One elder from the church spoke to the examining body and: "pointed out that these doctrines were not new or strange for the congregation even if they were unique in the presbytery; indeed, they had been believed and taught for quite some time at Reformed Heritage (going back to Peter Leithart’s tenure as pastor in the late 1980s and early 1990s, if not before). It was also pointed out that this was a transfer exam, not an ordination exam, and all [Lusk's] positions had been acceptable in Louisiana presbytery. Catholicity and intra-denominational brotherhood demanded they receive [Lusk]."[5]
The Evangel Presbytery declined the transfer. The elders from the church asked for a formal reason for the decision but this request was denied them.[5] Lusk states: "I think the Evangel committee’s decision against recommending me was borne out of a lack of confidence to play the part of judge in the so-called “Auburn Avenue” or “Federal Vision” controversy."[5] He went on to state, however: "I regarded, and continue to regard, all the men who served on Evangel’s committee as exemplary Christian men. They are faithful pastors and servants in Christ’s kingdom. Our disagreement over covenant children does not outweigh the many truths we hold in common."[5]
After Lusk's arrival the church session voted to change its name to Trinity Presbyterian Church.[5]
^Rich Lusk, 'Paedofaith: A Primer on the Mystery of Infant Salvation and a Handbook for Covenant Parents, p. ii Athanasius Press, Monroe, Louisiana (2005)