After signing with Pluto Records,[1][2][3][4] the group quickly worked on their debut album. It was worked alongside Paul Leavitt, Matt Bayles, Dann Miler of The JonBenét, and Michael Fossenkemper at Turtle Tone Studios, Valencia studios, and Red Room Studios. On March 25, 2008, the band showcased some of their songs on MySpace and announced that Chad Middleton from VCR will feature in the effort on Blabbermouth.[5][6] They also got Ben Hirschhorn of Morning for the Masses to feature as well. The album features both Hall and Crawford as Drums and also features a cover for Push It from Salt 'N Pepa.
On September 18, 2009, lead vocalist Alison Bellavance announced on a MySpace blog that the band was disbanding due to "personal issues."[7][8]
Release and promotion
Before the release, the band held a CD release party on May 3, 2008, only in physical form with My America, Girlfight, HeyHey, and Innerpartysystem.[9] The band finally released their debut studio album Try This On For Size on May 6, 2008.[10]
The band announced a music video shoot on May 10 in 10 S. Main ST. Quakertown PA, where fans can attend and appear on the band's next music video. The music video was released on May 31, 2008, it was for the track “President of The Wrong Crowd” and it was directed by Adam Kobylarz.[9]
The track "Check Your Lease, You're In F**k City" appeared in Hardcore, Punk, Etc. 2008 on RevHQ.[11]
The album was met with positive reviews from many major outlets. Ryan Cooper from About.com said that the album have "an amalgam that is aggressive and fun, making a sound perfect for fans both on the dance floor in back or the pit down in front." Revolver Magazine adds 'So ridiculous, it's kinda awesome." Theprp adds "brash, oddly catchy and often abrasive, yet thanks to a variety of elements, ultimately charming as well."
Eduardo Rivadavia from All Music was more critical of the album, stating "Try This on for Size's prevailing electronic beats are bound to shoo away most metal and hardcore purists on principle alone, while the tuneless screeching that must be endured throughout will clear the average dancefloor faster than a three alarm fire." Lambgoat thought the same to an extent, explaining "the electronic influence is at its worst gimmicky and at its best an unnecessary supplement."
Teeth of the Divine was generous to the effort, adding "a pretty decent party album for dance, screamo and pop fans all mashed together in one catchy, quirky little album that’s certainly not for ‘real’ metal heads, but will have some odd appeal to the more curious metal fan." Chee Kam from V13 was very impressed, describing to the album "a certain theme throughout all the art." The group appeared in issue #46 of Decibel Magazine where they review the band's album.