Dutey played youth football with the One7 Academy, before heading to Liberty University in 2016 to play in college. Over four seasons with the Flames, Dutey made 55 appearances and scored 2 goals.[1]
Dutey signed his first professional contract with USL Championship side Charlotte Independence ahead of their 2020 season. Dutey didn't appear in 2020, but re-signed with the club on 14 April 2021.[6] He made his professional debut on 1 May 2021, appearing as an 88th-minute substitute during a 3–0 loss to Tampa Bay Rowdies.[7]