The church has its roots in the ghost town of Port Crescent, Michigan. In 1844, Rev. W. Swartz of Ruth, Michigan organized the area Lutherans and ultimately founded the church under the name of The German Evangelical Lutheran St. Peters Church of Port Crescent in 1873. Services were held in private homes. In 1893, the congregation, under Rev. E. Berner, purchased the All Saints Episcopalian Church, which had been built in 1885.
In 1901, Mr. Albert Iseler donated an acre of land to Zion Church.
In 1907, the businessmen of Kinde, Michigan offered the congregation $130 and a plot of land to relocate to their town. The congregation accepted and the church building was moved from Port Crescent. Since then the church has been served by many pastors and joined with Zion Lutheran Church in 1950.
In 1945 the congregation purchased the building of a former Methodist church located about 600 feet (180 m) south for use as a social hall.[2] A 2,500-square-foot (230 m2) addition to the church itself was completed in 1954.[2]
The addition of a hall was completed in 2005.[3] The $200,000, 3,500-square-foot (330 m2) structure contains offices and meeting areas, allowing the congregation to sell the former Methodist church building.[2]
As of 2016[update], St. Peter's Lutheran Church is served by Pastor Larry K. Loree Sr. The church has 68 baptized members with 45 congregants on an average Sunday.[5]
