Leslie Rees felt the play was "disappointing in that it is a drama of tempestuous vigour rather than of true power. It is hair-raisingly startling rather than poetically elevating." Rees did think "The construction and organic development are extremely well handled. The characters are clear and distinct. But for the most part they are extremely unpleasant."[2]
Plot
A ship is wrecked on the West Australian coast. The play starts after the shipwreck, with over 300 people on an island. They include Lucretia, her husband Van Mylen, the captain Pelsart, a pastor, Sebastian, his daughter Judith and Pelsart's butler, Henyrock. The men are restless. Pelsart decides to return to Batavia, against advice, and also sends some men led by Hays to find water.
In the absence of Pelsart and Hays, some of the men, led by Cornelius, lead a revolt. They steal gold, massacre men, and keep women as sex slaves. Cornelius takes Lucretia after her husband is murdered, although he waits for a time. A mutineer Huyssen taunts Sebastian and the pastor kills him and his killed in turn.
Hays returns and defeats the mutineers. Pelsart returns and executes Cornelius and other mutineers. He falls dead of a heart attack before Cornelius is taken away. Hay returns to Batavia with the survivors including Lucretia.
^"THEATER". Catholic Weekly. Vol. VIII, no. 394. New South Wales, Australia. 15 September 1949. p. 5 (Magazine Section). Retrieved 18 July 2023 – via National Library of Australia.
^"AUSTRALIAN PLAY". The Age. No. 29, 854. Victoria, Australia. 3 January 1951. p. 4. Retrieved 18 July 2023 – via National Library of Australia.
^"Australian plays at the Union Theatre". The Sydney Morning Herald. 10 January 1962. p. 6.
^"Musicals outshone the plays". The Sydney Morning Herald. 16 July 1962. p. 77.