Sugar bowl (legal maxim)

In United States constitutional law and criminal procedure, the sugar bowl refers to a legal maxim relating to one of the restrictions on searches and seizures imposed by the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution. It specifically refers to the areas that may be searched in pursuit of the items stipulated in the warrant in relation to evidence of any other criminal acts which may be recovered.

The maxim (often quoted as "if you are looking for stolen televisions, you cannot look in sugar bowls") describes the relationship between what is described in a search warrant and the persons or things that may be validly searched as a consequence.

Under the law, only areas that could realistically contain the objects searched for can be searched, and therefore only evidence of other crimes found in those areas (or in plain sight) can be admitted.

Overview

In the eponymous example, if the search warrant states that a stolen television is the object of the search, a law-enforcement officer cannot look into a person's sugar bowl for what might be other stolen property (because, of course, a television would not fit inside a sugar bowl). However, the officer may look into other concealed areas where a television may be hidden, such as a closet, attic, or outside shed. On the other hand, if the search warrant stated that a stolen ring was the subject, since a ring can easily be concealed inside a sugar bowl, the officer may search inside the bowl.

An extension of this concept prevents search through possessions that could not possibly be the object in question. If stolen televisions are exclusively the subject of the warrant then officers could not read through paperwork or the contents of computers found at the scene even if the televisions could reasonably be hidden among large stacks of paper or amongst computer equipment. Televisions could not be hidden inside a folder of papers, or stored on a hard drive, thus excluding those from being searched. Similarly, those executing the warrant may not use search techniques that are not specifically used to find the target. In the setting of a building, drug dogs cannot be used unless drugs are specified in the warrant, while outside a metal detector could only be used if the item could be detected by it.

Generally these issues do not become relevant, as investigators are careful to apply for warrants that cover the maximum areas that there is evidence to allow for. If there is evidence to support the issuing of a warrant to find stolen televisions, investigators may apply for one that includes stolen televisions, parts of televisions, sums of cash and records of the sale of televisions, on the rationale that possession of a large number of stolen items constitutes evidence of participating in a trade in stolen objects. As cash can be stored in a sugar bowl, this allows for the search of almost everywhere. Conversely such warrants risk becoming effective general warrants which are prohibited under the Fourth Amendment.

There are some cases where even a warrant that only specifies a single item to be looked for can reasonably be applied to almost every conceivable area, most notably illegal drugs which could be present in almost any quantity from milligrams to kilograms, thus reasonably being concealed in almost anything.

In effect, the sugar bowl is a reminder to law enforcement to carefully stipulate their warrants and not to use speculative warrants to search for evidence of serious crimes. Even if such evidence is found, if it is outside the scope of the areas the warrant permits then it is very likely to be excluded from trial as an illegal search and seizure.[1]

See also

References

  1. ^ James M. Rosenbaum (June 2006). "In Defense of the Sugar Bowl" (PDF). Federal Courts Law Review. Archived from the original on September 28, 2007.

Read other articles:

Cristina Alesci

CNN and CNNMoney correspondent Cristina AlesciCristina AlesciBornQueens, New YorkNationalityAmericanEducationCraig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism at the City University of New York (MA)Pace University (BA)OccupationChief Corporate Affairs OfficerEmployersChobani(2020–2022)CNN (2014–2020)Bloomberg NewsBloomberg TelevisionNotable creditsCNN InternationalHLNBloomberg TelevisionRaw IngredientsBoard member ofCraig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism Cristina Alesci was the Chief ...

 

Goa Binsari

Artikel ini sebatang kara, artinya tidak ada artikel lain yang memiliki pranala balik ke halaman ini.Bantulah menambah pranala ke artikel ini dari artikel yang berhubungan atau coba peralatan pencari pranala.Tag ini diberikan pada Oktober 2022. Gua Binsari atau yang dikenal sebagai Gua Jepang adalah salah satu dari beberapa peninggalan bersejarah yang terdapat di Pulau Biak, Papua. Nama asli dari gua ini adalah Abyab Binsari yang berarti ‘Goa Nenek’. Jika ditinjau dari namanya menurut, ke...

 

2008–09 Manchester City F.C. season

2008–09 season of Manchester City Manchester City 2008–09 football seasonManchester City2008–09 seasonOwnerAbu Dhabi United GroupChairmanThaksin Shinawatra until the sale of club on 1 September 2008 Khaldoon Al Mubarak from 1 September 2008ManagerMark HughesStadiumCity of Manchester StadiumPremier League10thFA CupThird roundLeague CupSecond roundUEFA CupQuarter-finalsTop goalscorerLeague: Robinho (14)All: Robinho (15)Highest home attendance47,331 vs Chelsea 13 September 2008Lowest home ...

Company B (teater)

Company B adalah sebuah perusahaan teater Australia yang berpusat di Belvoir St Theatre di Sydney, Australia. Company B dibentuk tahun 1984 dan, di bawah kepemimpinan artistik Neil Armfield, perusahaan ini menarik pengarang drama, sutradara dan aktor berpengaruh di Australia. Company B juga bergabung dengan pusat dan festival seni besar nasional dan internasional. Company B melejit karena aksi uniknya yang diambil untuk menyelamatkan Nimrod Theatre dari perubuhan tahun 1984. Daripada kehilang...

 

Cestice

Village and municipality in Slovakia Košice-okolie District in the Kosice Region Cestice (Hungarian: Szeszta) is a village and municipality in Košice-okolie District in the Kosice Region of eastern Slovakia. History Historically the village was first mentioned in 1317. Genealogical resources The records for genealogical research are available at the state archive Statny Archiv in Kosice, Slovakia Roman Catholic church records (births/marriages/deaths): 1788-1897 (parish B) Greek Catholic ch...

 

Mindfulness-based stress reduction

Program offering mindfulness training This article needs more reliable medical references for verification or relies too heavily on primary sources. Please review the contents of the article and add the appropriate references if you can. Unsourced or poorly sourced material may be challenged and removed. Find sources: Mindfulness-based stress reduction – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (November 2023) Part of a series onMindfulness Buddhism...

2021–22 NBA season

76th NBA season Sports season2021–22 NBA seasonNBA 75th anniversary diamondLeagueNational Basketball AssociationSportBasketballDurationOctober 19, 2021 – April 10, 2022April 12–15, 2022(play-in tournament)April 16, 2022 – May 29, 2022 (playoffs)June 2–16, 2022 (finals)Number of games82Number of teams30TV partner(s)ABC, TNT, ESPN, NBA TVDraftTop draft pickCade CunninghamPicked byDetroit PistonsRegular seasonTop seedPhoenix SunsSeason MVPNikola Jokić (Denver)Top scorerJoel Embiid (Ph...

 

大字 (数字)

この項目には、一部のコンピュータや閲覧ソフトで表示できない文字が含まれています（詳細）。 数字の大字（だいじ）は、漢数字の一種。通常用いる単純な字形の漢数字（小字）の代わりに同じ音の別の漢字を用いるものである。 概要 壱万円日本銀行券（「壱」が大字） 弐千円日本銀行券（「弐」が大字） 漢数字には「一」「二」「三」と続く小字と、「壱」「�...

 

Sungai Binanga Sangkara

Sungai Binanga SangkaraBinanga Sangkara River, Binanga Sangkarak, Binanga Sangkara', Binanga Sangkara, Sungai KaliboneTampilkan peta SulawesiTampilkan peta IndonesiaEtimologidari Bahasa Makassar Binanga berarti Sungai, Sangkara' berarti luasLokasiNegara IndonesiaProvinsiSulawesi SelatanKabupatenMaros & PangkepKecamatanBontoa, PangkajeneCiri-ciri fisikHulu sungaiSungai Pute - lokasiKecamatan Bontoa, Kabupaten Maros Hulu ke-2Sungai Soreang - lokasiKabupaten Pangkep ...

格奥尔基·季米特洛夫

此條目之中立性有争议。其內容、語調可能帶有明顯的個人觀點或地方色彩。 (2011年6月)加上此模板的編輯者需在討論頁說明此文中立性有爭議的原因，以便讓各編輯者討論和改善。在編輯之前請務必察看讨论页。 格奥尔基·季米特洛夫保加利亚共产党中央委员会总书记任期1948年8月—1949年7月2日前任自己（第一书记）继任维尔科·契尔文科夫保加利亚共产党中央委员会第一�...

 

Gun laws in New Mexico

New Mexico's gun law Location of New Mexico in the United States Gun laws in New Mexico regulate the sale, possession, and use of firearms and ammunition in the state of New Mexico in the United States.[1][2] New Mexico is among states with some of the least restrictive firearms laws in the country. Being part of the Intermountain West, New Mexico is home to a strong gun culture, which is reflected in New Mexico's constitution and gun laws. State laws governing the possession ...

 

哥伦布 (密西西比州)

密西西比州 哥伦布城市綽號：Possum Town哥伦布位于密西西比州的位置坐标：33°30′06″N 88°24′54″W / 33.501666666667°N 88.415°W / 33.501666666667; -88.415国家 美國州密西西比州县朗兹县始建于1821年政府 • 市长罗伯特·史密斯 (民主党)面积 • 总计22.3 平方英里（57.8 平方公里） • 陸地21.4 平方英里（55.5 平方公里） • ...

German Samoa

Colony of the German Empire in Oceania from 1900 to 1920 German SamoaDeutsch-Samoa (German)Siamani-Sāmoa (Samoan)1900–1920 Service flag of the colonial office Coat of arms of the German Empire Brown: German New Guinea; yellow: German Pacific protectorates; red: German Samoa; orange: North Solomons, ceded to BritainStatusGerman colonyCapitalApiaCommon languagesGerman (official, administration) Samoan (native)Tupu Sili (ruler of Samoa) • 1900–1919 Wilhelm II Governor ...

 

Penne Hackforth-Jones

Australian actress (1949–2013) Penne Hackforth-JonesBornPenelope Beatrix Hackforth-Jones(1949-08-05)5 August 1949Greenwich, Connecticut, U.S.Died17 May 2013(2013-05-17) (aged 63)Melbourne, Victoria, AustraliaOccupation(s)Actress, biographer Penne Hackforth-Jones (5 August 1949 – 17 May 2013)[1] was an American-born Australian actress and biographer.[2][3][4][5] Early life Penelope Beatrix Hackforth-Jones[1] was born in Augu...

 

Orphan drug

Regulatory class of pharmaceutical drug An orphan drug is a pharmaceutical agent that is developed to treat certain rare medical conditions. An orphan drug would not be profitable to produce without government assistance, due to the small population of patients affected by the conditions. The conditions that orphan drugs are used to treat are referred to as orphan diseases. The assignment of orphan status to a disease and to drugs developed to treat it is a matter of public policy that depend...

John B. Brisbin

American politician John B. BrisbinMember of the Minnesota House of RepresentativesIn office1863Mayor of Saint Paul, MinnesotaIn office1857–1858 Personal detailsBornJohn Ball Brisbin(1827-01-10)January 10, 1827Schuylerville, New York, U.S.DiedMarch 22, 1898(1898-03-22) (aged 71)Saint Paul, Minnesota, U.S.Political partyDemocraticSpouses Almira George ​ ​(m. 1850; died 1863)​ Margaret M. Jones ​(m. 1865)​ Child...

 

Same-sex marriage in Oaxaca

Part of the LGBT rights seriesLegal status ofsame-sex unions Marriage Andorra Argentina Australia Austria Belgium Brazil Canada Chile Colombia Costa Rica Cuba Denmark Ecuador Estonia Finland France Germany Greece Iceland Ireland Liechtenstein* Luxembourg Malta Mexico Netherlands1 New Zealand2 Norway Portugal Slovenia South Africa Spain Sweden Switzerland Taiwan Thailand* United Kingdom3 United States4 Uruguay Recognized Israel5 Civil unions andregistered partnerships Bolivia Croatia Cyprus C...

 

Alfred Lenoir

Pour les articles homonymes, voir Lenoir. Alfred LenoirPortrait du sculpteur Alfred Lenoir dans son atelier de la rue Boileau, Collection Félix Potin (vers 1920)BiographieNaissance 12 mai 1850Ancien 11e arrondissement de ParisDécès 27 juillet 1920 (à 70 ans)16e arrondissement de ParisSépulture Cimetière du MontparnasseNationalité françaiseActivité SculpteurPère Albert LenoirMère Laure Rey (d)Fratrie Zélia LenoirAngéline Lenoir (d)Conjoint Jenny Desrues (d) (à partir d...

Wolfgang de Beer

Wolfgang de BeerNazionalità Germania Ovest Germania Altezza185 cm Peso90 kg Calcio RuoloAllenatore (ex portiere) Termine carriera2001 - giocatore2018 - allenatore CarrieraSquadre di club1 1981-1986 Duisburg62 (-?)1986-2001 Borussia Dortmund181 (-?) Nazionale 1984 Germania Ovest Under-211 (0) Carriera da allenatore 2001-2018 Borussia Dortmund(prep. port.) 1 I due numeri indicano le presenze e le reti segnate, per le sole partite di campionato.Il simbolo → indica un t...

 

Dock landing ship

Type of amphibious warfare ship USS Harpers Ferry, a United States Navy dock landing ship Soviet Ivan Rogov-class landing ship A dock landing ship (also called landing ship, dock or LSD) is an amphibious warfare ship with a well dock to transport and launch landing craft and amphibious vehicles.[1] Some ships with well decks, such as the Soviet Ivan Rogov class, also have bow doors to enable them to deliver vehicles directly onto a beach (like a tank landing ship). Modern dock la...