Finsterwald attended Syracuse University, where he received varsity letters in football, basketball and baseball. He played for the Syracuse Orange football team in 1916 and 1917.[3][4] After the 1917 season, he served in the U.S. Army during World War I, attaining the rank of second lieutenant. After his discharge, he enrolled at Ohio University, where he played during the 1919 season as a member of the Ohio Bobcats football team.[3]
During the fall of 1920, Finsterwald returned to Ohio University as the coach of the school's football team. He coached the team from 1920 to 1922 and compiled a 13–10–1 record. Finsterwald also coached the Ohio Bobcats men's basketball team from 1920 to 1922, leading the team to a 34–6 record.[3]
Family and later life
Finsterwald died in 1962 in Athens, Ohio, at age 65.[2] In 1965, he was posthumously inducted into the Ohio University Athletic Hall of Fame. His son, Dow Finsterwald, became a professional golfer, won the 1958 PGA Championship, and was inducted into Ohio University Athletic Hall of Fame four years after his father.[6]