Sydney Sparkes Orr

Sydney Sparkes Orr (6 December 1914 - 15 July 1966) was Professor of Philosophy at the University of Tasmania and the centre of the "Orr case", a celebrated academic scandal of the 1950s.

Born in Belfast in 1914, Orr achieved a first-class-honours BA in Philosophy and received an MA with special commendation at Queen's University before commencing his teaching career at the University of St Andrews and the University of Melbourne. In 1952 he was appointed to the chair of philosophy at the University of Tasmania, after falsifying his academic record in his application.[1]

In 1955 the University dismissed him for sexual relations with an undergraduate student. He denied the accusation but his appeals to the Tasmanian Supreme Court and the High Court of Australia were unsuccessful. Many academics believed Orr had been denied due process and his position was declared "black". Many also thought that Orr had been made a scapegoat due to his openly challenging the University authorities.[2]

Orr died in 1966, shortly after reaching a monetary settlement with the university of A$16,000.[3]

References

  1. ^ Cassandra Pybus, Gross Moral Turpitude: The Orr Case Reconsidered, Melbourne (Heinemann), 1993, pp. 167-71. The accusation that Orr lied when claiming to have an MA with first class honours, when such degrees were unclassified, seems to ignore the fact that, at that time, the classification of the first degree was considered more important than subsequent research. Orr had a first-class honours BA and received an MA with special commendation. Oxbridge professors whose MAs were obtained without further examination beyond the BA, sometimes regarded research degrees with disdain.
  2. ^ E.g., Martin B Knowledge and Power in Academia Honi Soit 6 August 1991, p. 10
  3. ^ "Sydney Sparkes Orr". The Companion to Tasmanian History. University of Tasmania. Retrieved 17 August 2022.

Sources

  • W. D. Joske Orr, Sydney Sparkes (1914? - 1966), Australian Dictionary of Biography, Volume 15, Melbourne University Press, 2000, pp 543–544.
  • W. H. C. Eddy (1961) Orr, Jacaranda Publishers, Brisbane
  • John Polya and Robert Solomon (1996) Dreyfus in Australia, Privately Published, Sydney, NSW. ISBN 0-646-30523-9
  • Clyde Manwell and C. M. Ann Baker (1986) "Not Merely Malice": The University of Tasmania Versus Professor Orr, in Brian Martin, C. M. Ann Baker, Clyde Manwell and Cedric Pugh (eds.), Intellectual Suppression. Australian Case Histories, Analysis and Responses, Angus and Robertson, North Ryde (NSW) pp. 39–49
  • Cassandra Pybus (1994) Seduction and Consent: A Case of Gross Moral Turpitude, Mandarin, Port Melbourne
  • J. Franklin (2003) Corrupting the Youth: A History of Philosophy in Australia, Macleay Press, ch. 3
  • Orr v University of Tasmania(1957) 100 Commonwealth Law Reports 526

Further reading