The station was assigned the call letters WTSN-FM on September 6, 1991. The call sign was changed to WRZY on October 15, 1993, and to WRGW on April 18, 1994;[4] under that call sign, the station took to the air January 25, 1995, with an adult contemporary format branded as "The Rock Garden".[1][5] The station changed its call letters to WRDX on April 15, 1996,[4] concurrent with a switch to an adult standards format branded "Radio Deluxe"; however, the AC format returned a month later,[6] and the station became WBYY on June 14, 1996,[4] to reflect its "98.7 The Bay" branding.[7]
On August 31, 2015, WBYY and its sister station WTSN announced plans to merge with Port Broadcasting's WNBP and WWSF and Aruba Capital Holdings' WXEX and WXEX-FM to form Coastal Radio Partners.[8] The three-way merger was not completed;[9] on September 29, 2016, WBYY and WTSN were instead sold to Binnie Media for $2.1 million.[10]
On May 24, 2019, WBYY changed its format from adult contemporary to classic hits, branded as "Frank FM"; the programming is largely simulcast with Nashua sister station WFNQ, though WBYY breaks away for local commercials and station identifications.[11] The "Frank FM" network, which also includes WLNH-FM in Laconia, transitioned to a hot adult contemporary format during 2021.[12]
After morning host Marc Nazzaro (who used the air name "DJ Nazzy") was laid off from "Frank FM" in January 2023 as part of a refocus of Binnie Media's resources on its news and talk programming, vice president of programming Heath Cole told the Concord Monitor that "the music format that we do will change".[13] On February 1, 2023, WBYY, along with the rest of the "Frank FM" network, returned to a classic hits format; the stations also dropped their remaining on-air staff, who were reassigned to other positions within the company.[14]