Russell on Crime

"A Treatise on Crimes and Misdemeanours" redirects here. For the general topic, see legal treatise.

A Treatise on Crimes and Misdemeanours or Russell on Crime is a book originally written by William Oldnall Russell.[1] For the purpose of citation, its name may be abbreviated to Russ Cr.[2]

Russell's Treatise on Crimes and Misdemeanours, which appeared in 1819 in two volumes in octavo, was pronounced by Warren (Law Student, 2nd edit. p. 620) "the best general treatise in criminal law". A second edition appeared in 1827; a third, edited by C. S. Greaves, in 1843, with a supplement in 1851; a fourth, in 3 volumes, in 1865; and a fifth, edited by S. Prentice, Q.C., in 1877. The American editions, of which seven were issued between 1824 and 1853, do not reproduce the whole work.[3]

In 1847, J G Marvin said of the third London and fifth American editions:[4]

The American editions, excepting the last, do not contain the whole of Russell on Crimes, from the supposed inapplicability, on the part of the editors, of certain parts of the work to this country. Its appreciation among us is best shown by the number of American editions. The notes of American Cases are numerous and able, and no English law book has received more careful and excellent editorial care than Russell on Crimes. Professor Whiteside remarks, that the second volume contains the best summary of the leading principles of the Law of Evidence, especially relating to Criminal Jurisprudence, he has ever met with. It is said to have been drawn up by Mr. Williams, the learned author of the work on Executors. Mr. Warren says, it is the best general Treatise on Criminal Law. 1 Leg. Reporter, 298; Hoff. Leg. Stu. 438;[5] Warren's L. S. 620.[6]

The most recent edition of Russell on Crime was the twelfth edition, which was published in 1964.[7]

References

  • Marke (ed). A Catalogue of the Law Collection at New York University. Law Center of New York University. New York. 1953. Law Book Exchange Ltd. Union, New Jersey. 1999. Page 453.
  • Linsay Farmer, "Of Treatises and Textbooks" in Fernandez and Dubber (eds). Law Books in Action: Essays on the Anglo-American Legal Treatise. Hart Publishing. Oxford and Portland, Oregon. 2012. Pages 154 to 156.
  • Lindsay Farmer. Making the Modern Criminal Law. Oxford University Press. 2016. Pages 146 and 147.

Editions

  • First Edition. London. 1819. vol 2.
  • First American Edition. 1824. Vols 1 and 2.
  • Second Edition. London. 1826. Vol 1. 1828. Vol 2.
  • Third Edition. London. 1843. Vols 1 [1] [2] and 2.
  • Sixth American Edition. 1850. Vols 1 and 2
  • Eighth American Edition. 1857. Vols 1 and 2
  • Fourth Edition (1865) C. S. Greaves[8]
  • Fifth Edition (1877) S. Prentice[8]
  • Sixth Edition (1896) Horace Smith and A. P. P. Keep[8]
  • Seventh Edition (1909) W. F. Craies and L. W. Kershaw [8]
  • Eighth Edition (1923) R. E. Ross and G. B. McClure[8]
  • Ninth Edition 1936) R. E. Ross [8]
  • Tenth Edition (1950) J. W. Cecil Turner[8]
  • Eleventh Edition. 1958, 2 volumes,[8] Stevens & Sons Ltd, 1964.
  • Twelfth Edition. 1964, 2 volumes, Sweet & Maxwell Ltd, 1964.[9] Google Books

Reviews

  • Daniel Davis (1825) 20 North American Review 224 JSTOR
  • (1853) 1 American Law Register 448 JSTOR
  • W B L (1896) 35 American Law Register and Review (New Series) 679 (Old Series volume 44) JSTOR
  • P W H (1924) 2 Cambridge Law Journal 126 JSTOR
  • J W C T (1937) 6 Cambridge Law Journal 281 JSTOR
  • (1937) 2 University of Toronto Law Journal 200 JSTOR
  • A Ll A (1952) 11 Cambridge Law Journal 316 JSTOR
  • C (1952) 15 Modern Law Review 260 JSTOR
  • Francis A Allen (1952) 43 Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology, and Police Science 228 JSTOR
  • Walter P Armstrong Jr (1959) 45 ABA Journal 194 JSTOR
  • C (1959) 22 Modern Law Review 708 JSTOR
  • Rupert Cross (1964) 22 Cambridge Law Journal 286 JSTOR
  • Richard F Sparks (1965) 28 Modern Law Review 497 JSTOR

Footnotes

  1. ^ Marvin. pp. 36 and 624.
  2. ^ Archbold Criminal Pleading, Evidence and Practice. 1999. p. xix.
  3. ^ Norgate, Gerald le Grys (1897). "Russell, William Oldnall" . In Lee, Sidney (ed.). Dictionary of National Biography. Vol. 49. London: Smith, Elder & Co. p. 490.
  4. ^ A Treatise on Crimes and Misdemeanors. 3d ed. By C. S. Greaves. 5th American from the 3d London ed.; with the Notes and References, of Daniel Davis and Theron Metcalf, Esq'rs., and additional Notes and References, by George Sharswood. 2 vols. 8vo. Philadelphia. 1845.
  5. ^ Google Books
  6. ^ Marvin, J G. Legal Bibliography, or a thesaurus of American, English, Irish and Scotch law books:together with some continental treatises. T & J W Johnson. 1847. Page 624.
  7. ^ Archbold Criminal Pleading, Evidence and Practice. 1999. p. xix.
  8. ^ a b c d e f g h Wildy & Sons Booksellers. "Russell on Crime 11th ed".
  9. ^ Wildy & Sons Booksellers. "Russell on Crime 12th ed"