Unternehmen Michael

Unternehmen Michael
Directed byKarl Ritter
Screenplay by
[3]
Based onthe play Unternehmen Michael or Frühlingsschlacht
by Hans Fritz von Zwehl
Produced byKarl Ritter
Starring
CinematographyGünther Anders
Edited byGottfried Ritter
Music byHerbert Windt
Production
company
Release date
  • 7 September 1937 (1937-09-07)[1][2]
CountryNazi Germany
LanguageGerman

Unternehmen Michael (Operation Michael or The Michael Action; English title The Private's Job[2]) is a 1937 German film directed by Karl Ritter, the first of three films about the First World War which he made during the period when the Third Reich was rearming.

Plot summary

The film is set in the First World War and is based on a 1932 play by Hans Fritz von Zwehl (Frühlingsschlacht, 'Spring Battle', originally also titled Unternehmen Michael)[4][5] about the German offensive Operation Michael during the First World War, which was launched on 21 March 1918. The British are in possession of the village of Beaurevoir. The Germans plan to send in assault troops to take the village, but their commanding officer, Captain Hill, is injured the night before. A desk officer, Major zur Linden (Mathias Wieman), volunteers to lead the mission. The unit succeed but find themselves surrounded by the enemy. They discuss their options and Major zur Linden's advocacy of a heroic death for the sake of their country wins out over the defeatist and the traditional military pragmatist; the Germans declare a ceasefire and then the commanding general, in full knowledge, gives the order for their artillery to bombard the village as the British are storming it, thereby sacrificing their own men in order to kill the enemy.[6][7][8] The sacrifice is not in vain; it enables the Germans to push forward to the British fortress, the 'Labyrinth'.[9]


Cast

Production and themes

Shooting took place between 12 May and late June 1937, with interiors shot at the UFA studios in Neubabelsberg.[2]

Unternehmen Michael is the first of three 'soldier films' set during the First World War which Ritter made in 1936–38, when Nazi Germany was rearming in preparation for renewed war.[10] Ritter himself described his war films as "pictorial armo[u]red car[s]", in contrast to entertainment films.[11] It was a Staatsauftragsfilm; it was commissioned by the Ministry of Propaganda.[12] It is representative of the glorification in Nazi Germany of the heroic death (Heldentod). As the general tells the major in charge of the assault unit: "Posterity will remember us not by the greatness of our victory but by the measure of our sacrifice!"[7][13] Thousands of men are sacrificed over a ruined village of little strategic value.[14]

Release

The film premièred on 7 September 1937 at the Ufa-Palast in Nuremberg during the 9th Nazi Party rally and in Berlin at the Ufa-Palast am Zoo on 19 November 1937.[2] It was shown the following year in the United States.

Reception

Officers of the Wehrmacht objected to the suicidal message of the film.[15] The director, Karl Ritter, responded by saying, "I want to show the German youth that senseless, sacrificed death has its moral value."[6][7][16] Carl Bloem, a retired military officer who had published popular novels, was asked to rebut the film's point of view and did so in a radio play in which the pragmatic view won out amongst the soldiers: "No German commanding officer has the right or duty to destroy uselessly the lives of German soldiers." The company raise the white flag of surrender. This was broadcast on the Cologne radio station, but the Ministry of Propaganda disavowed it, with the statement, "Our film has the purpose of showing the younger generation of today the real spirit of the German soldier during the offensive at the western front in 1918."[17] The film was awarded the Prädikat (distinction) of staatspolitisch besonders wertvoll (particular political value).[1]

The New York Times, however, saw the film as "not emphasiz[ing]" the horrors of war.[18]

The film is classified by the Friedrich Wilhelm Murnau Foundation as a Vorbehaltsfilm (conditional film), meaning it can only be shown in Germany under restricted conditions for educational purposes.[19]

References

  1. ^ a b David Welch, Propaganda and the German Cinema, 1933–1945, Oxford: Oxford University-Clarendon, 1983, ISBN 9780198225980, p. 320 (rev. ed. 2001, p. 275).
  2. ^ a b c d e Rolf Giesen, Nazi Propaganda Films: A History and Filmography, Jefferson, North Carolina/London: McFarland, 2003, ISBN 9780786415564, p. 227.
  3. ^ Krieg und Militär im Film des 20. Jahrhunderts, ed. Bernhard Chiari, Matthias Rogg and Wolfgang Schmidt, Beiträge zur Militärgeschichte 59, Munich: Oldenbourg, 2003, ISBN 9783486567168, p. 369 (in German)
  4. ^ "ZWEHL, von, Hans Fritz", Wer ist wer?: das deutsche Who's who Volume 12, Lübeck: Schmidt Römhild, 1955, p. 1304 (in German)
  5. ^ Heinz Schlötermann, Das deutsche Weltkriegsdrama 1919–1937: eine wertkritische Analyse, "Nationaltheater", Schriftenreihe des theaterwissenschaftlichen Instituts der Friedrich-Schiller-Universität Jena II, Würzburg-Aumühle: K. Triltsch, 1939, OCLC 9985315, p. 29 (in German)
  6. ^ a b Harry Waldman, Nazi Films in America, 1933–1942, Jefferson, North Carolina/London: McFarland, 2008, ISBN 9780786438617, p. 166, referring to it as the First Battle of the Somme.
  7. ^ a b c John Altmann, "The Technique and Content of Hitler's War Propaganda Films: Part II: Karl Ritter's 'Soldier' Films", Hollywood Quarterly, 5.1, Autumn 1950, pp. 61–72, p. 63.
  8. ^ David Stewart Hull, Film in the Third Reich: A Study of the German Cinema 1933–1945, Berkeley/Los Angeles: University of California, 1969, OCLC 46409, p. 118.
  9. ^ Giesen, pp. 52–55, citing Roger Manvell, Films and the Second World War, South Brunswick, New Jersey: A. S. Barnes, 1974, ISBN 9780498014734, p. 51.
  10. ^ Reiner Rother, "'Stukas'. Zeitnaher Film unter Kriegsbedingungen", in Krieg und Militär im Film des 20. Jahrhunderts, pp. 349–70, p. 350.
  11. ^ Altmann, p. 62.
  12. ^ Welch, p. 247 (rev. ed., p. 211)
  13. ^ Welch, p. 189.
  14. ^ Ron Theodore Robin, The Barbed-Wire College: Reeducating German Pows in the United States During World War II, Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University, 1995, ISBN 9780691037004, p. 117.
  15. ^ Altmann, pp. 62–63.
  16. ^ Hull, p. 119.
  17. ^ Altmann, pp. 63–64.
  18. ^ New York Times review, 14 May 1938, quoted in Waldman, p. 166.
  19. ^ Unternehmen Michael, Friedrich Wilhelm Murnau Foundation, retrieved 5 December 2012 (in German)