Skillet was recorded in Memphis, Tennessee, at Ardent Studios in 1996. Skillet, at the time, was a three-piece band consisting of John Cooper on vocals, bass guitar and piano, Ken Steorts on guitar, backing vocals and guitar synth, and Trey McClurkin on drums and backing vocals. Prior to releasing their eponymous debut album, the band recorded Right Upside Your Head, a six-song demo on cassette tape, earlier that same year. The songs "Shovel" and "Darn Great Day" were exclusive to the demo while "Gasoline", "Promise Blender" and "Boundaries" would be re-recorded for Skillet. The demo version of "Boundaries" features Ken Steorts on vocals. The demo track "Safe With Me" was re-recorded as "Safe With You" on the band's debut album.
According to Steorts in a 1997 interview, the band's name came from Rick Miller, a pastor at Covenant Community Church.[4] In 2022, Cooper said his desired name for Skillet's debut album was Right Upside Yo Head, though the record label disagreed with using it.[5]
Skillet's self-titled album was the band's only album with more than one music video until the release of their sixth studio album, Comatose, in 2006, which had four.
"I Can" is a simple video, and shows the band playing on a stage along with various shots of the crowd worshipping God. The video was shot during an actual live show, as it adds an extra portion of the band playing and a part at the end of the song where John Cooper shares his testimony with the crowd.
"Gasoline" also shows the band playing on a stage, though it is unknown if this was during an actual show or simply a video shoot. It also features scenes of John crawling around in an outdoor scene, meant to be crying out for God. The music video was later included on The Early Years (1996–2001), Skillet's first compilation album, in 2010.
The "Saturn" music video features the band wandering around a large telescope and laboratory, as well as playing on a rooftop.