Template documentationviewedithistorypurge Shortcut {{contradictTemplate:Contradict}} This template will categorize tagged articles into Category:Self-contradictory...

This template will categorise tagged articles into Category:Articles contradicting other articles. This template is a self-reference. This template should...

This template will categorise tagged articles into Category:Articles contradicting other articles. This template is a self-reference. This template should...

This template is used to mark sentences or phrases that contradict other material in the same page by default, or a different page if one...

{{Contradicts others}} {{Contradicts others/sandbox}} Love {{Contradicts others}} {{Contradicts others/sandbox}} Love {{Contradicts others}} {{Contradicts...

Shortcut {{contradictTemplate:Contradict}} This template will categorize tagged articles into Category:Self-contradictory articles. This template is a...

This template is used to mark sentences or phrases that contradict other material in the same page by default, or a different page if one is specified...

Template documentationviewedithistorypurge Shortcut {{contradictTemplate:Contradict}} This template will categorize tagged articles into Category:Self-contradictory...

contradictory statement will add the article to this category. Use {{Contradict|date={{{month name}}} {{{year}}}}} for the whole article or section. If...

This section appears to contradict itself. Please see the talk page for more information....

mark statements that are inconsistent with other parts of the article. {{Contradict-inline}}, for outright contradictions The above documentation is transcluded...

Love...

header templates {{humorantipolicy}} – for essays whose humor is that they contradict a policy {{humor}} designed for non-essays (not humorous mainspace encyclopedic...

This template is used to mark sentences or phrases that contradict other material in the same page by default, or a different page if one...

header templates {{humorantipolicy}} – for essays whose humor is that they contradict a policy {{humor}} designed for non-essays (not humorous mainspace encyclopedic...

are platformers (2), Sonic is the main character (3), and they do not contradict each other (4). Sonic Rush and the Sonic Advance series belong in the...

... that some canons of the Canon law of the Eastern Orthodox Church contradict each others? Source: Vasile, Mihai (2017). "Introduction". Orthodox canon...

state BOTH viewpoints in accord with WP:BALANCE: "When reputable sources contradict one another, the core of the NPOV policy is to let competing approaches...

Passed as it meets criteria, I prefer the alternative hook as it seems to contradict itself (although it is referenced in the article). James086Talk | Email...

websites are used when they provide more details. None of the sources contradict each other, and often both more- and less- well-known media sites cite...

audience, but it seems to contradict a part of the article: it states that the film was considered a gay film, but this was contradicted by its director. Perhaps...

header templates {{humorantipolicy}} – for essays whose humor is that they contradict a policy {{humor}} designed for non-essays (not humorous mainspace encyclopedic...

this article from the Dictionary of African Christian Biography, which contradicts numerous facts stated in your article, such the spelling of her last...

f-block rows (despite that giving 15 f-block elements in each row, which contradicts quantum mechanics), leaving the heavier members of group 3 ambiguous...

to separate the two parts of that sentence. The second part was not contradicting or qualifying the first. Rather, it meant that more than 2/3 resolve...

source, but not mentioned in the Farwell & Co. article and seeming to contradict Wadsworth's 1863 retirement) and Farwell supervised their training. The...

discussed on the article's talk page, the article (and sources) seem to contradict each other regarding where Geddes was in 1912/3 (which is not material...

that according to media outlet WLOS, surveillance footage appears to contradict the police's initial account of the shooting of Jason Harley Kloepfer...

copyedit no matter what else shakes out. There is also material that contradicts Tohono O'odham#Tohono O'odham Nation, which states it is the third largest...

interesting, and appropriately referenced. Moghra Oasis has a maintenance tag ({Contradict}), which should be dealt with. The hook is neutreal and interesting, and...

are generally accepted throughout the United Kingdom." which seems to contradict itself. Are they legal tender or not? Andrew D. (talk) 12:42, 7 June 2016...

dont think it is a problem to cite argenpress.info, since it doesn't contradict anything in any of the other sources.User:Maunus ·ʍaunus·snunɐw· 22:56...

Coldwell (talk) 19:36, 11 August 2015 (UTC) The article and the source contradict themselves over this; both later state there is limited phosphate mining...

about Ely was that he was an intellectual maverick who was willing to contradict his own beliefs (as the above DYK shows). The law review article mentioned...

shouldn't be capitalized. The article does mention that there are some contradicting opinions on which tree is the true one, so consider changing "was blown...

cannot read, the article meets all the criteria. However, it seems to contradict Dongfeng Motor in describing it as the second-biggest car maker. Please...

of September 2022 (and I'm not aware of any sources that specifically contradict this, just some that are less precise). But if it's the latter, I can...

Inconsistent This template is used to mark statements that are inconsistent with other parts of the article. {{Contradict-inline}}, for outright contradictions...

article states that his second novel 'required no editing', which seems to contradict the statement in the hook that she edited it. I'd also personally like...

and the complaining party is not at fault ... This appears to directly contradict the holding in Throckmorton, yet Throckmorton was cited as the authority...

Asia? What is this article about? The Title, contradicts the lede I think, and that seems to contradict the sub-headings. Ping me when the subject is...

(talk) 07:05, 11 December 2018 (UTC) Well ALT0 is interesting because it contradicted previous theories about it. Joseph2302 (talk) 07:23, 11 December 2018...

best bet, and then the secondary sources also help, although they also contradict the newspapers, so I used that in there in order to expand the prose....

sources contradict this, stating that the origin is disputed. ▫ JohnnyMrNinja 10:01, 11 May 2012 (UTC) Later sources do not actually contradict Shaw; rather...

then it can be "remixed" to remove the watermark, which would seem to contradict the intention of the uploader. Gobōnobo + c 23:11, 2 May 2012 (UTC) Very...

--Gerda Arendt (talk) 17:49, 14 March 2015 (UTC) The hook (and article) contradict the source, which says that she found that African-Amercian babies learn...

not make sense, I wish to make it clear that it does becuase we cannot contradict what the producer said. And the source never used songs It used the word...

2015 (UTC) Unless I'm mistaken, doesn't the article Parliament Square contradict the hook? Fuebaey (talk) 15:01, 16 February 2015 (UTC) Not mistaken -...

and does not the fact that the Little Mahanoy Creek contains wild trout contradict the hook? Cwmhiraeth (talk) 07:22, 11 January 2016 (UTC) Note the "in...

17:43, 7 May 2014 (UTC). Date and expansion fine. However, the hook is contradicted by the article in that it says that Northern were there from 1908 to...

discussion of the flag there). In fact, the Britannica article seems to contradict the claim and suggests that the Islamic symbolism wasn't intentional -...

"By 1860 the hospital was nearing its capacity of 350" which appears to contradict the hook. Please determine which cours of events is correct (the sources...

obituary, but the details available in the abstract on Proquest don't contradict the way the source is used. I conducted a spot check against Reports of...

code, a public health law, and an international treaty, all of which contradict each other? Source: [1] As of 2019, the country had three concurrent provisions:...

Nachrichten says that she's defending her women's title (which seems to contradict the main hook proposed), and that in addition she's playing in the general...

rioting (in the article or the hook). To say three nights, however, would contradict some sources and require a explanatory footnote at the least. –Reidgreg...

geology enough understand a distinction, but don't reference 4 and 5 contradict each other in terms of the names and numbers of volcanic features? Best...

Template:Cleanup split Template:Summarize section Template:Duplication Template:Contradicts other The above documentation is transcluded from Template:Summarize/doc...

years old, which would still point back to 1877. The two sources still contradict each other, no matter which date you choose to base your information on...

history ) ... that Chien-Shiung Wu conducted the Wu experiment, which contradicted the hypothetical law of conservation of parity? Reviewed: Template:Did...

wasn't rebuilt. On a first casual reading, the hook seems to be partially contradicted later in the article, when we're told the eastern cloisters were rebuilt—I...

depending on your definition of "Eastern United States," actually appears to contradict both the article's claim and the first citation's claim about this car...

hook accordingly. This also ties into the hook overall, which seems to contradict itself. Thanks. Jolly Ω Janner 08:43, 18 March 2016 (UTC) Speak Life is...

alignment is not affected by the current version, which doesn't surprise me but contradicts documentation. Wnt (talk) 02:53, 6 February 2012 (UTC) {{{1}}}...

Theleekycauldron Nice catch. It seems that the statistics for the second source contradict themselves. I'm assuming that the 17 students in the body may have been...

same order as the sources, and not using so many similar terms" seems to contradict your previous remarks. Apparently when I change the wording (whitish-brown...

chapter XIII, the one you gave in ref2. Second, the article infobox contradicts the text. It says he was Acting governor from June 1644, while text claims...

explorers. I had quite a time interpreting Appletons; sometimes it seemed to contradict itself. :) I'd be happy to see additional resources brought in to improve...

2014 (UTC) Also the last sentence of the opening paragraph now seems to contradict the opening of the Microraptoria article which notes larger genera are...

retrieved his journal against his captain's orders, and its publication contradicted the captain's claims about their chances of survival? Source: " he managed...

it to the other, but it's not clear to me whether the various sources contradict or complement each other on this point. Apart from that, nice work; I...

this point it just gets bureaucratic - the linked film articles do not contradict the fact that Yip directed the series and Yen played the lead. However...

claim is credible, especially considering that no more recent sources contradict it. Nevertheless, ALT1: ... that in the 1990s, Little Crooked Run was...

SchroCat (talk). Self nominated at 08:06, 23 February 2015 (UTC). The hook contradicts Portraits of Vincent van Gogh, which states in Remarks that "Self-portrait...

reason I put up the quote of Wiki guideline here is for other editors to contradict me if they feel like. All other requirement are met, Texas can stay if...

direct break from Modern architecture, designed in order to disrupt and contradict formal Modernist aesthetics.[14] More simply, Venturi demonstrated his...

are platformers (2), Sonic is the main character (3), and they do not contradict each other (4). Sonic Rush and the Sonic Advance series belong in the...

so I'd say no to this nomination. Anyhow other editors are welcomed to contradict me and re-review the artilce if they feel so. Lajbi Holla @ me • CP 15:03...

rediscovered!", but is more accurate. When reliable sources apparently contradict each other (or objective reality), only the most authoritative source(s)...

species is threatened by habitat loss, but the Status section directly contradicts the claim. This is the only issue, but it should be addressed nonetheless...

(not obsolete, so active), |is-obsolete=<any text> is yes (obsolete) N Contradicting situation: Obsolete vs. Active. By default |code-priority=no, so |is-obsolete=T/F...

orders for that year amounted to only 900 pieces." The second sentence contradicts the first. Hybernator (talk) 21:50, 25 August 2013 (UTC) Done. Good spotting :)...

discriminated against Turkish Jews? This is interesting because it shows the contradicting nature of Turkish policies. It also shows the good and the bad that...

Comment: This article was a pain to write thanks to sources managing to contradict each other in various ways. These three hooks seem relatively uncontested...

occurred between 1,000,000 and 750,000 years ago". These views seem to contradict each other. It seems as if there are varying views and that you have arbitrarily...

decided to quit the Iran nuclear deal in 2018. but the source plainly contradicts this, stating It was among five vessels designated by the US on February...

hook. Boring. The second hook is supported by the first source, but is contradicted by the second. This assassination was unsolved, and some pin it on the...

source. I see that it proposed new rules, and that it "repealed" laws that contradict it, but not that it amends existing law. Yoninah (talk) 22:57, 14 August...

this claim comes from an online petition, and presents evidence that contradicts it being the direct inspiration. Perhaps the hook should say that it...

is classified as a stub even through it appears to. Am unsure if I can contradict / override DYKcheck and so will mark as "maybe" for the moment. Maximilian775...

(not obsolete, so active), |is-obsolete=<any text> is yes (obsolete) N Contradicting situation: Obsolete vs. Active. By default |code-priority=no, so |is-obsolete=T/F...

time you get more - contradicting - results by searching "Andrea Pisani". So you should sort out your own sources to not contradict each other and give...

(not obsolete, so active), |is-obsolete=<any text> is yes (obsolete) N Contradicting situation: Obsolete vs. Active. By default |code-priority=no, so |is-obsolete=T/F...

(not obsolete, so active), |is-obsolete=<any text> is yes (obsolete) N Contradicting situation: Obsolete vs. Active. By default |code-priority=no, so |is-obsolete=T/F...

the two hooks I prefer ALT0, but the hook tense and the article seem to contradict each other: the hook says that he used to sell ice cream, but the article...

correct title and provide a proper citation for it. References 5 and 6 contradict each other - one states the building was constructed in 1879, the other...

(not obsolete, so active), |is-obsolete=<any text> is yes (obsolete) N Contradicting situation: Obsolete vs. Active. By default |code-priority=no, so |is-obsolete=T/F...

(not obsolete, so active), |is-obsolete=<any text> is yes (obsolete) N Contradicting situation: Obsolete vs. Active. By default |code-priority=no, so |is-obsolete=T/F...

(not obsolete, so active), |is-obsolete=<any text> is yes (obsolete) N Contradicting situation: Obsolete vs. Active. By default |code-priority=no, so |is-obsolete=T/F...

(UTC). ALT3: ... that the text in the epilogue of video game Device 6 contradicts with its visuals? This is probably unacceptable since the plot is not...

sentences). However, I have a problem with the hook, as it somewhat contradicts what is said in the body (i.e. the hook says its illegal because the...

(not obsolete, so active), |is-obsolete=<any text> is yes (obsolete) N Contradicting situation: Obsolete vs. Active. By default |code-priority=no, so |is-obsolete=T/F...

offline sourcing. Nice article. Thanks (Just spotted that second hook contradicts the Blue Hall article and the Nobel banquet article) Victuallers (talk)...

(not obsolete, so active), |is-obsolete=<any text> is yes (obsolete) N Contradicting situation: Obsolete vs. Active. By default |code-priority=no, so |is-obsolete=T/F...

23:42, 27 April 2016 (UTC) I pulled this from prep 1 because the article contradicts the hook. The article says "The greatest vote-share any single party...

(not obsolete, so active), |is-obsolete=<any text> is yes (obsolete) N Contradicting situation: Obsolete vs. Active. By default |code-priority=no, so |is-obsolete=T/F...

22:19, 1 November 2015 (UTC) @Sillyfolkboy: Er, the cites you've added contradict what's in the claim (the table shows France finishing second, not third)...

the hook. Ignoring the fact that it's a bit dull, it seems to actually contradict the article's contents. By my count 22 of the states listed use the Euro...

research. I am citing reliable secondary sources. Please show which sources contradict other reliable sources, preferably on talk. --Piotr Konieczny aka Prokonsul...

Gerber House is the second LGBT history designation. The ref seems to contradict the article when it says: "For example, some properties already designated...

she eradicated the disease entirely, which any number of sources would contradict. Is there a firmer source, or should we just go with the 4,000? theleekycauldron...

April 2013 (UTC) Noting that the term has been used in 2006 does not contradict that the All-China Women's Federation coined the term. The Ministry of...

the idea that Solomon Linda was cheated, which maybe doesn't directly contradict the exploitation argument but perhaps should be mentioned in the article...

is to develop a hook that verifies to the sources and resolve the {{Contradicts other}} tag I've placed on the article. theleekycauldron (talk • she/her)...

citation is provided for the specific claim in the hook. Also, the lede contradicts the hook by stating that "most" rather than "all other known" pterosaurs...

song, when a group was involved. More importantly, Kelly's blog post is contradicted by a number of other sources which say that Akon has overstated his influence...

I added some words on Gürsel's views on them and that those scholars contradict his views. Other works I read appear to assume the reader knows Kurds...

Thanks for your feedback,Crispulop. You're right, the sources seem to contradict each other (sometimes even themselves!) re the locations and the confusion...

the hook. Moreover, the hook fact is referenced to the two papers that contradict each other, and that is not perfect (because of the dependence of the...

failed. Narutolovehinata5 tccsdnew 11:31, 20 May 2019 (UTC) Sorry to contradict, but I think the first hook is very interesting. Who would have expected...

Nominated by Rosiestep (talk) at 00:53, 9 June 2015 (UTC). The article contradicts itself with differing accounts in the lede and the history section, and...

this a full review, but on a first glance, the quote seems to directly contradict the hook, which gives a figure of "2,000 meters" instead (it should be...

dubious not only because they start "In some species", which seems to contradict the article being about a single species called Furcifer balteatus. Worse...

helium. Her groundbreaking conclusion was initially rejected because it contradicted the scientific wisdom of the time, which held that there were no significant...

wasn't yet opera director when he played in the film, and "once" seems to contradict the "many films", sounding like a one-time-exception to me. --Gerda Arendt...

third sentence ("This policy") seems off—the first clause appears to contradict the second—and the final sentence needs a bit more context. The second...

confusing as the two sentences are not in chronological order and seem to contradict one another.) Cwmhiraeth (talk) 05:45, 10 September 2020 (UTC) Thank you...

portion of the preceding text", but three of the four "supporting" points contradict that claim. Clarityfiend (talk) 00:18, 5 March 2021 (UTC) I've brought...

2012 (UTC) Sorry, I missed that tag. I have removed the claim, as it is contradicted by other info and best omitted as poorly sourced and not relevant to...

payola (not a proper noun). No close paraphrasing detected. ALT0 is contradicted by the article as the practice still persists. ALT1 is backed up by the...

aqe and length qualify, and references check out. However, the hook contradicts the second paragraph of the article, which says that she was diagnosed...

which might mean Northern Cyprus or might not. but then the sub-headline contradicts the headline and says that it's almost the only place? And then the claim...

1 October 2020 (UTC) @Lajmmoore: the very first line of the article contradicts the hook fact. And there is no inline cite for the hook fact per WP:DYK#Cited...

(UTC) Having had time to take a closer look at the sources, it seems they contradict one another with regard to the time the flag was first used. So here's...

original hook. Two sources for the fact were provided, and the hook contradicts the online source. I've added a bit more material from that source and...

sukhaya bahujana hitaya cha... was suggested by... Swami Vivekananda" is contradicted. It seems it was suggested by Gautama Buddha, interpreted and promoted...

be his date of service.[6]. Now, the 27th P.S. reference would seem to contradict his saying he was with The 94th (Rickenbacker). However, this blog post...

by Crisco 1492 (talk) at 04:41, 11 August 2012 (UTC) The hook fact is contradicted several times in the first few sentences. Or at least its strongly suggested...

true (the best-known Hurricane Shark image remains a hoax) and b) that contradicts what reliable sources say, which is that it is real (again, regardless...

17:56, 11 August 2015 (UTC) The hook fact is uncited in the lede and contradicted by the final sentence of the lede and in the history section. Belle (talk)...

one more, the first year is a year and the last ;) - also I should not contradict the source + it's the prettier number + it doesn't matter, is only a synonym...

elections are separate and tend not to occur at the same time. That seems to contradict what you've written above. Would you consider renaming this "Double direct...

which starts with "Tetrads are not uncommon" needs a citation, since it contradicts the "rarity" of the tetrads claim. April 2014 lunar eclipse: 5-fold expansion...

a DAB page. The use of the term "canal boats" is neutral and does not contradict any sources; it is a generic term that will cover any vessels on the British...

"where the music and entertainment used to go around the clock" seems contradicted by source. At one point it says it was 24/hours per day. In another instance...

appearance? Doing a more thorough review now. Actually, Cwmhiraeth, sorry to contradict what I said earlier; previously I had looked at the article but not the...

it needs a qualifier because at least one of the citations directly contradicts the claim of the hook. If a qualifier were added (something like "some...

public failure at the time, of which no trace remains." - it seems to contradict the earlier paragraph about her return in 1975, nor does it specifiy the...

Saints in Japan Comment: ALT1 is a Thai language source. The hooks seem to contradict each other. Explanation: the online channel still exists, it is just no...

Past a reliable source? Also, I may be confused but does the article contradict with Jesse L. Brown, I may be dumb here. Minor comment that isn't DYK...

primary sources; deaflympics websites. If we have two primary sources that contradict each other, it's probably best to avoid putting that info in the hook...

January 2014 (UTC) The hook may be well-sourced, but it's also directly contradicted in the article and source. First the source quotes Lewis as saying she...

Independence is a specific reference, i.e.Lake Superior, and doesn't contradict the other hook. How would you word this? -- Gwillhickers (talk) 21:41...

days. However, due to the fact that clinical studies have a tendency to contradict each other, I prefer ALT1. Too many variables count when taking lifespan...

plagiarism, and close paraphrasing: Other problems: - WP:V issue: Lede contradicts body. The original song was never released as a single, but the remix...

constitution in refs 6/7, or Basque nationalism in refs 10/11 - 11 seems to contradict the claim ("While Athletic have never been associated with the fringe...

remained the largest field station in the Southern Caribbean", which contradicts the notion in the hook of it being so "until 2002". The book source used...

paragraph to support that sentence, Chittenden, 1903, Volume II, p. 290, contradicts what the above sentence says. The source says that the pilot of Spread...

(115 ft) long? For neutrality, we need to remove this claim too, which is contradicted by other data and retain only "the largest reclining clay Buddha statue...

(UTC) You're right. But the hook is talking about hard sauce, which contradicts the image. Please change the hook to emphasize the dessert sauce and...

WP:WAWARD) 14:14, 31 August 2016 (UTC) The text in Sula megapode seems to contradict the hook: "The Sula scrubfowl is known only from the Banggai Islands and...

absolutely safe). Misc: The statement that the book is over 1100 pages contradicts Cherry's statement that it is 824 pages long (p.96). A link or a gloss...

sources. With multiple reliable sources, there might be information that contradicts other information in the same or other articles. Not all future categories...

north of Morocco, are they? (Not even on Wikipedia.) Also, the pictures contradict the descriptions. --(AfadsBad (talk) 04:43, 29 March 2014 (UTC)) I have...

find it ironic that you want to use a primary and unreliable source to contradict secondary and reliable ones though. Third, numerous biology sources that...

make sense). Even the 19th-century contemporary newspapers sometimes contradicted each other (e.g. Hayter was once described as an officer - although he...

back very vivid memories of post-war Beirut. Merabet's chapter does not contradict the information in the article. I'll explain: (1) It is not claimed that...

indicate the review status, and the "date, length and ref check out" was contradicted by another reviewer, who pointed out that the main hook (and that section...

suggests it wasn't the one performed in the semi-final. This seems to contradict Der Speigel. January (talk) 21:14, 3 April 2014 (UTC) Everything else...

rule here that's relevant: WP:DYKSG#D10, which reads, If your article contradicts an existing article, the contradiction should be resolved one way or...

There are also no details of anyone killed in the Massage parlour. This contradicts most sources on this incident as does the claims about the laundry van...

sounds like it may be an issue here, per WP:DYKSG#D10: If your article contradicts an existing article, the contradiction should be resolved one way or...

My wording "occasionally Wilma may have provided banking services" contradicts neither source and the article is not about Wilma, so let's not get side...

(p.175) that Lake Allison was named for Allison's work on erratics, contradicting our article's claim that it was named for his work on soil. It does...

there are some serious concerns in the article. Firstly, it seems to contradict itself in the lead by saying that there have never been any Polish laws...

registerwall but can be used AGF. Article is presentable Some sources contradict each other. The 2008 Express and Star reference states she retired at...

"May 14, 1012" is a typo? You never cite her DOB-- in fact, a source, contradicts what you list. Are FNs 1 and 13 duplicates? Image is OK, definitely PD...

implied by the source, and not contradicted by any intepretation of AC3>"unique" (a bit ambigious but not contradicted by anything)>"only" (arguably the...

difficult to find information about many individuals, and these usually contradict each other. As result, the article represents most what is known about...

source looks leftwing and a little iffy. The USC source doesn't exactly contradict the source I mentioned above, but regardless both of the sources you mention...

this is good. This is cited adequately and I don't see anything that contradicts it (unless I missed something). Ominae (talk) 06:43, 18 April 2025 (UTC)...

while overseeing its research, product and safety teams. This seems to contradict the proposed ALT0a wording (assuming such endeavours have one, and only...

Red-tailed hawk (talk) at 13:43, 2 September 2022 (UTC). Hook is too weak and contradicts actual content of the article: "The report concluded that human rights...

states "and has never been extended or rerouted", which is completely contradicted by the "History" section. I have removed the phrase, which unfortunately...

20:11, 22 October 2013 (UTC) Pulled from prep. The hook is directly contradicted by the article: "...director Milan Bhowmik said that the film is not...

1918 flu, people infected numbers (500 million), mortality rate (2~3%) contradict the deaths worldwide "20–100 million" statements. Review needed. Lead:...

SL93 (talk) 22:24, 20 December 2018 (UTC) OK. But we have a source that contradicts that. Do you want to say something like: ALT1a: ... that American pianist...

quite; aside from the awkward phrasing of the hook, the hook itself is contradicted later in the article – "and produces numerous fruit bodies in autumn...

Other problems: Overall: Hook seems fine unless there other sources contradicting the number of Nas. Whilst Earwig's Copyvio Detector says 33.8%, this...

like a distinct possibility rather than a shelved production. Ref #13 contradicts the sentence it's attached to; 'closing her deal' usually means signing...

I wrote the hook in a way that agrees with all the sources without contradicting any of them. Oncenawhile (talk) 23:19, 2 May 2017 (UTC) But addressing...

say that it's the third most popular game in Old Bavaria, but that contradicts the part of the article which says it's rarely played today (although...

that point in his life to make such a claim (and, indeed, that claim is contradicted by the List of governors of South Sumatra, which puts Adnan Kapau Gani...

category may have the same issue and neither the original uploader or the contradicting editor have made any other edits so contacting them seems unlikely....

ALT0 is sourced only to a user-created review; as Joofjoof notes, that contradicts more reliable sources, including those at burrito#history. ALT1 is better...

sense, but vaguely suggest only "another article". Template:Cleanup split Template:Summarize section Template:Duplication Template:Contradicts other...

everything is fine, including sources, hook and length. I hope no one else contradicts this. George Ho (talk) 21:13, 5 January 2016 (UTC) I think this would...

matter how no one wants to admit it? If crap about articles that are contradicted in other articles can be added, why not this? SL93 (talk) 22:12, 25 July...

Anobium625 (talk) 20:09, 20 September 2018 (UTC) Then at the risk of being contradicted I'll say ALT3 is good to go. Kim Post (talk) 20:40, 20 September 2018...

applied to 'buildings of national importance and special interest'" which contradicts Statue of John Laird where the same is said of grade III. This should...

(UTC) As noted at WT:DYK#Typhoon Nat (1991), the article and infobox contradict each other, the article has clear inaccuracies, and is grossly inadequate...

only "not directly sourced," it's not included in the article. It is contradicted by a caption, also. "The Canadian Shield can be seen on a map showing...

on during these sessions, its a loose interpretation. The source also contradicts another statement in article. It says so the could shoot in the St. James...

August 2016 (UTC) Not in the article, no. In fact, one of the sources contradicts itself by identifying both women as the first! Gatoclass (talk) 14:25...

Overall: Article is new enough, long enough. ALT0 and 2 seem okay. ALT1 is contradicted by the article, which says that the football team was expected to compete;...

this nomination from p6 as the sources for the hook (ALT5) appear to contradict one another. Variety says the film "may be going where no major studio...

just because people aren't willing to challenge it; DYKSPLIT and DYKNEW contradict each other, at least from how I see it. EF5 16:22, 11 January 2025 (UTC)...

which was suggested by Jengod as the reviewer? (It strikes me that it contradicts the original hook but is more in line with what the article actually...

possible for boaters to get authorization to land and it does happen, which contradicts ALT0: "nobody" is an absolute, while "without authorization" is far from...

Gambia. But this isn't in the source at the end of the paragraph, and is contradicted by The Gambia at the 2020 Summer Paralympics, which says that Malang...

"seismic" this is not the first time that the US (via Trump) has in effect contradicted its own signature at the UN and that will have consequences.Selfstudier...

ignored by biblical scholars during the last 1500 years" because it is contradicted by the existence of those older sources. Removing that statement--or...

see. It should probably be written more explicitly. Though it kind of contradicts the later part of the article that says how much Furillo has in common...

Helga Eng: "started a forty-year career as a primary school teacher" contradicts "From 1916 she would never return to her schoolteaching job" doesn't...

the article, what I removed was the connecting information that they contradict each other and which implies that based on the South Bend Tribune, Roberts...

Template:Cleanup split Template:Summarize section Template:Duplication Template:Contradicts other The above documentation is transcluded from Template:Summarize/doc...

(UTC) Surviving but not thriving. Note that the source quoted above contradicts the blurb. Abductive (reasoning) 00:27, 10 December 2019 (UTC) Would...

boats came into usage in the second half of the 19th century, which contradicts the hook, which places them in the century prior. Second, the "pulling...

that as a hook fact in this case. Meanwhile, I understand I'm about to contradict my earlier comments here, but I'd probably suggest against adding source...

I have added a few more recent sources to the article, none of them contradicting Nielsen but making statements in the same vein. For the hook though...

of "Onward, Christian Soldiers"? ThaddeusB, I don't see how the hook contradicts the article. The hymn was replaced in Anglican and British crematorium...

@Cwmhiraeth: some new information added to the article by Esculenta contradicts the hook, so we'll need to iron out a new one. I proposed an ALT1, does...

scientists" -> "was among the first modern scientists" As for hook; ALT1 is contradicted by the source. Hook ALT2 could be acceptable; but I prefer the first...

ALT1 hooks, both of which specifically listed "third Caliph", which is contradicted by at least one source. BlueMoonset (talk) 00:47, 24 March 2013 (UTC)...

started circus school, by the way, while "about nine" doesn't actually contradict eight. Also, it's an interview by someone who knows a lot about the circus...

issue of her place of birth remains; the source it is referenced to contradicts itself by giving it as both Orange County, Florida (in the fast facts...

Stevie fae Scotland (talk) 14:05, 30 July 2021 (UTC) ALT1 is directly contradicted by the text cited as proving it. If "The front-left wheel followed suit"...

discovered the itch mite as cause of scabies by using a microscope in 1687, contradicted contemporary medical doctrine, was alienated and had a hard time finding...

(500 to 3000) and the uncited sections you've pointed out and removed contradicting elements. I hope it is enough. Thank you for adding the conversions...

a citation that he was a general and in fact the citation you added contradicts this: "Although his role is unclear, most historical accounts are in...

professionally written and credits photographs correctly, and doesn't seem to contradict anything in the book sources. So in that respect, I think we can accept...

unreferenced. That can't pass like this either. ALT4, by the way, is directly contradicted by the New York Times source, so I'm striking that one.—♦♦ AMBER(ЯʘCK)...

and QPQ was done. ALT4 and ALT5 both are short enough. But ALT4 is contradicted by the article which says that he is a long distance runner. There looks...

sourcing. this does not support the entire statement it is used for; this contradicts the lede, which says he was elected in 2011. The article is also barely...

context of the 1990 election, it doesn't cover the 1989 date which seems to contradict the 1990 of ALT3. (Note: I struck ALT2 due to the sourcing issues on that...

--Launchballer 18:45, 14 September 2015 (UTC) This is Wikipedia - rules often contradict each other. Plot summaries and music video descriptions do not need to...

al was the first full description and to the unfamiliar eye may even contradict the Penhallow ref, "didn't get a full description and named" should be...

termites by their unique-among-termites behavior of socialness, again, contradicts Wikipedia article on termites. Fix one or the other. Clicked on other...

but doing so put it above the 200 character limit) However, it seems to contradict the article. The article suggests that he was already a referee a month...

(talk) 21:44, 29 June 2014 (UTC) Sorry, but all the sources for this hook contradict one another, I think a new hook will have to be found. Gatoclass (talk)...

words came from the subject herself and I don't really see how that contradicts policies and BLP. Plus there have been many other cases where interviews...

appreciated). However I am concerned about the hooks. Main hook is directly contradicted by "Poland was impacted by the plague. Although it lost large amounts...

(rather than a general viewpoint implied by the hook), and one that is contradicted by the independent research referred to by the RIAA (and deprecated in...

have played? Leitirlad (talk) 02:20, 4 December 2018 (UTC) New hook contradicts the first one, though is basically the same, is almost too long (184...

{{Disputed}} {{Disputed section}} POV {{POV}} {{POV section}} Content {{Contradicts others}} {{Controversial}} {{Dubious}} {{Hoax}} {{Original research}}...

more vague but also a bit more dramatic. That would mean it would not contradict any particular source, while retaining the overall meaning. CMD (talk)...

2010? Length, date and sourcing check out. However, the hook slightly contradicts what the article says by stating that "most" of his books were banned...

Usernameunique (talk • contribs) 23:26, 14 December 2017 (UTC) The hook is contradicted by the source (see hatted discussion above, which is copied from the...

pointless, decontextualised trivia. Your alternative hook is also flatly contradicted by the article itself. – Joe (talk) 15:02, 18 May 2021 (UTC) Vetoing...

founder of speech therapy, which is also unsourced. Don't these statements contradict one another? The third paragraph under "Life" needs at least one citation...

(talk) 22:31, 15 August 2011 (UTC) Two unreliable sources can equally contradict each other. It is hardly a month ago that I started a long discussion...

parish priest had removed the painting, deeming it pagan imagery that contradicted Catholic teaching. Reviewed: Template:Did you know nominations/One Million...

only is it not contained in the articles, but it seems to be directly contradicted by them. Both articles state that the two species are distinguished by...

have more than five DYKs. I've striked the original hook because it contradicts the linked article Junction (road) - where an interchange is a sub-division...

typical symptoms of a dehydration but rather a common sore throat. So it contradicts the other source. Lajbi Holla @ me • CP 22:25, 23 September 2012 (UTC)...

June 2014 (UTC) Thanks for checking the details, - I don't think it contradicts the original hook, --Gerda Arendt (talk) 12:52, 27 June 2014 (UTC) Thank...

sources, so I'm unable to evaluate the sourcing. I noted that the article contradicts itself on the orphan's name (Rahel vs. Rachel). This should be corrected...

same as being "undeveloped." Also, the gist of the hook seems to be contradicted by this source, indicating that Broad Street was already "bustling" and...

giving up the ration, nor the compensatory beer amount (which actually contradicts what is said in the Black Tot Day article). If capitalisation is the...

Nafield (talk) 09:10, 4 April 2013 (UTC) Hooks 1 and 3 appear to be contradicted by the third paragraph of the article, and if the Spanish national statistical...

provide context. Hook (Format): Y Hook (Content): Nominator seems to contradict their own hook in the following line. Please make your hook clear and...

editors think it's fine, and there's no reliable sources that dispute or contradict the claim. If you don't like ALT5, what about ALT6? Joseph2302 (talk)...

review. I believe this is unreasonable as there is concrete evidence that contradicts their statements regarding the article's eligibility. The article does...

(UTC) Actually, a quick addendum. Assuming Traces of War is reliable, it contradicts the information that's in this article. Traces of War: "His commission...

tccsdnew 20:20, 13 September 2018 (UTC) The dates in the lede seem to me to contradict the main text -- have I missed something? Square courts are not really...

and 3 are just statements of fact. They aren't so hooky and they may contradict the article, as while the hook is emphasizing popularity among lower classes...

that "These monuments (Tombs) were built between 1433 to 1533". This contradicts the dates in the article and hook. This source, which I view to be unreliable...

I am still bothered that a Persian etymological dictionary directly contradicts Makris's claim, which only makes sense if the Banda people were enslaved...

fled to Nice and then Odette joined him in 1942. However this sentence contradicts this "That year, she met Moussa Abadi when he fled to Nice and together...

agitation." These sources show that the hook 1 is not accurate enough and contradicts the summary provided by majority of sources. Shashank5988 (talk) 16:13...

recent - Dhaky perhaps. In fact, if you look at her note 3 she somewhat contradicts herself, dating the style only from the new century (following Dhaky)...

a few shools in Sri Lanka. But it is not supported by the refs, and contradicts the information on recent preservation attempts. Therefore I think its...

That source also says, "Began swimming in 2009 in Gelephu (BHU)." which contradicts ""Tenzin started swimming in 2006, swimming in rivers in Gelephu at the...

the article) that it was how it was originally written, and it doesn't contradict the fact that other denominations use it. It's not misleading to discuss...

final part, on him "not knowing" that the Securitate was behind this, is contradicted by all other sources, but that's besides the point.) On Weiss' Jewishness...

April 2019 (UTC) Zanhe The quoted source, which is not an academic work, contradicts Suryadinata et al, who says that she was born in Semarang. Should I include...

section there is a subsection titled, First Tamil sound film? which contradicts the previous statement stating it is a multilingual film. Thus leaving...

17 October 2016 (UTC) For the original hook, it seems to be partly contradicted by the text, as it says they were on FabricLive.06, and it does not verify...

translate. Also the geology does not make sense in our article and it contradicts itself. This article needs fixed. I don't think you should need much...

as 128 out of 453 going on to develop MS (28% on my caculator) which contradicts the hook. So either the sources are not so definite as 50%, but 28-50%...

(Alexander) Francis Knighted in 1989, CBE in 1976 Born 31 August 1926 (this contradicted what was in the article, until I removed it) Name of parents and wife...

are in the running are completely untrue". This pretty much directly contradicts, and certainly does not support, the hook fact. Harrias talk 08:29, 29...

At least "The Navy from Within", which is a reliable source, flatly contradicts this. As for the history of the ceremony, the article reads as if the...

confirming that Laquan McDonald was shot by a police officer 16 times, contradicting the official police account of a single gunshot? Source: https://www...

you were able to find it. (I found it on find a grave, and indeed, it contradicts the other one.) Then later you write that Marr "minored in Spanish at...

English legal system or the British legal system. That does not actually contradict the source cited in the article. I can't help but think that EEng will...

mistaken. Are there any other independent sources that corroborate or contradict this story? If we accept the source as fact, we can say that the lot draw...

even maintained beyond the case title (e.g. the appellant and appellee contradict this fiction), as if it is the actual truth, should not be done. Claiming...

{{Ratio/sandbox|0|0}} → 0:0 {{resratio|0|0}} → 0 {{resratio/sandbox|0|0}} → 0 Contradicting named parameters {{Ratio|1|2|x=3 |y=4}} → 1∶2 {{Ratio/sandbox|1|2|x=3...

with the article itself. However, the hook as it's nominated seems to contradict H2 criterium. I'm sure that the Polish insurgents "defended" Warsaw while...

the fact that it doesn't appear in the article (and also is somewhat contradicted by the map showing its location in the article). I'm not sure ALT1 is...

are no sources disputing these ideas. The sentence you quote in no way contradicts the hook or anything Rogers says. Nobody's interpreting "productive"...

characteristics" The high-tensile steel bit in the article is actually contradicted by the cited source, which states that the original intention was to...

paragraph: the second sentence is not complete, and the third sentence contradicts the second sentence. Third paragraph: the description of the three temples...

the Black Panther, and returned to the character in the 1970s, those contradict your explanation for not including the Fantastic Four, which is that they...

the supplied sources support the hook - indeed the first one directly contradicts it as it says the breed was developed from "other bobtail kitties" imported...

this day in 1990 at his native hamlet Keegam Shopian." (which in no way contradicts source 1 or 4). --Soman (talk) 19:10, 11 May 2014 (UTC) For the election...

reality the stadium was built to support the Packers." This seems to contradict what you're saying here, which is that it was "originally" built for high...

about how the vocalist didn't show her face in pictures, but that's contradicted by how recently she's started appearing personally in publicity photos...

check the source again and find some more that support this or perhaps contradict it. — JudeccaXIII (talk) 22:17, 5 November 2016 (UTC) Yoninah The text...

ride" sounds to me like the men treated the women players easily which contradicts the idea of the men not hesitating to use physical contact. This is not...

"According to Indian Express, the removal proposal issued by the NDMC contradicts a 2021 traffic study submitted by the Central Public Works Department...

I removed the third, which was a rather ignorant bit of OR anyways, contradicted as it was by other sources used in the article. [3] ᛗᛁᛟᛚᚾᛁᚱPants Tell...

(Maybe additional sources would clarify this, but as written the article contradicts the source.) The hook is consistent with the source, as it indicates...

so they aren't hers, though she's the chief executive—this seems to contradict the pre-existing Tanganyika Province article, which mentions the so-called...

article says what I think it says, then as far as I can tell it directly contradicts the hook: "The 1770s epidemic was the most devastating and widespread...

building in Prague, and indeed List of tallest buildings in Prague seems to contradict it. I actually had a preference for a hook combining ALT7 and ALT8, but...

(talk) 21:06, 27 July 2022 (UTC) Flibirigit, that is in one source but is contradicted in another. A mention of the telescope in an obituary in a local paper...

which states that three diplomats plus a reporter were kidnapped, which contradicts the four diplomats mentioned in the hook. (There are also issues with...

what you state, and page 3 gives an example of it. (Page 2 specifically contradicts what you wrote, stating that .d files are "...for direct inclusion in...

there's a discrepancy based on language, but since none of these estimates contradict one another, and "over a hundred thousand" and "over 200,000" are more...

pink. — Kaz (talk) 19:32, 16 May 2017 (UTC) The Ripleys reference is contradicted by the Dictionary.com reference, so no the hook is not supported.--Kevmin...

and wanted to make sure it was reflected or at least that it doesn't contradict anything I've written. Which it doesn't, thankfully.) I'm happy now for...

is talking about a specific dossier being unpersuasive, which is not contradicted by the source you provided. I've edited the hook to clarify. (t · c)...

well-referenced, and amusing article; great work. I don't believe it contradicts the general Wikipedia notability guideline of WP:PERP either. That said...

it backs up the story but it says our colonel was 52 years old, which contradicts the article, which claims he lived 61 years. Which one is correct? Are...

userpage there is a section which states "(NOT the masala films)" which contradicts your rooting for CE, which is a hardcore masala film, isn't it? Will...

normal for a species level page. Additionally the Aquilegia sentences contradict the etymology section on the genus page and should be moved there not...

possibly, Alt3 ... that well established ideas about sustainability are contradicted by environmentalism of the poor? Source: Davey, Ian (2009) Environmentalism...

position. WP has competing policies, guidelines and essays and when they contradict I like to go with the policy. Lightburst (talk) 19:05, 1 December 2023...

numbers cited. Ref#3 is a blog. Ref#4 checks out, but the cited sentence contradicts the lead. The article (and the source) say the whole square was renamed...

to change the article). ALT1 hook (and, for that matter, the article) contradicts the source: Après une apparition dans le film Dancing Machine, aux côtés...

reserves meant that Malaysia would be preparing to import LNG" umm? that contradicts the hook. LNG imports are either increasing or the country is "preparing...

that their inclusion amounts to original research; it appears to me to contradict WP:PRIMARY. --BrownHairedGirl (talk) • (contribs) 14:36, 28 June 2014...

"dubious" template, since we couldn't find any corroboration -- and they are contradicted by other evidence. --Orlady (talk) 16:58, 7 January 2014 (UTC) New reviewer...

in a more concise way (meaning, direct to the point), while also not contradicting the article text. Narutolovehinata5 tccsdnew 00:12, 10 December 2018...

it. I would suggest going on his medical research. I am happy to be contradicted if anyone can verify the Nazi bit. Philafrenzy (talk) 18:49, 5 May 2018...

national series since Frank requires a source that says so and is not contradicted by known facts established by other reliable sources. If such cannot...

as it says there are no hotels or restaurants in Naranag -- directly contradicting the article. From this blog, I infer that hotels might exist there,...

conformance with the Verifiability policy). The Buenos Aires foundation claim contradicts the existing WP article, and that needs to be resolved per Wikipedia:DYKAR#D10...

(UTC) I am very uncomfortable with "could easily", especially when it contradicts the other sources that the teams in the Gibraltar Civilian Football Association...

2012, it took over 10 hours to transfer 200 children? I realize I'm contradicting my earlier comments about putting the move first, but this feels like...

Yoninah (talk) 13:22, 21 January 2020 (UTC) Ah, it's true. Another source contradicted ALT6 and I just corrected the article. sentausa (talk) 13:42, 21 January...

issue of whether or not he actually invented tiramisu, as this article contradicts the tiramisu article on who created it. Joseph2302 (talk) 15:11, 10 November...

Jews as an important element of the myth, which I don't think that's contradicted by any of the sources you cited. If you'd like to expand the article...

(UTC) @Vanamonde93: there is not a single word in what I wrote that contradicts WP:V. Harvard referencing errors (which actually, I've already fixed)...

clones of Olivia Rodrigo in her "Get Him Back!" music video represented "contradicting voices" in her head? --NØ 10:49, 13 September 2023 (UTC) Hey Vaticidalprophet...

Leotiales." (emphasis added). The inclusion of B. rufus in that sentence contradicts the rest of the article, so I was taking it as a misprint. Shall I perhaps...

Clearly they became urban majority states in different decades, which contradicts the hook statement. BlueMoonset (talk) 04:38, 24 March 2013 (UTC) Actually...

armed with muskets, although his party also had guns", which seems to contradict the statement that the Ngāi Tahu had no guns (though they might have had...

it shows the church building (in gray) clearly inside the park, which contradicts the article. The attached PDF may not be the one you meant, since it...

studied the biological effects of radiation, the 20 years of living doesn't contradict the fact that the dose was lethal. Because when a poison is studied in...

candidates. The original hook is consistent with source 3, but it is contradicted by source 4. Regarding your third bullet, while a newspaper article republished...

assuming LavaBaron's review is accurate (and I have seen nothing which contradicts it), you could leave ALT0 to be promoted. However, I think ALT1 is better...

silver medal in the 60 meters hurdles" - The 2018 Expressodasilhas source contradicts itself by saying he won silver in the 60 meters hurdles in one paragraph...

File:Bali Iqbal.jpg is still pending, and the image's current licence tag contradicts the information given in the summary. (That is, the summary template...

namely factual content in the article that doesn't make sense and/or is contradicted by the sources. I have not gone over the article with a finetooth comb;...

appropriate only for notions that are unconfirmed without being seriously contradicted; here it's apparent that there're a lot of amusing theories in competition...

don't know what happened to the DYK guideline that read If an article contradicts an existing article, the contradiction should be resolved one way or...

(ie a fiction) that is mentioned (in passing) in your ref which then contradicts the idea saying "he [Luigi] led the rescue mission, ensuring damage control...

style. I stand by that and there is nothing in the above replies to even contradict me on that, just dancing around the point. Dahn (talk) 18:58, 19 July...

be too comfortable approving either of these alts because they seem to contradict each other - did it become popular in the 1920s because children's song...

reading the sectoral representation article linked in the lede). It also contradicts the article, which suggested disqualification was overturned by the Supreme...

Vanamonde (talk) 07:24, 29 May 2018 (UTC) The lead is small but it is not contradicting the body, updated the first sentence as per your suggestion, also requested...

16:15, 1 August 2019 (UTC) Infobox: Nasir-Ud-Daulah Asaf Jah IV - that contradicts with the lede Mir Farqunda Ali Khan Siddiqi Asaf Jah lV starship Corrected...

surprise, but when no independent sources support this and most (all?) contradict this, then such a source is not acceptable at all. Fram (talk) 17:26,...

need not be in the same tense. However, some of the wording seems to contradict itself. I have struck a portion of my initial review as I mistyped. The...

ALT1 but ALT0 is also fine. My main issue is that ALT1 and the article contradict: the hook says Popov never heard the symphony performed in its entirety...

I know the number is similar to many Arab publishers.” The first is contradicted by independent sources; the second estimate seems a bit high, too, really...

and it shouldn't, as it is a blog; a blog which makes a claim directly contradicted by what are arguably better sources -- namely, that Mallo was actually...

just switch the hook; it's one of those situations where no one else contradicts Rhoads on this, but I can only find Rhoads or people citing him saying...

Your work is appreciated. Sometimes, it becomes frustrating hearing contradicting guidelines and/or interpretations of the guidelines. I think (speaking...

sourcing on this article, one citation has an abstract that directly contradicts what this article says it contains, for example. Please read comments...

in the lead that Abu Hamza al-Thumali narrated this Dua, which would contradict the hook fact. This apparent contradiction would need to be resolved before...

jolielover♥talk 14:13, 13 February 2025 (UTC) Not only that, but the claim is contradicted by a quick search: apparently it may have snowed in Zimbabwe in the 1930s...

mates with?". This statement is not supported by the bolded article and contradicted by the reference cited there. The article states only that this is the...

§ Legacy. Similarly, ALT2 is present and sourced in the article, but then contradicted in the same paragraph. Overall: @EF5: You gave two online sources for...

of Style, and which are pretty much faux citations. This explicitly contradicts DYK rules, which state that the fact for the hook has to be immediately...

Time R thanks very much for adding those clips. The Daily Oklahoman contradicts the Washington Post obit and is rather vague so can't be used. The Daily...

chronological story flow (e.g. "at first it was independent..."), or contradicts the preceding phrase (e.g. "with two story avant-corpss"). If they could...

struck ALT0 and ALT1. ALT2 is AGF and cited inline, but the hook fact is contradicted later, in the first sentence under Exhibitions. ALT3 is AGF and cited...

referenced in the NRHP document—to see that it doesn't support, and in fact contradicts, the NRHP statement—it's available here: File:The Second Cathedral of...

Kahn and Averill. ISBN 9780900707285.) In a 1969 CBC Radio interview he contradicts himself by describing the symphony as the "the Götz von Berlichingen"...

by the argument. Except in fairly uncommon cases of multiple RS that contradict each other, we don't generally recognize any "hierarchy" of reliable sources...

Poland which did not exist during whole of his lifetime (diff) is what contradicts WP:OPENPARA. Poland is now linked both in the infobox and in the first...

coordinated activities, except when a female is in oestrus, which seems to contradict ALT5 ("relatively little time" isn't none except mating), and No direct...

the paragraph are acceptable and there is no guideline or policy which contradicts this. I completely disagree that you should cite at the end of the first...

The other part of the hook fact checks out, but we can't run a date contradicted by WP:RS. That fact will need to be removed from the article, and a new...

generally sought to destroy the seamen's faith in their leadership by contradicting what they had heard from Germany on official channels." from: West,...

ironically, to have been spared by war and preserved by poverty. The infobox contradicts the main text on the date of consecration, uncited... there may be a...

count as a QPQ. Bruxton (talk) 23:36, 3 February 2024 (UTC) You are contradicting yourself Bruxton: an ongoing review cannot be full. It does not matter...

Konieczny aka Prokonsul Piotrus| reply here 02:47, 17 September 2021 (UTC) Contradicted by the article which describes various types of peripheral involvement...

this article which appears (I haven't read the article in detail) to contradict the article about Rubicon's role in LAP. This should be resolved. TompaDompa...

was now searching for sources to find an appropriate one but they are contradicting. What about this source? Makeandtoss (talk) 18:46, 24 December 2015...

subsequent events and conversations were His recollections were also contradicted by "a string of witnesses ... many of them Navy SEALs.," who depicted...

necessarily sufficient to have it as a hook, certainly not when it is contradicted by other sources. Calling Jingdezhen a remote town is like calling Geneva...

Wikipedia" - I think this is very much not acceptable editing), and contradicted by a multitude of sources - see Talk:Jew with a coin/Archive 1#"aren't...

combination of causes and effects. Note that the lead sentence of the article contradicts ALT6 by saying "The United States fiscal cliff refers to a predicted...

(1848) article with sourced statements about political prisoners (thus contradicting ALT0): "A first attempt to change the situation in the Duchy was made...

qualifications. The linked article also dramatically contradicts the hook, and its lede contradicts most of its content. HLHJ (talk) 04:12, 11 January 2020...

and interesting; ALT1 claims that she whispers her commands, a claim contradicted by its source, and it is not approved (although it could easily be workshopped)...

don't think we can say he only supplied the money for 3,000, since that contradicts the sources. BlueMoonset (talk) 21:23, 12 June 2014 (UTC) I agree with...

controversial).The extreme hook is based on a very weak source and is contradicted by other reliable sources.MyMoloboaccount (talk) 22:14, 16 April 2019...

geologists will give three different opinions, and so has been flagged as contradicting the Ecca Group article. It may take a long time to resolve these concerns...

above is true. Cielquiparle (talk) 22:08, 4 March 2025 (UTC) ALT1 is contradicted by this BBC article: SA billionaire overtakes Dangote as Africa’s richest...

times to create a credible fact that very likely has no public evidence contradicting it). However, I've done a few edits and more checking. Six of the ship...

feel that the proposed hook really matches the source (without flatly contradicting it). Fram (talk) 09:10, 10 January 2013 (UTC) All right then, let's...

context, The Times published a piece yesterday morning that directly contradicted my hook, which meant it wasn't accurate (he could afford a chip butty...

edition despite claims to the contrary). These two facts would seem to contradict each other, and cast doubt on the reliability of one or the other of these...

was Federalist, and doesn't mention the family. It also seems to be contradicted by Jefferson's appointment of Bishop's dad after the election—as written...

(UTC) @Miraclepine: Regarding ALT1, is there a reliable source that contradicts with the University of Southern California source utilized in the article...

compared to endometriosis (the token underfunded women's disease), contradicting my initial source. Other sources just say it's underfunded (e.g. a UK...

successful, until the hook appears on the Main Page. The hook fact is contradicted in the article which states he was in 6th grade at a camp when he got...

be a lot of confusion on this point, with various people claiming it contradicts WP:V, I've proposed that WP:V should be updated to reflect our best practice...

source doesn't cast aspersions so why should we? On the other hand, it contradicts what the frontman said elsewhere. Exceptional claims need exceptional...

"US" qualifier now in the article lead and DYK hook is inaccurate and contradicts the properly sourced statements in the article body. Thank you, Skeet...

can I point out that your and others strict reading of DYK rules is contradicted by the lead paragraph of WP:DYK: "The DYK section publicizes new or expanded...

source. I could not verify the hook fact. The Pathe source that is cited contradicts both the article and the hook, indicating that she was questioned by...

the vice-chancellors of the University of Oxford" sentence apparently contradicts the "administered by the chancellor of the university"? These are the...

SAAF to Great Britain's Women's Royal Air Force, receiving a commission contradicts the preceding paragraph that says she served ... in the South African...

DYK hook include a claim not contained therein (one that explicitly contradicts our article, in fact). —David Levy 01:30, 3 January 2019 (UTC) we don't...

attestations to the practice in Indian literature, others say it is contradicted by the next stanza? Or, to be honest, you could just say try: ...that...

need a new hook here given that Steve has added sources which appear to contradict the hook. Narutolovehinata5 tccsdnew 01:56, 29 April 2018 (UTC) Not really...

issue as Stoutonia 1968 was written before the 1970 launch. This also contradicts with The Dunn County News which says it was held in Stout State's communications...

Contributor"), also does not verify the statement that bars are 100g, which is contradicted by the paragraph right above it. Taken together, I am not sure if this...

be referred to throughout Wikipedia articles, and these 'conventions' contradict reliable sources and attempt to 'correct' popular culture. The issue of...

record for the fastest debunked superlative hook, the source itself contradicts it. Grigorije Janković's term between 1810 and 1822 is longer. Vučević...

However, I have not been able to find any studies that state that or contradict that in a peer-reviewed context. Thus, I wanted to ask you Bruxton - why...

have written about the Rephaim, and it agrees with, or at least does not contradict most other scholars, at least from what I have seen. I could probably...

in the article, it cannot be inflammatory in the hook is explicitly contradicted by another part of the guidelines, that's in a part about one contentious...

announced" is incorrect (that is, whatever source you're referencing contradicts a Japanese source, where it's described as kinda "meant to invoke mystery...

(talk) 05:54, 24 April 2019 (UTC) @The C of E:, but the hook still contradicts the reliable source, because the monarch cannot change the name alone...

and have several articles waiting for update. This article should not contradict the Beckmann article. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 22:34, 3 December 2025 (UTC)...

press coverage during that time frame also included such material that contradict the main theme and thesis this article and other sources presents. Even...

17:56, 11 August 2015 (UTC) The hook fact is uncited in the lede and contradicted by the final sentence of the lede and in the history section. Belle (talk)...

and that she "came to the USA with her family at a young age"; this contradicts the article saying that she was born in California. Is it a reliable...

restrictions on detailing country by country, the current phrasing actively contradicts the source's "not only major powers" statement. I think rephrasing is...

markup Userbox Category {{User reality}} This user believes that religion that contradicts verifiable facts is a lie. Category:Rationalist Wikipedians...

Magnificat by Luther," the current version, is clear but incorrect (and contradicts Rizzuti, still quoted as source for this sentence) I covered the relation...

clearly be used as a source, especially since any of her claims can be contradicted by other sources. (Also, please stop focusing on the "fiction author"...

glossed or mentioned in the linked article. Some statements seem to be contradicted by their cited sources. The Hmong source seems to be saying something...

certain region was far from settled. In fact, I found that the sources contradicted each other, and that the claim was not just unclear but disputed. For...

is fair page. However, any hook above (except my suggestion) simply contradicts this page. Does it follow from our AlphaFold page that it "has solved...

"Israelites" based off the primary source, even if this is slightly contradicted by the Forward article. HadesTTW (he/him • talk) 19:39, 26 September...

but at this point to say we simply don't know why he created the hat contradicts the article and uses the most vague claim of those advanced by the sources...

about that word. Oh yes. Unctuous and ingratiating. That would seem to contradict Mr. Cole's idea that I'm offensive. Unless I'm being offensive and ingratiating...

"atrocities" on the part of the Soviet government, an interpretation that is contradicted by some of the sources cited in the article. (t · c) buidhe 17:58, 24...

critical and no need to clutter the text mentioning it. The image does not contradict the text: it was vogue in 15th-16th, but there is no claim that they vanished...

that Pharos's structure is relatively well-preserved – this seems to contradict the earlier Pharos is a relatively degraded crater. Addressed, additionally...

This article or section appears to contradict itself. Please see the talk page for more information....

the illustration is Boccacio's work, a claim that the same caption now contradicts, since Yuri Gershkovich (who died in 2013) is also credited as an author...

obviously not in the spirit of the BLP policy, and the RS policy clearly contradicts it. ―Jochem van Hees (talk) 09:19, 23 September 2022 (UTC) Policies related...

misunderstanding sickle cell but do not explicitly credit Bristow with contradicting this misinformation in any particular way. I would argue the content...

ALT. However, now that it was proposed as an ALT, you oppose it. This contradicts your earlier comment about it being okay with you if the idea was proposed...

the war is imminent. The idea behind ALT6 is good, though "by stage 2" contradicts the statement that hostages would be released during stage 2 (lead section...

{{Disputed}} {{Disputed section}} POV {{POV}} {{POV section}} Content {{Contradicts others}} {{Controversial}} {{Dubious}} {{Hoax}} {{Original research}}...

and we are choosing to say outright that it does exist? Does this not contradict the article's definition of the list as a "hypothesized document"? Surtsicna...

Romania, though it was a small one. What part of your verbose claim contradicts this? You have also claimed that a direct account by a witness of something...

giving carte blanche for fringe theories to drag on and on, despite contradicting every single reliable source. But you know... the FSM is not Gaza and...

classification of Sequoia dakotensis as Sequoia. So the 2002 paper is contradicted by a more recent publication https://propagationnation...

documentary. Yet the film features the leading authorities on homeopathy contradicting each other on every fundamental aspect of the concept. Presenting these...

the long-term continuity of mainland Greek ("Helladic") culture, which contradicted the established scholarly view that Minoan Crete had been the dominant...

3 August 2021 (UTC) The problem is that, at the moment, the article contradicts the hook. The article says that Dragon Man is a species, while the hook...

markup Userbox Category {{User reality}} This user believes that religion that contradicts verifiable facts is a lie. Category:Rationalist Wikipedians...

themselves if that's okay. Not yet got a response from the author whose paper contradicts the first paragraph if I understand correctly. —Femke 🐦 (talk) 08:02...

that is interesting. You'll also need to fix your lead section, which contradicts what we know about the accident rate. In other words, the slang didn't...

offender, though it is often one of the chief victims." is directly contradicted by later sources. See the next paragraph for more on the last two points...

that he continued to work with the specialist for weeks, which seems to contradict the hook? Looking around online for sources about quickly curing a stammer...

practice dentistry in the UK with an American degree I don't think this contradicts anything in the article - are you asking me to clarify/add this? Yes...

(UTC) I disagree with that assessment. Can you provide citations that contradict that Gibraltar is A) not a part of the Kettle River range, B) north of...

and the articles receive high traffic, if including those dates really contradicts MOS:FILM, then they should have been removed. So I would prefer to keep...

the end of it, the first, second and last paragraphs of the "Findings contradicting Trump's denials" section need citations at the end of them, the first...

all modern editions" and that's unstated, uncited, and still directly contradicted by cited sentences talking about how it's not trustworthy and only used...

{{Disputed}} {{Disputed section}} POV {{POV}} {{POV section}} Content {{Contradicts others}} {{Controversial}} {{Dubious}} {{Hoax}} {{Original research}}...

sources. With multiple reliable sources, there might be information that contradicts other information in the same or other articles. All future categories...

sources. With multiple reliable sources, there might be information that contradicts other information in the same or other articles. Not all future categories...

a long-time recurring problem with your nominations. It also seems to contradict your original objection to ALT2: you didn't want ALT2 as is because it...

you can read in the section titled "Carlist protegé". This technically contradicts your claim: "I don't see anything above this in the article that says...

'Нохимович'), and says we ran a colonial goods store. Maybe the source contradict each other, maybe mishpokhe should be understood more broadly. The notion...

bring nothing to the table but vague criticism and advises which even contradict grammar rules. Please clarify specifically what your concerns are or I...

Please don't reduce her to one disputed factoid. And when newspapers are contradicted by authoritative sources (and other articles), then we don't put such...

aid as a result of the Israeli blockade, are indications that acts that contradict the Genocide Convention, primarily those mentioned in Article II, paragraphs...