The church began informally in 1890 as St. Andrews Mission, with support from All Saints Episcopal Church in nearby Pasadena.[2] In 1905, a temporary structure was built on the corner of Monterey Road and Fremont Avenue, where the current church would be later built.[2]
In 1919, a $3,000 (equivalent to $53,000 in 2023) addition was started, which included a stage and dressing rooms.[5] The chimes were donated to the building by aviator Pancho Barnes,[6] who, on January 5, 1921, had married Rev. C. Rankin Barnes at the church.[6]
The tower was damaged in the 1987 Whittier Narrows earthquake.[7] When the tower was repaired and retrofitted to meet earthquake protection standards,[2] the chapel's pillars were narrowed, which had been obstructing views of the front of the church from rear pews.[7]