The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey

The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey: A Disputed Genocide is a 2006 book by Guenter Lewy about the Armenian genocide in the Ottoman Empire. In the book, Lewy argues that the high death toll among Ottoman Armenians was a byproduct of the conditions of the marches and on sporadic attacks rather than a planned attempt to exterminate them.

The book was published by University of Utah Press after being rejected by eleven publishers and was promoted by the Turkish government. Although some reviewers who agreed with Lewy's belief that the Armenians were not victims of a genocide praised the book, its reception was overall negative with other reviewers identifying significant "errors of fact, interpretation, and omission".[1] Furthermore, the book was criticized for repeating the collective guilt argument used by the Young Turks to justify the genocide that they ordered.

Background

According to Professor Tessa Hofmann of Berlin's Free University, Lewy had conceived of the idea of writing on the Armenian genocide as early as 2000:

In the summer of 2000 a retiree, resting on my couch, expressed a strange intention. Guenter Lewy, the retired American political scientist, wanted to subject "the Armenian massacres" to a similar revision as he had done before with respect to the Sinti and the Roma. That revision, argued Lewy, had shown that even though their fate in World War II proved tragic, it did not represent a "real" genocide, as there were no centrally organized and state-sponsored premeditation and genocidal intention.[2]

Since he does not read Ottoman Turkish, Lewy relied on two unnamed individuals to translate materials for him.[3]

After it was rejected by eleven publishers including four university presses, the book's publication by University of Utah Press was arranged by M. Hakan Yavuz.[4][5]

Contents

The work focuses on the Armenian genocide during 1915-1916 and provides no coverage of subsequent years.[6]

Lewy argued that there was not enough evidence to support the conclusion that the Ottoman government deliberately attempted to destroy the Armenian population through a genocide.[7] Akçam stated that this was the "central thesis" of the book with this statement made on several occasions. The author stated that the high death toll was simply a byproduct of the conditions of the marches and on sporadic attacks rather than a planned attempt to kill the Armenians.[8][9]

According to the author, evidence that stated that the genocide was deliberate was doctored:[7] The Memoirs of Naim Bey,[8] the documents of the Turkish courts-martial of 1919–1920, and other documents related to the Special Organization (SO). He also argued that hearsay formed the basis of The Treatment of Armenians in the Ottoman Empire (nicknamed the "Blue Book"),[10] and that the speech made by Reşit Akif Pasha accusing the Committee of Union and Progress (CUP) Central Committee of instigating a genocide was dishonestly made.[11]

Lewy, who decided that a lack of competence in the Ottoman authorities was the reason for the deaths,[10] as well as local government officials disobeying the central government,[12] includes criticisms of the Ottoman government, stating that it took too harsh action against perceived Armenian threats,[13] that the number of Armenian deaths and amount of damage exceeded that of what the Turks experienced, and that the Ottoman government did not provide adequate protections for any ethnic group.[7]

Lewy's book criticizes the work of many scholars of the Armenian Genocide, including Donald Bloxham, Richard Hovannisian, Taner Akçam, Erik Jan Zürcher, Ronald Suny, Robert Melson, Leo Kuper, and David Lang, but especially Vahakn Dadrian.[7][3]

Reception

Methodology

Akçam argued that the central thesis of the book was an unproven theory while Lewy himself argued that the idea of genocide being planned was a theory; Akçam also stated that there were other documents that proved the genocide was planned.[14] Akçam also stated that the author misinterpreted some documents, that his lack of skills in Turkish hampered his research,[15] and that Lewy was not informed of current research. In addition Akçam disliked the author's dichotomy of "Armenian" and "Turkish" "sides" to the Armenian genocide denial dispute,[16] as it conflates Armenians of differing allegiances together and because "it should be an unacceptable attitude for a social scientist to classify the differences of interpretation of these events according to ethnic origin."[17]

Historian Richard Hovannisian discusses the book in an academic article on Armenian genocide denial, stating, "Like others in the modern period actively contesting the use of the term genocide for the Armenian case, Lewy picks and chooses bits of information and quotations to build his case."[5] Joseph A. Kéchichian also criticized the book for denying the genocide and resorting to "pronounced selectivity of data, deflection, distortion, and occasional falsification" to support this thesis.[9] Historian Hilmar Kaiser states that Lewy's "explanations for the causes of Armenian deaths remain unconvincing" and that, on points that did not fit his thesis, "Lewy chose to ignore the archival and published records". Kaiser states that "Lewy does not clearly distinguish between academic studies, pamphlets, various types of memoirs" and "major parts of the book do not meet academic standards".[18]

Armenian genocide denial

In the book, Lewy states that "the Armenians can hardly claim that they suffered for no reason at all... large numbers of them had fought the Turks openly or played the role of a fifth column; not surprisingly, with their backs against the wall, the Ottomans reacted resolutely, if not viciously". A. Dirk Moses responds to this "telling slip", stating that Lewy falls into the trap of attributing collective guilt from Armenian combatants to the defenceless women and children from other parts of the country who were deported. Moses notes that law of war makes a strict distinction between civilians and combatants and that "The collective guilt accusation is unacceptable in scholarship, let alone in normal discourse and is, I think, one of the key ingredients in genocidal thinking."[19] Quoting the same passage, Thomas de Waal writes that "Lewy repeats the Young Turks’ trick of justifying collective punishment of a whole nation".[20]

According to Marc A. Mamigonian, the book is one of "the key texts of modern denial". Mamigonian faults Lewy for making excuses for the Ottoman government's actions.[4] Norman Naimark does not consider the book to be denialist, but is nevertheless critical of Lewy's main argument: "if Lewy wishes to maintain his claims to historical objectivity by using accepted judicial definitions of genocide, then the difficulty of finding direct evidence for the Young Turks’ premeditated planning of mass murder should not prevent him from concluding that genocide took place. At its core, then, Lewy’s argument is illogical".[21]

McCarthy wrote that it as "an outstanding work of historiography".[7] Michael M. Gunter, after having written a positive statement that was used on the cover of The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey, wrote a review of the book for the International Journal of Middle East Studies (IJMES) without the editors' knowledge that he had made the positive statement. History News Network stated that the review "reportedly arrived in their office sans cover."[22] Two academics, Joseph A. Kéchichian,[23] and Keith David Watenpaugh,[24] criticized the presence of the review in the IJMES. Gunter issued a response to his critics.[22]

References

Notes

  1. ^ Watenpaugh, Keith David (2007). "A Response to Michael Gunter's Review of The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey: A Disputed Genocide (IJMES 38 [2006]: 598–601)". International Journal of Middle East Studies. 39 (3): 512–514. doi:10.1017/S0020743807070869. S2CID 161727102. The majority of the postpublication reviews of Lewy's work have identified obvious and egregious errors of fact, interpretation, and omission most of which presumably would have been caught had the text been carefully scrutinized by competent and nonpartisan readers.
  2. ^ See Taner Akçam, "Guenter Lewy’s The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey." Genocide Studies and Prevention, 3:1 April 2008, pp. 111–43.
  3. ^ a b Kéchichian, Joseph A. (2007). "A Response to Michael Gunter's Review of The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey: A Disputed Genocide (IJMES 38 [2006]: 598–601)". International Journal of Middle East Studies. 39 (3): 509–512. doi:10.1017/S0020743807070857. ISSN 0020-7438. JSTOR 30069560. S2CID 162021204. One is dealing here with a book whose author admits a lack of familiarity with both Ottoman and Turkish languages. Lewy declares that he does not know Turkish at all and that he had to depend on"two Turkish speaking persons" (p. 292, n. 112) as well as on others"who have translated some important Turkish materials for me" (p. xiii). However, departing from a very common standard procedure, Lewy repeatedly avoids identifying those who, he says, helped him in the matter of translation of numerous documents. Would it be unfair to ask, under these circumstances, why go to such a highly unusual act of withholding?
  4. ^ a b Mamigonian, Marc A. (2015). "Academic Denial of the Armenian Genocide in American Scholarship: Denialism as Manufactured Controversy". Genocide Studies International. 9 (1): 61–82. doi:10.3138/gsi.9.1.04. S2CID 154623321.
  5. ^ a b Hovannisian, Richard G. (2015). "Denial of the Armenian Genocide 100 Years Later: The New Practitioners and Their Trade". Genocide Studies International. 9 (2): 228–247. doi:10.3138/gsi.9.2.04. S2CID 155132689.
  6. ^ Erickson, Edward J. (Spring 2006). "ARMENIANS: The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey: A Disputed Genocide". The Middle East Journal. Archived from the original on 2019-06-22. Retrieved 2019-06-22.
  7. ^ a b c d e McCarthy, p. 337.
  8. ^ a b Akçam, p. 112.
  9. ^ a b Kéchichian, Joseph (2007). "The Armenian Genocide and an Updated Denial Initiative: A Review Essay". Genocide Studies and Prevention. 2 (2): 173–181. doi:10.3138/gsp.2.2.173. ISSN 1911-0359. Lewy systematically uses and emphasizes the term relocation throughout his book; this prejudicial stance is striking, and the theme of relocation truly dominates the text. According to Lewy, Turkish authorities had no intention of liquidating the Armenian population but were merely trying to deport and resettle that population; their blunders and failures in the process caused massive but unintended casualties. To foster this perspective, Lewy relies on several techniques, including pronounced selectivity of data, deflection, distortion, and occasional falsification.
  10. ^ a b Akçam, p. 114.
  11. ^ Akçam, p. 113.
  12. ^ Akçam, p. 115.
  13. ^ Brown, L. Carl (2006-05-01). "The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey: A Disputed Genocide". Foreign Affairs. Retrieved 2019-06-22. {{cite magazine}}: Cite magazine requires |magazine= (help)
  14. ^ Akçam, p. 116.
  15. ^ Akçam, p. 117.
  16. ^ Akçam, p. 118.
  17. ^ Akçam, p. 119.
  18. ^ Kaiser, Hilmar (2010). "The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey—A Disputed Genocide". Die Welt des Islams (in German). 50 (1): 181–183. doi:10.1163/004325309X12451617197064. ISSN 1570-0607.
  19. ^ Anderson, Margaret Lavinia; Reynolds, Michael; Kieser, Hans-Lukas; Balakian, Peter; Moses, A. Dirk; Akçam, Taner (2013). "Taner Akçam, The Young Turks' crime against humanity: the Armenian genocide and ethnic cleansing in the Ottoman Empire (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2012)". Journal of Genocide Research. 15 (4): 463–509. doi:10.1080/14623528.2013.856095. S2CID 73167962. This is a telling slip; Lewy is talking about 'the Armenians' as if the defenceless women and children who comprised the deportation columns were vicariously responsible for Armenian rebels in other parts of the country. The collective guilt accusation is unacceptable in scholarship, let alone in normal discourse and is, I think, one of the key ingredients in genocidal thinking. It fails to distinguish between combatants and non-combatants, on which international humanitarian law has been insisting for over a hundred years now.
  20. ^ de Waal, Thomas (2015). Great Catastrophe: Armenians and Turks in the Shadow of Genocide. Oxford University Press. p. 63. ISBN 978-0-19-935069-8.
  21. ^ Naimark, N. M. (2007). "The Great Game of Genocide: Imperialism, Nationalism, and the Destruction of the Ottoman Armenians, Donald Bloxham (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005), xiv + 329 pp., cloth $39.95, pbk $26.95. * The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey: A Disputed Genocide, Guenter Lewy (Salt Lake City: The University of Utah Press, 2005), xiii + 370 pp., cloth $24.95". Holocaust and Genocide Studies. 21 (2): 298–303. doi:10.1093/hgs/dcm023.
  22. ^ a b "Michael Gunter: He blurbed a book ... Should he then have reviewed it?". History News Network. Columbian College of Arts and Sciences, George Washington University. 2007-08-17. Retrieved 2019-06-23.
  23. ^ Kéchichian, p. 509.
  24. ^ Watenpaugh, Extract.

Further reading

Read other articles:

Pulka

Pulka sedang diseret oleh seorang peski. Anak kecil bermain pulka. Pulka adalah sebutan dalam bahasa Swedia untuk eretan salju berukuran kecil untuk olahraga meluncur dan alat pengangkutan.[1] Eretan ini diseret oleh anjing, rusa kutub, atau orang sewaktu berski. Pulka berbentuk seperti perahu kecil, memiliki dasar yang cembung, dan tidak memiliki tidak memiliki alas luncur. Orang memakai pulka untuk mengangkut perbekalan seperti tenda, makanan, atau membawa anak kecil/orang lain. Di ...

 

 

Ste. Genevieve Catholic Church

Church in Missouri, United StatesSte. Genevieve Catholic Church37°58′45″N 90°02′50″W / 37.97917°N 90.04722°W / 37.97917; -90.04722LocationSte. Genevieve, MissouriCountryUnited StatesDenominationCatholicHistoryFounded30 April 1876 (1876-04-30)ConsecratedSeptember 29, 1880Cult(s) presentSte. GenevieveRelics heldAbout two dozenArchitectureArchitect(s)Francis Xavier Weiss Ste. Genevieve Catholic Church is a Roman Catholic church located in Ste. G...

 

 

Yelena Yevtyukhova

Russian politician Yelena YevtyukhovaЕлена ЕвтюховаMember of the State Duma from Chukotka constituency of Chukotka AOIncumbentAssumed office 19 September 2021Preceded byValentina Rudchenko Personal detailsBorn (1970-08-07) 7 August 1970 (age 53)Ust-Belaya, Anadyrsky District, Chukotka National Okrug, Magadan Oblast, Russian SFSR, Soviet UnionPolitical partyUnited RussiaAlma materMoscow State University of Economics, Statistics, and Informatics Yelena Aleksandrovna Yevtyu...

SS Vaderland (1900)

Ocean liner Vaderland, seen in 1910 History Name 1900: Vaderland 1915: Southland OwnerInternational Navigation Company Operator 1901: American Line (charter) 1903–1914: Red Star Line 1914–1917: White Star–Dominion Port of registry 1900: Liverpool 1903: Antwerp 1914: Liverpool Route 1900: Antwerp – Southampton – New York 1901: Southampton – Cherbourg – New York 1903: Antwerp – New York 1914: Liverpool – New York 1914: Liverpool – Halifax – Portland, Maine 1915: (troopship...

 

 

Roberto Andò

Questa voce o sezione sugli argomenti teatro e registi è priva o carente di note e riferimenti bibliografici puntuali. Sebbene vi siano una bibliografia e/o dei collegamenti esterni, manca la contestualizzazione delle fonti con note a piè di pagina o altri riferimenti precisi che indichino puntualmente la provenienza delle informazioni. Puoi migliorare questa voce citando le fonti più precisamente. Segui i suggerimenti dei progetti di riferimento 1, 2. Roberto Andò (a destra) con Ma...

 

 

وولفرين والإكس- من (مسلسل)

يفتقر محتوى هذه المقالة إلى الاستشهاد بمصادر. فضلاً، ساهم في تطوير هذه المقالة من خلال إضافة مصادر موثوق بها. أي معلومات غير موثقة يمكن التشكيك بها وإزالتها. (سبتمبر 2023) تحتاج هذه المقالة إلى تهذيب لتتناسب مع دليل الأسلوب في ويكيبيديا. فضلاً، ساهم في تهذيب هذه المقالة من خلا...

Ionis Pharmaceuticals

Biotechnology company This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article contains content that is written like an advertisement. Please help improve it by removing promotional content and inappropriate external links, and by adding encyclopedic content written from a neutral point of view. (December 2018) (Learn how and when to remove this message) This article needs to be updat...

 

 

Avenue House

Avenue House from East End Road Avenue House (also known as Stephens House) is a large Victorian mansion (Grade II listed) situated on East End Road in Finchley in the London Borough of Barnet. Built in 1859 on land formerly known as Temple Croft Field, it was acquired in 1874 by ink magnate and philanthropist Henry Charles Stephens (Inky) who later enlarged and improved the house and grounds with advice from well-known landscape gardener Robert Marnock (1800–89). On his death in 1918 Step...

 

 

Bar association

Professional body of lawyers This article is about the professional body of lawyers. For other uses, see Bar (disambiguation). For the broader meaning of bar in legal contexts, see Bar (law). For the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode, see Bar Association (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine). This article includes a list of general references, but it lacks sufficient corresponding inline citations. Please help to improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (July 2015) (Learn how and w...

Hongkongers

Permanent residents of Hong Kong This article needs to be updated. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information. (January 2023) For the local Cantonese dialect, see Hong Kong Cantonese. Ethnic group Hongkongers香港人Total populationc. 7.413 million[1]Regions with significant populations Hong Kong7,413,070[2] Mainland China472,900[3] United States330,000[needs update][4] Canada213,855[needs...

 

 

Red Rock River (Montana)

River in Montana, United StatesRed Rock RiverUpper Red Rock Lake near headwaters of Red Rock RiverLocation of mouthLocationCountryUnited StatesStateMontanaCountyBeaverheadPhysical characteristicsMouth  • coordinates44°56′33″N 112°50′43″W / 44.94250°N 112.84528°W / 44.94250; -112.84528 (Red Rock River)[1] • elevation5,545 feet (1,690 m)[1]Length70 miles (110 km)Basin size1,548 square...

 

 

Rail transport in Libya

There have been no operational railways in Libya since 1965, but various lines existed in the past. Since 1998, plans for an extensive system have been developed,[1] but work has largely halted since the outbreak of the First Libyan Civil War in 2011. History See also: Italian Libya Railways Map of the colonial railway in Libya before the 1960s Arrival of the first locomotive in the harbour of Tripoli, around 1912 Littorina passing Tripoli Central Railway Station in the 1930s Janzour...

Frances Power Cobbe

Philosopher and women's suffrage and animal welfare activist (1822-1904) Frances Power CobbePortrait from Life of Frances Power Cobbe, 1894Born(1822-12-04)4 December 1822Newbridge House, County Dublin, IrelandDied5 April 1904(1904-04-05) (aged 81)Hengwrt, WalesOccupation(s)Writer, social reformer, philosopherKnown for Founding the Society for the Protection of Animals Liable to Vivisection (1875) and British Union for the Abolition of Vivisection (1898) Being a member of the executi...

 

 

Languages of the Philippines

Languages of the PhilippinesOverview of the spread and overlap of the languages spoken throughout the country as of March 2017, by the KWF (Komisyon sa Wikang Filipino)OfficialFilipino and EnglishNationalFilipino[1]RegionalAklanonArabicCentral BikolCebuanoChavacanoHiligaynon/IlonggoIbanagIlocanoIvatanKapampangan/PampangoKinaray-aMaguindanaoMaranaoPangasinan/PangasinenseSambalSpanishSurigaononTagalogTausūgWarayYakan[2]VernacularMalay (Indonesian · Malaysian)Philippine Spanis...

 

 

Lost television broadcast

History of missing television material Lost episode redirects here. For other uses, see Lost episode (disambiguation). This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Lost television broadcas...

Tranvia Novara-Biandrate

Tranvia Novara-BiandrateInizioNovara FineBiandrate Inaugurazione1884 Chiusura1934 GestoreSocietà Ferrovie del Ticino Lunghezza11,8 km Tipotranvia Scartamento1.445 mm Trasporto pubblico Manuale La tranvia Novara-Biandrate, naturale complemento della coeva Vercelli-Biandrate-Fara, era parte di un esteso insieme di linee gestito dalla Società Ferrovie del Ticino. Inaugurato nel 1884, la trazione a vapore non consentì di mantenere tale servizio concorrenziale rispetto al nascente trasport...

 

 

Withycombe

For the surname, see Withycombe (surname). Human settlement in EnglandWithycombeChurch of St Nicholas, WithycombeWithycombeLocation within SomersetPopulation293 (2011)[1]OS grid referenceSS825385DistrictSomerset West and TauntonShire countySomersetRegionSouth WestCountryEnglandSovereign stateUnited KingdomPost townMineheadPostcode districtTA24PoliceAvon and SomersetFireDevon and SomersetAmbulanceSouth Western UK ParliamentBridgwater and West Somerset...

 

 

Attukal Pongala

Indian religious festival Aatukaal PongalaObserved byHindus of KeralaTypeReligious, culturalDateper Hindu calendar2023 dateTuesday, 7 March[1]2024 dateSunday, 25 February[2]FrequencyAnnual Attukal Pongala is a 10-day religious festival celebrated at the Attukal Bhagavathy Temple in Thiruvananthapuram in the Indian state of Kerala. On the ninth day there is a huge gathering of millions of women on the temple surroundings. These women prepare a divine food made of...

Krabi F.C.

Thai football club This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Krabi F.C. – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (December 2021) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Football clubKrabi กระบี่ เอฟซีFull nameKrabi Football Club สโมสรฟุตบอลจัง�...

 

 

Sonja Fuss

German footballer (born 1978) Sonja Fuss Fuss in 2019Personal informationFull name Sonja Beate Fuss[1]Date of birth (1978-11-05) 5 November 1978 (age 45)Place of birth Bonn, West GermanyHeight 1.67 m (5 ft 5+1⁄2 in)Position(s) DefenderYouth career Grün-Weiß BrauweilerCollege careerYears Team Apps (Gls)1998–1999 Hartford Hawks Senior career*Years Team Apps (Gls)0000–2004 FFC Brauweiler Pulheim 89 2004–2005 FSV Frankfurt 11 (2)2005 1. FFC Turbine Potsda...