In 1914, Hunter returned to Cornell to take over the soccer team, and later, the hockey team. In 1915, his responsibilities were increased to include those of head coach for the lacrosse team, of which he was the first non-student-coach.[4] Hunter coached the lacrosse team for two seasons and amassed a 7–8–1 record.[5] Hunter was the first person to coach all three sports at Cornell.[3] His Cornell soccer teams compiled a 2–5–5 record over his two seasons,[6] and his hockey teams amassed a 20–15–0 record.[2]
In 1919, he was hired as head coach of the Yale University hockey, lacrosse, and soccer teams.[7]
Hunter coached the Army lacrosse team from 1921 to 1923, and compiled a 16–5–1 record.[8] In 1923, he led Army to an 8–1–1 record and its first national championship in lacrosse.[9] He coached the hockey team from 1921 to 1923 and compiled a 12–12–2 record.[10]
Hunter served as the head coach for the Harvard Universitylacrosse team in 1927 and amassed a 3–8 record.[11] He began 1928 as coach, but fell ill midway through the season and was replaced by H. W. Jeffers.[12]
National champion
Postseason invitational champion
Conference regular season champion
Conference regular season and conference tournament champion
Division regular season champion
Division regular season and conference tournament champion
Conference tournament champion