Reynolds was born in Bloemfontein, but grew up in Welkom, where he earned call-ups to represent the Griffons provincial side at national competitions since primary school level. He represented them at the Under-13 Craven Week in 2008, the Under-16 Grant Khomo Week in 2011 and played twice at the premier high school rugby union tournament in South Africa, the Under-18 Craven Week, in 2012 and 2013. He was the main kicker for the team at the 2013 event held in Polokwane, kicking 47 points in addition to scoring two tries to finish the tournament as the overall top scorer.[2] He also played at Under-19 level for the Griffons in their 2012 and 2013 campaigns.
Reynolds was named in the Golden Lions XV squad for the 2016 Currie Cup qualification series. He made his first class debut by coming on as a replacement in their opening match against the Border Bulldogs in a 23–27 defeat.[7] He again played off the bench in their next match against Namibian side the Welwitschias in Windhoek and scored his first senior points as he converted to tries in a 66–12 victory for his side.[8] He was promoted to the starting line-up for their next match against Gauteng rivals the Blue Bulls and kicked eleven points in a 38–17 victory.[9] The next week, he scored his first senior try in a 24–27 defeat to Western Province in Cape Town.[10]
He alternated the starting fly-half spot with the more experienced Marnitz Boshoff for the next few weeks of the campaign, before travelling with the LionsSuper Rugby team for their final match of the regular season against the Jaguares in Buenos Aires.[11]
Notes
^ On the SARU points scorer page, Arrie Vosloo's are split; some of them are listed against Jacobus Vosloo. This is due to duplicate player profiles existing for the player. If added together, he was the third top scorer.