll go to GAC if that is where this belongs.--TonyTheTiger (T/C/BIO/WP:CHICAGO/WP:FOUR)...

now working on the article, and I'd be happy to review it once it's up at GAC (as I have reviewed several of the others). J Milburn (talk) 13:47, 4 July...

interpretations or guesswork. My second concern is that the article does not meet GAC #3a ("it addresses the main aspects of the topic"). The western portion of...

Charlesjsharp (talk) 14:17, 2 July 2020 (UTC) Agreed, but this is FPC, not GAC. Definitely something to be worked on, but I think an FP can be used to drive...

skills will come in handy in another areas of Wikipedia such as WP:DYK and WP:GAC, where you get to work with articles of a different nature. - Mailer Diablo...

from [1]. Dey68 07:36, 18 August 2006 (UTC) St. Mary's University College GAC (history · last edit) from [2] Ladybirdintheuk 10:07, 18 August 2006 (UTC)...

05:07, 28 January 2008 (UTC) Articles cannot be simultaneously listed at WP:GAC and WP:FAC (see the instructions at WP:FAC; which would you like to withdraw...

been mis-assessed; it might be a good idea to see if that actually passes a GAC, it hasn't yet. Jay32183 23:36, 18 February 2007 (UTC) Oppose, the 3 FAs...

this article exists because of advice on the main Guitar Hero II article's GAC reviews, which specifically suggested that, while the content is important...

or FA classes should be listed, respectively, at Good article candidates (GAC) and Featured article candidates (FAC) respectively; if those processes confer...

explanation? These are the basic guidelines to take it to "decent article", ie GAC. Don't hesitate to contact me if you have any questions.--SidiLemine 11:13...

and improve readability. a good start overall, but probably not ready for GAC based on the comments above. ChicagoPimp 23:07, 12 June 2007 (UTC)  Done...

A3CC Dongfeng D120 (Dongfeng EQ7240BP) Dongfeng ePi (Dongfeng eπ) GAC Entranze GAC Moca Geely Fengyin/Geely Forwind SWM EROE Lynk & Co Zero ORA Futurist...

in general, but I am not sure if it is ready for FAC; you could try first GAC for further feedback.--Yannismarou (talk) 08:22, 3 September 2008 (UTC) Thanks...

from [1]. Dey68 07:36, 18 August 2006 (UTC) St. Mary's University College GAC (history · last edit) from [2] Ladybirdintheuk 10:07, 18 August 2006 (UTC)...

logs) (diff  !top) - Link: www.chinapev.com/gac-motor/gac-toyota/gac-aion-s-will-soon-have-a-sibling-gac-toyota-to-release-all-electric-ia5/ (R/Xmeta/L)...

been there for months and I've never seen him participate there. As far as GAC goes, he reviews articles, but is by no means a bigwig. In fact, he's had...

I've listed this article for peer review because it has now failed at WP:GAC twice. I could use any some assistance in getting it over the hump. Thanks...

consistent with MOS:DASH? Personally, I wouldn't get too excited about this at GAC, but it's certainly something that could arise at FAC. They are now...

last I checked) when I tagged it for review. Quick-failed twice through WP:GAC, but hey—third time's the charm. It's come a long, long way since those trials...

1 January 2009 (UTC) FYI I just nominated Washington Park Subdivision at GAC.--TonyTheTiger (t/c/bio/WP:CHICAGO/WP:LOTM) 03:37, 1 January 2009 (UTC) FYI...

how far we've come and what needs to be done prior to submitting it as a GAC/FAC. Caknuck (talk) 02:11, 26 February 2008 (UTC) Please consider adding...

Australian indie rock Australian country music B-class - may be ready for WP:GAC (see also Category:B-Class Australian music articles) Brian Cadd Daddy Cool...

cultural masterpiece of the XXth century. The main problem with the last GAC was the lack of references. Althought this has been partially adressed, it...

15 August 2023 (UTC) De-list woefully short of sources, and so fails WP:GAC 2b/2c- some sections such as "Rivalries" have 0 sources at all, which means...

if you go for FA. You should also have got criticized in GAC. If I was the evaluator in GAC, believe me, you'd have a hard time! Turn also "Bibliography"...

schemes for small and medium-sized requests, participation grants and the GAC-advised Wikimedia grants program. WMF board of trustees: The minutes of the...

suppose I'll start this show. I made a couple edits when this article was a GAC, and have watched this article improve since then, as well as talking with...

improvements as well. Hbdragon88 17:17, 24 September 2006 (UTC) Send it back to GAC and raise a little hell, because length is NOT a GA requirement. Nifboy 17:43...

Result: Delist article, renominate at WP:GAC. Lara♥Love 16:34, 6 August 2007 (UTC) I have notified WP:MLB, WP:NYC, WP:NYY and all editors with a dozen...

to talk about starting a meta:Wikimedia chapter, and/or meta:FDC and meta:GAC processes, so the Singapore community can start to manage their own funding...

and bounds from this to to this. The article seems poised to make it WP:GAC debut sometime before the end of year once a few details can be hammered...

This is not ready; I think it is something that would benefit going through GAC first. The licensing/information on the lead image could do with improving...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

concerned I have nothing else to propose. From the first moment I believed that GAC was redundant and this article should go straight away to FAC! That is why...

Oppose, not nearly ready. Suggest a peer review, followed by submitting GAC, then re-approach FAC. Consulting WP:MEDMOS may help. The article is very...

reliable source I could find about this album -- this two-paragraph bit from GAC. Suggesting deletion, but with no prejudice against re-creation once more...

references contain the location of the publisher. Probably not a big deal at WP:GAC but it would be noticed at WP:FAC should you wish to move the article along...

concerns, more on the legality, etc. I don't think it's quite ready for WP:GAC. -- bcasterline • talk 00:55, 8 September 2006 (UTC) Thank you! I will work...

(added by Cocoaguy, nominator here) Yes, you've passed 60 Minutes through GAC several times without actually reviewing it. See User_talk:Cocoaguy RHB 09:45...

12 August 2007 (UTC) strong oppose - no references! did this even have a GAC review? this topic should include coverage from major national media sources...

December 2007 (UTC) Oppose and close The article is now on GAC. Close the FAC, wait for the GAC to finish, then if the article passes GA, you can take it...

converted to prose. I think they would be especially harsh on that over at GAC or FAC. I can do a more thorough edit on this if you would like though, let...

Milford, County Armagh in Armagh, Northern Ireland. Geograph Moy Tír Na nÓg GAC in Armagh, Northern Ireland. Geograph Mullaghbrack in Armagh, Northern Ireland...

to be fixed in the article to help it reach FA status. It is currently in GAC right now behind a large backlog. Over the last few weeks I have scoured...

represent WEF-USCA as sole incorporator and sign the retention agreement. If GAC funds have not been secured by the time WEF-USCA must pay for its incorporation...

(delete) – (View log) I'm not sure if this is a notable tour or not. The GAC source, while certainly reliable, only lists tour dates and artists, as do...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

than an advertisment. This article would be better fit with the article for GAC than as its own article, at least until it is not only webcast.User:Boon0044...

not sure why it's rated "Start-Class". I think it could be submitted to WP:GAC with some work. Specific issues: Information on his early life is sparse...

barely addressed any of the problems in the article, and resubmitted it to WP:GAC. I'm not going to judge it this time, but somebody else can feel free to...

September 2007 (UTC) Ah, well, then I'll support upon the live album passing GAC (which I'm confident it will). NSR77 TC 23:52, 2 September 2007 (UTC) Weak...

askews into non-NPOV. Given the stability of the response here, would a GAC already be reasonable? Wim van Dorst (Talk) 19:54, 27 September 2006 (UTC)...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

facts listed are nothing but trivia, and such sections are depreciated at WP:GAC and WP:FAC. I hope these suggestions are helpful. Like I said, however, this...

it is a comprehensive as it possibly can be. I have not gone through the GAC process before, so seeking peer review beforehand. Any feedback welcome....

WP:AALERTS came from, but prior to that system, I monitored WP:FAC, WP:FAR, WP:GAC, WP:GAR, WP:FLC and WP:FLRC to manually produce a list of discussions to...

you are keen to improve this article, it may be worth taking it through GAC first. Josh Milburn (talk) 08:34, 23 December 2018 (UTC) Coord note -- Per...

DissidentTalk 09:17, 20 September 2007 (UTC) Er, yeah, 5 GAs. I Don't Remember is at GAC now (hinthint). RfA - probaly at the start of next month - if I go on the...

like constructive criticism on it's content with a view to moving it to GAC status. I will be making a map for the article this week. Thanks, Parrot...

Geograph Lurganville in Lisburn, Northern Ireland. Geograph Lámh Dhearg GAC in Lisburn, Northern Ireland. Geograph Maghaberry in Lisburn, Northern Ireland...

considered improved by an image like this at all quality review processes (PR, GAC, FAC, FLC) except FPC.--TonyTheTiger (T/C/BIO/WP:CHICAGO/WP:FOUR) 01:41,...

was in 2007). What should be improved in it before it is submitted to WP:GAC or WP:FAC? Thanks, Pheonix (talk) 07:22, 30 December 2012 (UTC) Comments...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

would strongly recommend doing so. It might even be worth submitting to WP:GAC as an intermediate step before resubmitting for FAC. It is definitely not...

Gear presenter. The lead needs to be a bit longer, but it'll probably pass GAC as it is. In the infobox, the "Known for" entries should be in italics. The...

Lanka". I should have mentioned it earlier, but the idea is taking this to WP:FLC not WP:GAC or WP:FAC. - Caribbean~H.Q. 17:12, 9 January 2009 (UTC)...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

(UTC)/ Comment: suggest rm from here, act on suggestions, and submit at WP:GAC.Rlevse 17:13, 6 November 2006 (UTC) Comment doesn't contain a section detailing...

expansions in December 2014. This, I believe, means that WP:GAC#5 is no longer met. --Redrose64 🌹 (talk) 21:47, 1 February 2023 (UTC) Delist...

DJ Clayworth (talk) 17:10, 26 May 2009 (UTC) Keep as creator. The CMT and GAC sources assert notability as significant coverage in reliable third-party...

this article is GA then a cursory copy edit should catch all the issues for GAC, but if you do want to pursue FA status then you're going to need a very...

(UTC) Clovers added two sources, both blogs. Blogs for networks like CMT and GAC are fine in association with other sources, but here there are no other sources...

template on the article talk page instead. Other assessment pages, such as WP:GAC do not use an archive of results either. Requiring an editor to update this...

largely outside the scope of other WMF programs like entity-focused FDC or GAC procedures. The Foundation reaches its final funding decisions based on community...

webnode.com.ua/?_ga=2.92122266.1222025762.1536663046-1522735982.1536663046&_gac=1.149602562.1536663103.EAIaIQobChMIkZDf8uOy3QIVCKqaCh2BkgaVEAAYASAAEgJKSfD_BwE...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

POV set of edits from a small number of editors. I consider it as failing GAC on 2b, 2c, 3a & 4. Many of the issues I raised were there when it was a GA...

article who has nominated it at WP:GAC has deciced to move the image it into the main text. Obviously, people who know the GAC process understand how less than...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

Queenie (talk · contribs) I'm looking at this from the point of view of a GAC reviewer, as you requested. Well, the lead section certainly needs expansion...

personally done; I am sending the article about the national constitution to GAC right now and I am working up the article on capital punishment in the country...

other articles will be added. (I currently have two more MA-articles at GAC.) I mean that with a large topic such as this, and with Angelou continuing...

WP:PR or WP:GAC first. SandyGeorgia (Talk) 18:43, 17 February 2007 (UTC) Note that a completely uncited article will definitely not meet GAC - a whole swathe...

found it helpful please consider reviewing an article either here or at GAC to reduce the ever-present backlog. If you have specific questions regarding...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

standards (prose quality, in universe focus, citations), it might make a good GAC candidate should someone take the pain to go through the article and provide...

"After the war, he served on the influential General Advisory Committee (GAC) of the Atomic Energy Commission (AEC), and the Joint Research and Development...

vocalist or bassist? As a conclusion, I would say that the article will pass GAC. But for a higher ranking I would also like to have a more detailed biography...

has been closed. I would eventually like to nominate this article as a WP:GAC as I believe it has the potential to become a WP:GA. This is the first article...

to be handled by the volunteer-reviewers of the Grant Advisory Committee (GAC), which has apparently not yet managed to sort out fundamental aspects of...

who'll check the clips and pix are properly labelled before you take this to GAC etc. All in all, a nice article, well on the way to GA. Worth considering...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

article more credible. I'd give this article some work and then take it to WP:GAC to see if it will pass as a Good Article. That's the next logical step after...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

B. I'm reluctant to rate it GA without having successfully gone through GAC. In general, a nice article. These is my review: The lead is short. Check...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

several ways. You could: Help clean up articles that are already GAs or GACs. Reviewers and copyediters are EXTREMELY helpful. Work on improving an article...

19 January 2008 (UTC) Support All of my comments were fixed before its GAC. The article is well-written, has numerous pictures which exhibit different...

those GA candidates in the queue of the subsection where WP:AUS-related GACs are waiting. This will help to speed up the process, while helping other...

metapedianing (for teh record, I just removed the entire project space, except for GAC and FPOC, from my watchlist, because it's all pissing me off big time). Happy...

Amendments section. This will need to be addressed before it can be successful at GAC. Imbedded lists should be broken down into prose. Images look good, references...

(UTC) Object for now.Add a few more references, tweak it out, and ask for a peer review or send it to WP:GAC first.--Wizardman 22:59, 25 March 2007 (UTC)...

Geograph Loughermore in Limavady, Northern Ireland. Geograph Magilligan GAC in Limavady, Northern Ireland. Geograph Mid Londonderry (Northern Ireland...

me to see them in my own. I am trying to shift my reviewing efforts from GAC to Peer Review because I don't always have the time to see a GA review through...

article have been considered offtopic. Let's face it, any article at WP:GAC probably has a few faults or else it would be at WP:FAC. In this case, the...

subject, but was unable to find the kind of stuff to show she passes the GAC. Given that she doesn't pass WP:PROF either, and several strong arguments...

great that you've initiated a PR, but after this I would suggest maybe WP:GAC -- provided that the article is much improved from what I'm seeing now. (Note:...

WP:GAC. I intended to and thought I did, however, so I appreciate your listing it for me. I also hope it gets a review soon, but you're right about GAC,...

Strawberry Shortcake (80s Annual Specials). A long-awaited Triple Crown and a GAC are close by. I'm planning to do the same for the remaining specials in the...

20:15, 14 February 2007 (UTC) Comment - You're supposed to go in order at GAC, but you technically don't have to, so, as I'm not affiliated with WP:TROPIC...

2015 (UTC) I do not think you will have any problems getting this through GAC. @23W: Perhaps you may be interested in taking a look at this article? Josh...

articles about video games, patrol new pages (recently started), review GACs, and help out with various WikiProjects such as WikiProject Massively multiplayer...

boring and dry. You're the poster child, yes, but that's because you are a GAC and FAC nominating machine. It's a project wide problem and I include myself...

needing citations. So I took care of them. Any suggestions before I take it to GAC? Daniel Case 03:56, 4 March 2007 (UTC) Thank you for reading this! I was...

review, if you found it helpful consider reviewing an article here or at WP:GAC to help reduce the backlog. If you have questions or concerns please contact...

It's genuinely appreciated. I see that you wish to take this article to WP:GAC. This is a noble endeavor. I'll give you some feedback on how to improve...

of use to you in here, and I wish you luck in pushing this thing through GAC and FAC. Acdixon (talk · contribs) 16:19, 18 November 2012 (UTC) Lead: "The...

review discussion has been closed. Been thinking of putting this one up for GAC in a few weeks time, there is need for improvment in this articles ref section...

standards. Giants2008 (17-14) 20:28, 11 August 2008 (UTC) Oppose per past FAC/GAC comments that I made.Blnguyen (bananabucket) 04:15, 12 August 2008 (UTC)...

Article candidacy. Aside from that there have been very few edits since the GAC process and these represent minor if not superficial change. The article...

a bit vague. "Thought" is still tagged for copy-editing. Don't you go in GAC or FAC with such tags in your article. Fix the relevant issues first! In...

of Vanderbilt baseball team, interview with metromix.com, coverage from GAC. This is all you need to pass WP:NOTE, since its significant coverage from...

page moves · rights · RfA) AnomieBOT⚡ 18:09, 3 April 2014 (UTC) File:Glack GAC Crest.png (delete | talk | history | logs). Logo design, not necessarily...

the GAC was reviewed though, then it should be listed on the page again. LuciferMorgan 08:20, 6 June 2007 (UTC) Yes, they were added after the GAC was...

blacklist hits · user page logs · x-wiki · status · Google · StopForumSpam) Gac User is whitelisted: User is in trusted groups sysop, checkuser on some wikis...

Similar to trying to nominate something at WP:GAC with loads of {{citeneeded}} problems - the WP:GAC process even has "quick fail criteria" specifically...

Controversial BBC documentary. As of the 17th, this is awaiting a review at WP:GAC, and I am interested in how much it would take to get this to featured article...

Oppose, soures could be better and it isn't very well-written. Might pass WP:GAC, send it there first and see what they say.--Wizardman 18:21, 18 March 2007...

as unassessed. Those articles should probably go through peer review and GAC before considering this as an FT. Jay32183 04:57, 6 March 2007 (UTC) Tooth...

further edits should be made to this discussion. This article recently passed GAC and I think that it could be of A-class quality. All comments welcome. Kyriakos...

things in a flyover read that should be addressed prior to nomination at WP:GAC Do you have her maiden name? Usually this goes in the first line of the lead...

this Hamilton native on WrestleMania?" and "Hamilton native guest host on GAC show", which makes it clear that this is coverage by a local journal based...

you'll want to keep on with XfDs ad RfAs, maybe you can help us out at FAC or GAC. Other than that, I see no incivility to or perpetrated by you. If you were...

(UTC) Oppose: I noticed this one leave the WP:GAC board and took a quick look to see why it was bypassing GAC and going straight for FAC. The article has...

character articles at WP:MOS-MANGA. If possible, I'd like to take this to GAC. —Quasirandom 20:59, 26 September 2007 (UTC) Please see automated peer review...

mention it. If you don't want to make a call one way or another, I'll let the GAC reviewer decide.--TonyTheTiger (T/C/BIO/WP:CHICAGO/WP:FOUR) 18:51, 15 August...

out what flaws this article has so it can be fixed befor being taken to GAC and, eventually, FAC. Thanks, Red marquis (talk) 16:01, 5 July 2012 (UTC)...

if the above fixes can be made, I would recommend renominating it at WP:GAC for another go at it. There's some work to do, but it is not awful......

someone to understand if they do not know much about the Napoleonic wars. (GAC#1a) (t · c) buidhe 01:46, 1 August 2023 (UTC) Context is there: "In April...

period where the subject has become the most notable. It therefore fails the GAC#3, the broadness criterion in missing out on an entire decade of the group's...

here. I added the "novelette" mention in this section because of one of the GAC comments, but I agree with you that it's odd. I've removed it for now, but...

I was going to nominate this as a WP:GAC. However, it is quite short for a GA. I want to make sure I have done most basic things before nominating the...

early times. --Angelo 15:47, 18 September 2007 (UTC) Oppose Four FACs, a GAC, a peer review, and a GA/R in one week? Jeez Louise. Slow down, and take...

I expect that once my concerns have been addressed, this'd sail through GAC; I'm not so sure about FAC. I hope my comments have been a help! Seegoon...

Zimbu User is whitelisted: User is in a trusted group sysop on some wikis Gac User is whitelisted: User is in trusted groups sysop, checkuser on some wikis...

| talk | history | links | watch | logs) Wikipedia:Community portal/gac-summary (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs) Wikipedia:Community...

article looked vastly different to what it is now. This article may violate GAC criterion 2D, and the copyright violation report can be found here. Note...

Shortcut WP:GANRWP:GANR This is the statistical report of the good article nominations (GAN). It is updated daily by a bot and is provided to assist in...

article it was one paragraph - seen here. After receiving two very dodgy GAC reviews i submitted it to GAR where it received helpful feedback and almost...

you are new to Wikipedia and making an effort to get this article to WP:GAC. In order to have it pass as a GA you will need to meet the GA criteria....

similar? That's just a stylistic consideration and I doubt would impact a GAC/FAC. Some flow and prose could be touched up to be more pleasant a read,...

Championship redirect Complete Corofin GAA (Galway) and redirect Corofin GAC to Corofin GAA. List of All-Ireland Senior Football Championship winning...

like to see what additional work may be needed before nominating it as a GAC. I've attempted to follow the guidelines for a character article at WP:MOS-AM...

on what a properly cited article should be. My opinion is that a new WP:GAC should have at least one citation for every paragraph since each paragraph...

tracert • robtex.com • StopForumSpam • Google • AboutUs • Project HoneyPot) Gac User is whitelisted: User is in trusted groups sysop, checkuser on some wikis...

the article for FA status. I am keeping an eye on the Inseminoid article's GAC, while I personally nominated the Nightmare remake article for GA status...

more you add, the best for the article. I think the article will go through GAC, but I'm not yet sure for FAC.--Yannismarou 19:00, 8 May 2007 (UTC) I was...

part as well, and I suggest you be more active there. Helping out at WP:GAC and other WP functions is also helpful. In terms of your conduct, I see no...

finance non-core activities, which will include the Wikimedia grant program, a GAC allocation doubled to $600k, global education, and education programs in...

Majorly talk 20:32, 21 February 2009 (UTC) Some of this may be overkill for GAC but believe me if you eventually want to go for FAC making these changes...

have been replaced.--Gduwen (talk) 17:28, 6 March 2011 (UTC) During the WP:GAC, I had noted that there were unnecessary redundant links. I see many again...

Plaza from Cloud Gate due to complaints at WP:FAC. I will post both at WP:GAC and see how they are received.--TonyTheTiger (t/c/bio/WP:CHICAGO/WP:LOTM)...

same time? --enano (Talk) 16:07, 16 August 2006 (UTC) it is for weeks at GAC. There are no legal issues regarding that also. lol. let's discuss the article...

I've listed this article for peer review because the article failed at WP:GAC for reasons that were not clear because the cited problems do not seem to...

is one of the first things that will catch the eye of a reviewer on the GAC. It's also a good idea to avoid overlinking, a temptation to which I've often...

this article, other than the reference problems I stated. Good luck in WP:GAC. Thank you so much for your input and keen eyes! Crzycheetah 19:57, 9 April...

paragraphs have no references. Less than 15 kB, may be not comprehensive. Try GAC instead. --Kaypoh 12:13, 29 August 2007 (UTC) The above discussion is preserved...

the album out. Furthermore, if there's a "lot of info" where is it? CMT, GAC, etc. had nothing that amounted to anything more than "it will be released...

or not editing the page it will take a while but the article should be at GAC in around two weeks after Puerto Rican Amazon is nominated, thanks a lot...

committee members from the two grantmaking volunteer bodies, the IEG and GAC. If the pilot project is successful (signs so far indicate a high level of...

nominated for review. Result: Returned prior hold status This artcle was a WP:GAC and was put on hold on 8 May, 2007. But today on 9 May, 2007 it failed.(The...

long, but a little bit more than a few sentences per section. Under the GAC, I don't see any assessment criteria regarding length requirements. The one...

shows like, "My Brother and Me," "Keenan and Kel," and "All That."" Original GAC text: "As a child, Cox spent 5 years training studying dance in the U.S....

available in secondary sources? I am seeking a relisting of this article at GAC with the original date priority.--TonyTheTiger (T/C/BIO/WP:CHICAGO/WP:FOUR)...

the current structure and sources are useful material if you want to go to GAC. However, the frist objection is that entire sections are blatant copyvios...

of what we would be looking for at FAC. I suggest that you take it though GAC and peer review first, and you may also want to seek out a FAC mentor. These...

is not violated. The other concern is lack of reliable sources, but the GAC and Country Standard Time references look like they satisfy that to me. Olaf...

At this point, B class is the highest it can get before nominating it at GAC for GA status. I would consider getting a peer review with the WP:Films which...

comprehensive, carefully sourced article was recently improved upon via the GAC (passed) and peer review processes. As sole major contributor, I am seeking...

I think this article should have no problem meeting the standards of the GAC. I believe it has the potential to achieve FA status. Best, -- twelsht (talk)...

and shouldn't take too long. I would say that you should nominate it at WP:GAC and see what the reviewer thinks. I feel like it's very close to GA quality...

--Phoenix-wiki 22:49, 1 January 2008 (UTC) After pushing this through WP:GAC and one attempt at WP:FAC, I have pretty much exhausted my resorces in terms...

as unassessed. Those articles should probably go through peer review and GAC before considering this as an FT. Jay32183 04:57, 6 March 2007 (UTC) Tooth...

both be fairly evaluated against WIAFS. If you have ever participated at WP:GAC and WP:GAR, you might be familiar with the concept of the criteria. If people...

formatting and use of reliable sourcing is fine. Images Before taking this to WP:GAC be sure to get the image license question ironed out. Use of non-free images...

think I'll submit this to GAC tomorrow... Cheers, CP 01:31, 6 September 2007 (UTC) Excellent. I agree that it's ready for GAC. And the genius is, if there's...

w:vi:Thảo luận:Thịt trâu (logitem  top) - Link: amthucmuonnoi.net/thit-trau-gac-bep/ (R/Xmeta/L) 2022-10-07 06:47:25 (UTC): w:vi:User:103.199.35.138 (t -...

forked article. If you don't have that available to you, that's fine for GAC but probably won't help you if you take this article to FAC. As I state above...

shift at work.") If it was given a solid cleaning, it could head towards GAC, but this is a long way from FA standards. J Milburn (talk) 13:04, 5 December...

reliance on autobiography is a little troubling, of course, but this isn't GAC. WilyD 12:58, 7 January 2009 (UTC) Maybe. Do you have any WP:RS to prove...

isn't as important as adding more information; but it's necessary to pass GAC. If you need any further help or have any questions, message me on my talk...

future is less clear. There is an explicit rule about current events at GAC; I wouldn't support an explicit rule here, but I think it's something to...

I do GAC and GA/R reviews all the time. Even the occasional FA and peer review, but I am terrible at reviewing articles I've put a great deal of work...

17 April 2007 (UTC) I think the article is not ready for GAC. It needs some work for GAC, more work for A-Class, and a lot of work for FAC! Are you...

tracert • robtex.com • StopForumSpam • Google • AboutUs • Project HoneyPot) Gac User is whitelisted: User is in trusted groups sysop, checkuser on some wikis...

implemented. --RL0919 (talk) 21:44, 29 April 2017 (UTC) Support. I had my say at GAC, and the article has only improved since then. Josh Milburn (talk) 22:08...

article that is very thorough and well-sourced. Given that Casliber did the GAC, I'm not surprised that I didn't find any obvious issues. – VisionHolder...

2025 (UTC) Delist Having entire sections with zero citations is a blatant GAC fail. Trainsandotherthings (talk) 23:29, 11 September 2025 (UTC) The discussion...

conference co-funded by the GAC to correctly state the funding was provided by the Wikimedia Grants Program, which is advised by the GAC. Ijon (talk) 21:12, 25...

YellowMonkey (bananabucket) 05:25, 18 September 2009 (UTC) Also notethe previous GAC was an arbitrary driveby YellowMonkey (bananabucket) 05:27, 18 September...

stub. And with sub-sections or not I'm afraid this could be a problem in GAC. Now I am also a jurist and I know about legal provisions! But, you know...

listed this article for peer review because I'd like to bring this article to GAC sometimes in the future. As no-one ever review it before and it's out of...

ja:S-kei (talk - contribs) to ja:地球温暖化に関する論争 (diff). Links: dpa.aapg.org/gac/statements/climatechange.cfm dpa.aapg.org/ www.agu.org/fora/eos/pdfs/2006EO360008...

opinion, either informally or, on one occasion, via WP:3O. I also find FAC and GAC fairly stressful, but am able to look on the bright side afterward, when...

(making it the first TV show to possibly achieve this ranking) as soon as the GAC subarticles have successfully passed their candidacy. Copyedits are always...

comments. -Susanlesch 21:59, 1 February 2007 (UTC) Nice, indeed. Wait for GAC, and if you pass, I think the article can go straight to FAC. This is my...

listed this article for peer review because I was able to pass it through GAC this June and after the work to the article I have done since, I feel it...

blacklist hits · user page logs · x-wiki · status · Google · StopForumSpam) Gac User is whitelisted: User is in trusted groups sysop, checkuser on some wikis...

been mis-assessed; it might be a good idea to see if that actually passes a GAC, it hasn't yet. Jay32183 23:36, 18 February 2007 (UTC) Oppose, the 3 FAs...

previous 24 hours to get a GAC to pass with these edits here, here, here, here, and here. So it was something that I knew the GAC world was paying close attention...

if you found it helpful consider reviewing another article here or at WP:GAC to help reduce the backlog. If you have any questions or concerns please...

(UTC) Oppose: IMO, the article is far from a FA. Some things need to done a GAC: Most refs do not have page nos. ref 19 is " pp. 173-199 ", find which book...

23:14, 20 January 2007 (UTC) No prob. I'll look forward to seeing this at WP:GAC soon enough. Dåvid ƒuchs (talk • contribs) 23:19, 20 January 2007 (UTC)...

WO:GREECE. You can go first for a GA review (check WP:GAC) and then for a FA candidacy or skip GAC, and, when you think you are ready, go straight for FAC...

"Appearances in other media" that has to be taken care of before it goes to GAC. The range of information you cover looks good; the depth could probably...

on wikipedia (Barack Obama, Hillary Rodham Clinton, & John McCain) at WP:GAC, WP:GAR, and WP:FAR does not provide a precedent that ongoing dynmaics of...

current featured articles. The next step would be to nominate articles at WP:GAC and WP:FAC. Don't be discouraged if they don't pass; you'll receive feedback...

enter? The prose could still be improved, but it might be good enough for WP:GAC. The article somehow doesn't seem complete, though. In addition to a section...

earlier in the agenda, preferably right after we vote on the lawyer. The GAC has indicated that we need to submit our requests ASAP.Pjthepiano (talk)...

wise to condense and merge the history article. Having a check through the GAC, I don't really foresee many problems with this article. Perhaps a thorough...

de Vrees told the mailing-list: "I think that WMHK should reapply to the GAC (because I do think we need to fund them as a movement) with a modest proposal...

WP:FACR (unfortunately, I don't think it even complies with some of the WP:GAC). I do believe this article has the potential to be featured though. Best...

tagged. Closing. asilvering (talk) 07:16, 17 December 2025 (UTC) Windows 10 GAC (talk+ · tag · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user ·...

for some uncontroversial information, but, especially if you're aiming for GAC, it may be better to replace it with a stronger source. The cheese maker...

largely outside the scope of other WMF programs like entity-focused FDC or GAC procedures. The Foundation reaches its final funding decisions based on community...

think this is article for FAC just yet I would advise you take it take to GAC firstly, as I feel a review would bring it closer to featured standard its...

One of them didn't even have a rationale- it would have quick-failed at GAC. J Milburn (talk) 11:32, 26 November 2010 (UTC) Oppose, unfortunately. Impressive...

History and Fountain of Time when the latter makes its way through the WP:GAC process (hopefully on its first attempt). The subtopic may also include Bud...

—Onomatopoeia 12:43, 22 August 2007 (UTC) Comment - Article is currently at GAC. Can't we just leave it there and let it be re-reviewed, rather then going...

review, and if the results are favourable, I think I'm going to take it for GAC! All comments would be appreciated, and I shall action them if I am able...

have this batted away at FAC, although I think it'd likely breeze through GAC. A Featured Article would absolutely, definitely demand more in regarding...

This has twice failed at WP:GAC. Although the second time was mostly for faulty references, I would like some critical review. TonyTheTiger...

pictured. This concludes my review I hope it was helpful. Best of luck at GAC. H1nkles (talk) citius altius fortius 20:26, 18 April 2011 (UTC) Thank you...

review because I wanted a set of eyes on to help me prepare this for WP:GAC.--TonyTheTiger (T/C/BIO/WP:CHICAGO/WP:FOUR) 02:31, 3 November 2011 (UTC)...

hockey team and forms the bulk of the sources here. One concern during the GAC was how to layout the article properly, in that the Stanley Cup challenges...

been working on expanding and improving it, and I'd like to move toward GAC if possible. I'd like to know if it meets B-class article criteria at this...

you've already gone ahead and nominated the article for consideration at WP:GAC. Since they will do a formal review anyway, I won't be doing a more detailed...

B-Class requirements (very close), but not quite. It is also not yet ready for GAC or FAC nomination. TheJosh, I'd say you would want to work towards Good Article...

typically I cannot rate it as such, because it has not gone at least through GAC; but probably it will be soon FA, so why do you care about A-Class?! This...

which I got from the Chicago Public Library when I took the article to GAC. Let me know if this is O.K.--TonyTheTiger (t/c/bio/WP:CHICAGO/WP:LOTM) 00:52...

I've listed this article for peer review because I want to get it ready for GAC. Please review the entire article for completeness, consistency, verifiability...

presently under a one-month block for, among other things, disruption at WP:GAC. Orderinchaos 03:09, 8 April 2007 (UTC) Comment As Zleitzen(talk) said, I...

article as it is now has no inline citations, and wouldn't pass neither GAC or FAC. "Léonce Perret (May 13, 1880 in Niort, Deux-Sèvres, France – August...

out that prior versions were deleted. This article is likely to pass at WP:GAC. Don't compare this to the prior versions that were deleted. This song and...

07:52, 9 April 2007 (UTC) Question? Why do you have it at GAC and FAC at the same time? Clearing GAC before approaching FAC would make better use of editors'...

April 2007 (UTC) I've nominated Crash (song) at GAC then. I'm not sure how long FTCs usually last, but the GAC at the top is from March 18, so it could be...

comprehensiveness here, as far as Altman's works are concerned. Looking forward to GAC soon enough. Thanks, Slgrandson (How's my egg-throwing coleslaw?) 10:28,...

subject only seems to be borderline notable. Again, I suggest that PR and GAC would be a better route; without some more in-depth sources, I think you're...

2018 (UTC) The articles themselves are all very short, and already passed GAC. I can take another look and verify they summarized the articles well. Kees08...

than as a request for formal 'support'. Give yourself plenty of time. A GAC can be fairly straightforward, but an FAC is unlikely to be. Editors will...

Comments from JM At first glance, this looks like an article that is ready for GAC. My view may change once I've looked a little more closely. Here I go......

they've been most helpful and I will see about putting the article up for GAC later, but right now I should probably get on with some work.... ;-) ChrisTheDude...

article is promoted by User:FunPika in March 10, 2007. But while we were doing GAC backlog elimination drive in July 2007, serious issues came up regarding...

fulfill that very request for another four years!) Let's hope a long-belated GAC does justice. After all, this is the better of Nelvana's computer-animated...

taken care of! Plus I've added alt text to the poster. Anything else before GAC? --Slgrandson (How's my egg-throwing coleslaw?) 00:12, 4 May 2010 (UTC) The...

little clean up would get it to GA quality. I'd recommend getting it through GAC and then bringing it back here for a nit picky review prior to a run at FAC...

region. The article has been worked on-and-of since 2014, and has passed GAC and more recently, MILHIST's ACR, much to its benefit on both cases. I feel...

I did the same with 2008–09 Pittsburgh Penguins season, which is now at GAC. How difficult is it to keep articles up-to-date as the 2010–11 NHL season...

raise your concerns when you disagree. By the way, I have an article at WP:GAC, "Water" awaiting reviewal, please consider reviewing it. Was it the first...

Those are the big things that should be addressed before the article goes to GAC. This concludes my review I hope you found it helpful. If you have questions...

coming to FAC (or even GAC, for that matter). Christine (Figureskatingfan) (talk) 22:45, 31 January 2014 (UTC) This passed GAC before the first FAC in...

GAC Dublin-Belfast corridor Greenlough GAC Limavady GAC Muirchertach Ua Briain Newbridge GAC Patrick Cassidy (composer) Seán Browne Seán Dolans GAC 1737...

think it is too relevant. I also added some of the selection criteria. I've also nominated it for GAC. Mr.Z-mantalk¢Review! 22:15, 14 March 2007 (UTC)...

ready for the endless nitpicking and incivility that is FAC. You should try GAC first, but take note that: The controversy occured only two months ago, and...

identified as poor prose at FAC. This is not an issue you will run into at GAC but since you wish to push this article to FA standing I'm bringing it up...

discussion of this film yet published. This article has been reviewed at GAC by J Milburn and at PR by Wehwalt, Cassianto, SchroCat, and Sarastro. Hope...