The Sheffield and Rotherham Railway opened in 1838, and both industry and housing spread along its route through the Lower Don Valley. Despite its booming population, the district of Brightside did not have an Anglican church, the local congregation instead meeting in a licensed room with a capacity of only seventy people. However, the district had two large Methodist chapels,[2] and the Church Commissioners supported the construction of an Anglican church with a grant of £100.[3] The total cost of construction was £1600, with the remainder being raised by subscription.[4][5]
Initially, the church remained part of the parish of Grimesthorpe, but in 1864, it was given its own parish.[7][10] In 1873, a memorial was erected to William Mannifield, who had been killed in an accident at the nearby Brightside Colliery.[11]
George Pace conducted much work on the church, providing new decorations in 1957, then a new altar, reredos and lectern in the 1960s.[12] It was Grade II listed in 1973,[8] but was closed and deconsecrated in 1979.[13] During the 1980s, it was used as the Sheffield School of Gymnastics,[14] then in 1995 it was restored as part of the TV series Challenge Anneka, to serve as a training centre for Greentop Circus.[15]