In May 2010, Iftikhar was named the reserve team manager for Hesketh Bank after previously working with the junior teams[7] since 2007 at age 17 while working on his early coaching badges.[8]
In 2015, he was named manager of the senior squad the day before the season began. Despite working with a completely new squad and a difficult start to the season, the team finished out of the relegation zone. He also continued to strengthen the reserve squad and saw it promoted to the top reserve league that season. He declined an offer to continue being the squad's manager and left the club following the season.[8] While at Hesketh, he was mentored by Dave Sutton, former professional player and manager of Rochdale.[2]
Nelson
In June 2012, Iftikar was appointed a first team coach of Nelson of the North West Counties Football League prior to the 2012–13 season.[4] In October 2012 he temporarily took charge of the senior team after co-managers Robert Grimes and Michael Morrison resigned in October 2012.[9][10]
In May 2016, he was appointed manager of Bayangol of the Mongolia Premier League[12] The previous season, Bayangol were playing in the Mongolia 1st League but were forced into promotion by the Mongolian Football Federation ten days before the season began after second division club, Continental, declined promotion after earning it for financial reasons. Bayangol were unable to meet Premier League requirements for the team's manager to hold at least an UEFA "B" license or equivalent so they posted the opening on Twitter.[5] Prior to his move to Mongolia, Iftikhar was preparing to travel to Canada for a coaching position he had accepted.[13]
By 2021, Iftikhar was part of the staff of Skelmersdale United of the North West Counties League Premier Division.[17] At the end of November 2021, Iftikhar was appointed manager of Fort William in the Scottish Highland Football League[18] who were deemed "The Worst Team in Britain" in 2019, by many news media publishers.[19][20][21]
During his early years coaching Hesketh Bank, Iftikhar met Wigan Athletic manager Roberto Martinez, and become a voluntary scout for two years at the club.[2]
Everton
Iftikhar followed Martinez to Everton after his appointment as manager in 2013, and spent further two years working under Martinez at Goodison Park.[25]