After a short stint on the roster of Women's Professional Soccer club Chicago Red Stars in 2009, Wagenfuhr played for the Buffalo Flash of the W-League. With the Flash, Wagenfuhr logged 1,170 minutes in the midfield, notching a goal and two assists in her time with the club.[2]
In 2010, the Saint Louis Athletica picked up Wagenfuhr as a free agent.[3] She suffered a hamstring injury at the 23rd minute of the season opener against the Red Stars,[4] which cut short what would be her only match played with Athletica.[5] On June 1, 2010, Wagenfuhr again became a free agent upon the dissolution of the Athletica.[6]
In 2010, she signed with Littleton, Colorado-based Colorado Rush of the W-League, the second tier of American women's soccer.[7] On June 24, 2010, Wagenfuhr assisted on the game-winning goal in the expansion side's first-ever victory, a 2–0 triumph over the Santa Clarita Blue Heat.[8]
After soccer
She continued on to teach at Florida State University Schools as an English teacher.[citation needed]