David Hemingway from Melody Maker commented, "'Rough with the Smooth' starts with the flourish of strings that we've come to expect. Thirty seconds in and I had great plans for Single of the Week — a minute later it's become, bizarrely, 'The Kids from Fame'."[2] Pan-European magazine Music & Media named the song Single of the Week, writing, "Many so-called "dance divas" pretend they can sing; Shara is for real. Mixing her smooth vocals with the fairly rough backing, composition and arrangement are almost restyled Bacharach/David."[3] Johnny Cigarettes from NME said, "'Rough with the Smooth' is a swaying, swinging gospel-inflected love song that's not quite in the same league as such epic spine-tinglers as 'One Goodbye in Ten' or 'Inside Out', but will still make your coffee table move its feet. Which is quite an achievement, when you think about it."[4]
Track listing
UK CD single (7243 8 82424 2 4)
"Rough with the Smooth" (7-inch edit) – 3:51
"Rough with the Smooth" (Street Level mix) – 4:48
"Rough with the Smooth" (extended album mix) – 5:26
"Rough with the Smooth" (Long Island Expressway mix) – 8:22
"Rough with the Smooth" (Franktified dub) – 7:54
"Rough with the Smooth" (Saturday Night at the Glasshouse mix) – 4:56