In a 2024 interview with Questlove Supreme, Amerie revealed "Why Don't We Fall in Love" was not supposed to be the first single. She initially wanted "Talkin' to Me" to be her single debut - which was later made to be the second single released. Amerie considered "Why Don't We Fall in Love" to be the album's intro - hence the reason for the short length and the placement as the opening track on her debut album, All I Have. Despite this, Columbia Records insisted the song slated to be released as her first single.[1]
Music video
The single's music video was directed by Benny Boom and filmed in May 2002 in Brooklyn, New York.[2] The video features a guest appearance by Carl Thomas, and was released in June 2002. The video opens with the words "The first day of summer" ( The 1st day of summer was June 21, 2002 and although the date was never clear it was rumored that June 21 was the exact date of the release of the video).
Remixes
The official remix features rapper Ludacris who is also in the CD single and the Japanese edition of the album. There is also a remix called the "Roc-A-Fella Remix" that features Dipset rapper Cam'ron; another remix also produced by Rich Harrison called the "Richcraft Remix" has new verses by Amerie and a new instrumental. This remix would later appear on her next album Touch as a bonus track for the U.S. and Japanese editions.
Track listings and formats
U.S. double A-side single with "Got to Be There"
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (album version) – 2:39
"Got to Be There" – 3:01
UK and Australian CD single
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (album version) – 2:39
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (main mix featuring Ludacris) – 3:33
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (Richcraft Remix) – 3:36
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (instrumental) – 2:48
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (main mix - a cappella featuring Ludacris) – 3:26
UK 12" single
Side A:
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (main mix featuring Ludacris) – 3:33
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (album version) – 2:39
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (instrumental) – 2:48
Side B:
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (Richcraft Remix) – 3:36
"Why Don't We Fall in Love" (Richcraft Remix Instrumental) – 3:35