The album reached No. 10 on the UK Indie Chart.[7] The album failed to gain much popularity outside of the UK.[4] David Toop, writing for The Times described it as an "impressive" debut.[3] The Orlando Sentinel praised "the altered-state guitars and the biting irony lurking in the lyrics."[6]
Doug Brod, writing for Trouser Press, described the album as a "most impressive debut", writing that the diverse influences on the album "created an instantly familiar record that ultimately sounds like no one else".[4] According to Ira Robbins, also from Trouser Press, it was "grossly underappreciated".[8]
Sell Me a God was released on CD, MC and vinyl, with the CD and MC release adding three bonus tracks, including a cover of "Summer in the City" by the Lovin' Spoonful.[4]
Track listing
All tracks composed by Eat
"Tombstone" – 2:53
"Electric City" – 4:02
"Fatman" – 4:50
"Stories" – 2:42
"Walking Man" – 3:51
"Skin" – 4:43
"Red Moon" – 5:49 (bonus track on CD and MC release)
"Insect Head" – 5:24
"Body Bag" – 5:04
"Things I Need" – 4:14
"Judgement Train" – 4:12
"Gyrate" – 6:06 (bonus track on CD and MC release)