Items: Kane Mask, Kane's Unabomb Gear, Undertaker's Urn, Various items in The Undertaker's storage unit, including his black and purple jacket, phantom mask.
Items: Snake bag, The Honky Tonk Man's guitar (donated by Jimmy Hart), Hall of Fame tuxedo, WrestleMania III ring (not purchased because WWE thought it was not the authentic one)
Items: The Big Show's "Andre Tribute" Singlet (donated by Big Show), Madison Square Garden playbill from Andre's debut, Mark Henry's debut jacket (donated by Mark Henry), André the Giant's Jacket from The Main Event (on loan), The Giant Machine Mask (on loan), Andre the Giant's Pink Jacket (on loan) and Andre the Giant's passport.
Items: Rey Mysterio's WWE Debut Mask & Outfit (loan), Eddie Guerrero's Lowrider, Rey Mysterio's Custody Match Gear (not found), Rey Mysterio's Mask from final Eddie match (loan)
Items: Trish & Lita's Raw Main Event Gear, Mae Young's Crown & Robe (traded for Edge's 2005 Money in the Bank briefcase), Alundra's WWF Women's Championship (not acquired)
Items: Rikishi's Sumo Belt (bought for $3,000 plus VIP Tickets to Extreme Rules 2022), Yokozuna's WrestleMania X Robe (traded for Gorgeous George's Robe), The Rock's $500 Shirt (bought from Jerry Lawler for $10,000)
^Varsallone, Jim (April 14, 2021). "Booker T is on two new WWE TV series on A&E.; One is co-hosted by WWE rookie A.J. Francis". Miami Herald. Miami, Florida. Archived from the original on April 20, 2021. Retrieved May 3, 2021. Following at 10 p.m. each Sunday, the brand-new series "WWE's Most Wanted Treasures," led by WWE's Stephanie McMahon and Paul "Triple H" Levesque, launches a hunt for some of WWE's most iconic missing memorabilia including Kane's original mask, Ric Flair's Butterfly Robe, Andy Kaufman's neckbrace, Andre The Giant's passport and more.