Keister amassed a career batting average of .269, but he only managed two home runs across four minor league seasons before he retired from playing.[1]
As a coach
After leaving professional baseball, Keister latched on with the University of South Carolina as an assistant coach from 1996 to 1998. He was hired as head coach at Delaware State University, a role he filled from 1999 to 2000. For several years, he returned to professional baseball as a scout for the San Diego Padres, before he resumed a collegiate coaching role as head coach at Wesley College, a private liberal arts college in Dover, Delaware, in 2006.[citation needed] He served in that role and as also as the school's associate athletic director until 2011.[2]
The Washington Nationals hired Keister after five years coaching at Wesley College. He was named manager of the Gulf Coast League Nationals in 2012 and the Class-A Hagerstown Suns in 2013, before he was promoted to Class-A Advanced as manager of the Potomac Nationals.[citation needed] In December 2020, with the minor league Nationals—since relocated to Fredericksburg, Virginia, as the Fredericksburg Nationals—being relegated to Class-A play, the Nationals promoted Keister again to serve as coach of their Class-AA affiliate, the Harrisburg Senators.[3] Keister was fired from the Nationals organization in September 2022 by De Jon Watson, director of player development.[4]