In 1879, Alfred Kempe published a proof of the four color theorem, one of the big conjectures in graph theory.[1]
While the theorem is true, Kempe's proof is incorrect. Percy John Heawood illustrated it in 1890[2]
with a counter-example, and de la Vallée-Poussin reached the same conclusion in 1896 with the Poussin graph.[3]
Kempe's (incorrect) proof is based on alternating chains, and as those chains prove useful in graph theory mathematicians remain interested in such counterexamples.
More were found later: first, the Errera graph in 1921,[4][5]
then the Kittell graph in 1935, with 23 vertices,[6]
and finally two minimal counter-examples (the Soifer graph in 1997 and the Fritsch graph in 1998, both of order 9).[7][8][9]
References
^Kempe, A. B. "On the Geographical Problem of Four-Colors." Amer. J. Math. 2, 193–200, 1879.
^P. J. Heawood, "Map colour theorem", Quart. J. Pure Appl. Math. 24 (1890), 332–338.
^R. A. Wilson, Graphs, colourings and the four-colour theorem, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2002. MR1888337Zbl1007.05002.
^Errera, A. "Du coloriage des cartes et de quelques questions d'analysis situs." Ph.D. thesis. 1921.