Pornography Victims Compensation Act

This article is part of a series about
Mitch McConnell
U.S. Senator from Kentucky

United States Senate

The Pornography Victims Compensation Act of 1991 was a bill, S. 983,[1] in the U.S. Congress. The sponsor in the Senate was Senator Mitch McConnell[2] with eight cosponsors.[1] A Senate committee held hearings on the bill.[1][3] The bill was not voted on, did not pass, and did not become law.

Legislative substance

Under the bill, a person who was attacked after the attacker was substantially spurred by pornography could have been able to sue the pornography's producers, publishers, distributors, exhibitors, and sellers without needing a prior criminal charge against the pornography itself.[2][4] It was written not to prohibit any publication, but to hold liable for certain consequences, according to McConnell.[2] For political pragmatism, the bill was limited to child pornography and obscene material, that being already unprotected by the U.S. Constitution's First Amendment.[2][5]

As part of the rationale for passage, McConnell argued "that crime is fostered by a culture in which the sexual degradation, abuse, and murder of women and children are a form of entertainment", that "[t]he connection between the amount of violent entertainment and the amount of real-life violence is no longer seriously doubted among social scientists," that "more than one million children from six months to sixteen years old are sexually molested and then filmed or photographed", and that "[p]ornography is fueling violence in this country".[6]

Title

The formal title varied by year, as listed in the History section, below.

Informally, it was known as the Bundy Bill, after serial murderer Ted Bundy, who attributed his killings partly to porn.[5][7][8]

History

The bill or versions of it had been under congressional consideration for several years prior. Earlier versions reached a wider range of pornography[2] but had less support; narrowing that range to what was unprotected by Supreme Court decisions on the First Amendment led to wider support.

Other versions, searched for as introduced from approximately 1973 to part of 2010, included these:

  • Pornography Victims Protection Act of 1984, S. 3063 in the Senate, introduced by Sen. Arlen Specter with no cosponsors.[9] Hearings were held and, according to Sen. Specter, "[w]itnesses disagreed sharply about the general social effects of such [pornographic] materials. Some, such as Andrea Dworkin and Catherine [sic] MacKinnon, claimed that violent pornography is central to gender unequally [sic] in our society. Others, including Barry Lynn of the American Civil Liberties Union, denied that such a broad factual claim has been conclusively established.[10] Sen. Specter considered it "premature" to introduce legislation "based on a civil rights approach", referring to an Indianapolis ordinance and a proposed Minneapolis ordinance,[10] but did introduce S. 3063[10] instead.
  • Pornography Victims Protection Act of 1985, S. 1187 in the Senate, introduced by Sen. Arlen Specter with one cosponsor.[11][12] In 1987, Sen. Specter said this bill was a "companion" to H.R. 5509 (appearing in this list).[13] This bill, S. 1187, was cited in a court case, in a judge's dissenting opinion.[14]
  • Pornography Victims Protection Act of 1986, H.R. 5509 in the House of Representatives, introduced by Rep. Bill Green with 27 cosponsors.[15] Sen. Specter, speaking in 1987, said H.R. 5509 "received strong bipartisan support."[13]
  • Pornography Victims Protection Act of 1987, H.R. 1213 in the House of Representatives and S. 703 in the Senate (whether the bills were identical is not stated), introduced respectively by Rep. Bill Green with 118 cosponsors and by Sen. Arlen Specter with 15 cosponsors.[16] For S. 703, Sen. Specter made a public statement on the day he introduced the bill, explaining its premises and listing some of the support it has received.[17] For both bills, subcommittees of the respective judiciary committees held hearings.[16]
  • Pornography Victims Protection Act of 1989, H.R. 3472 in the House of Representatives, introduced by Rep. Bill Green with 61 cosponsors.[18]
  • Pornography Victims Compensation Act of 1989, S. 1226 in the Senate, introduced by Sen. Mitch McConnell with 11 cosponsors.[19]
  • Pornography Victims Compensation Act of 1989, H.R. 3785 in the House of Representatives, introduced by Rep. Tom Tauke with 25 cosponsors.[19]
  • Pornography Victims Protection Act of 1991, H.R. 1768 in the House of Representatives, introduced by Rep. Bill Green with 68 cosponsors.[20]
  • Pornography Victims' Compensation Act of 1992, S. 1521 in the Senate, introduced by Sen. Mitch McConnell with 15 cosponsors.[1][21]
  • Pornography Victims Protection Act of 1993, H.R. 2174 in the House of Representatives, introduced by Rep. Jan Meyers with 33 cosponsors.[22]

Supporters and opponents

1991 bill

Support came from Feminists Fighting Pornography and 200 National Organization for Women (NOW) chapters, but not two in New York and California[5] and not from the national level of NOW.[7] Support simultaneously came from Christian fundamentalists.[7]

Opponents included Feminists for Free Expression, Nadine Strossen, Betty Friedan, Marcia Pally, Adrienne Rich, Katha Pollitt, Karen DeCrow, Nora Ephron, Mary Gordon, Judy Blume, Jamaica Kincaid, Erica Jong, Susan Isaacs, Mary Morello, and "172 other feminist women".[23]

1992 bill

Supporters, according to Sen. McConnell, included the Family Research Council, Feminists Fighting Pornography, the American Family Association, victims rights groups, and some chapters of the National Organization for Women.[24] The opposition included an editorial in The New York Times.[25]

Criticism

Criticisms came from more than one direction: that the bill would punish a wide range of nonpornographic movies because criminals were inspired by them,[2] that it would lead to bans of feminist positive literature about women,[2] that booksellers would be timid about many titles that weren't obscene but just generally controversial,[5] that scientists hadn't established a firm link between porn and misbehavior,[5][7] that criminals should be held responsible for their actions rather than third parties being held liable,[5][7] that similar legislation against bars because subsequent drunken driving led to accidents had not been tested against major beer producers,[5] that using civil procedure rather than criminal to test if material is obscene when the standard of proof is lower in civil cases would make finding it obscene more likely,[7] that juries seeing an attacked woman as a victim would be likelier to judge that material was obscene,[7] that obscenity being defined by community standards and retailers' skittishness meant that the strictest community would be the standard-bearer for the nation,[7] and that it didn't encompass all the pornography that feminists found violated women's civil rights.[5]

References

  1. ^ a b c d 'Bill Summary & Status Search Results, in THOMAS website of The Library of Congress[permanent dead link‍], as accessed Sep. 11, 2010.
  2. ^ a b c d e f g Reske, Henry J., "Feminists Back Anti-Porn Bill", in American Bar Association Journal (ABAJ), Jun., 1992, vol. 78, p. 32 (ISSN 0747-0088) (ProQuest database), as accessed Jan. 24, 2010, or alternative link.
  3. ^ Legislative Proposals For Compensation of Victims of Sexual Crimes: Hearing Before the Committee on the Judiciary: United States Senate: One Hundred Second Congress: First Session: On the Pornography Victims' Compensation Act of 1991 and the Pornography Victims' Protection Act of 1991, July 23, 1991, S. Hrg. 102-471 (Serial No. J-102-33) (Washington [D.C.]: U.S. Government Printing Office 1992), in LexisNexis Congressional Hearings Digital Collection (re bills S. 983 (102d Cong) and S. 1521 (102d Cong)) (Durable URL), via http://web.lexis-nexis.com/congcomp/document? . . . (whole URL not preserved) and other LexisNexis URLs, as accessed May 28, 2010.
  4. ^ Torrey, Morrison, The Resurrection of the Antipornography Ordinance, in Texas Journal of Women and the Law, vol. 2, issue 1, pp. 116–117 (Winter 1993) (author assoc. prof., De Paul Univ. Coll. of Law).
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h Puente, Maria, Bill Holds Porn Producers Liable For Sex Crimes, in USA Today, Apr. 15, 1992, p. 09A (Final ed.) (in ProQuest), as accessed Jan. 24, 2010, or alternative link.
  6. ^ Four quotations: Greco, Albert N., The First Amendment, Freedom of the Press, and the Issue of "Harm": A Conundrum for Publishers, in Publishing Research Quarterly, vol. 11, no. 4, p. 48 & nn. 35–37 (Winter 1995/96) (author clinical assoc. prof., N.Y. Univ.) (article also appears as chap. in The Book Publishing Industry in the United States (Allyn & Bacon (probably), 1996)).
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h Bundy's Revenge: How to Sue Playboy, by Maureen Dezell, in The New Republic, vol. 206, no. 10, Mar. 9, 1992, pp. 15–16 (ProQuest (Platinum Periodicals) database (Full Text - PDF)), as accessed Jan. 25, 2010, an alternative link, as accessed Jan. 28, 2010, or another alternative link.
  8. ^ Torrey, Morrison, The Resurrection of the Anti-Pornography Ordinance, op. cit., p. 116 n. 17.
  9. ^ Bill Summary & Status Search Results, in THOMAS website of The Library of Congress[permanent dead link‍], as accessed Sep. 11, 2010.
  10. ^ a b c United States of America, Congressional Record: Proceedings and Debates of the 98th Congress Second Session, vol. 130, part 21, p. 29169, Oct. 3, 1984 (Washington [D.C.]: U.S. Gov't Printing Ofc., [final or permanent ed. (red bound)] 1984) (part 21 is Oct. 3–4, 1984, i.e., pp. 28831–30289) (Sen. Specter's statement at pp. 29169–29175 & bill's introduction also at pp. 29153–29154) (although Sen. Specter asked that his Federal bill be printed with his statement, per id., p. 29170, it was not (pp. 29170–29175)) (pp. 29153–29154 & 29169–29175 may correlate for content with, in the daily ed., p. S 13192 & probably other pp.).
  11. ^ Bill Summary & Status Search Results, in THOMAS website of The Library of Congress[permanent dead link‍], as accessed Sep. 11, 2010.
  12. ^ United States of America, Congressional Record: Proceedings and Debates of the 99th Congress, First Session, vol. 131, no. 69, May 23, 1985 (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office), pp. S 6853–S 6855 ("Continuation of Senate Proceedings of May 22, 1985, Issue No. 68; and Proceedings of May 23, 1985, Issue No. 69.", id., cover I) ("daily Congressional Record", per id., p. D 600, thus not the final or permanent ed.).
  13. ^ a b Congressional Record, vol. 133, no. 32, Mar. 10, 1987, p. S 2932 ("daily Congressional Record", per id., p. D 236).
  14. ^ People v. P.J. Video, 65 N.Y.2d 566, 578, 493 N.Y.S.2d 988, 483 N.E.2d 1120 (Jul. 5, 1985) (dissent) ("The promotion of obscenity for profit creates and advances a clear and present danger to the participants in the movies, as well as to women generally, resulting from conceivable instances where a viewer of such films seeks, by compulsion, to simulate that which he has viewed"), per N.Y. Ct. App. Rpts., in Loislaw (with N.Y. State Bar Ass'n), as accessed Sep. 11, 2010 (citing also Congressional Record, vol. 131, pp. S6853–S6855).
  15. ^ Bill Summary & Status Search Results, in THOMAS website of The Library of Congress[permanent dead link‍], as accessed Sep. 11, 2010.
  16. ^ a b Bill Summary & Status Search Results, in THOMAS website of The Library of Congress[permanent dead link‍], as accessed Sep. 11, 2010.
  17. ^ Congressional Record, vol. 133, no. 32, Mar. 10, 1987, pp. S 2931–S 2933 ("daily Congressional Record", per id., p. D 236) (bill's introduction also at p. S 2921) (pp. S 2931–S 2933 may correlate for content with, in the final or permanent ed., pp. 5147 (re S. 703) & 5160 (re Feminists Fighting Pornography)).
  18. ^ Bill Summary & Status Search Results, in THOMAS website of The Library of Congress[permanent dead link‍], as accessed Sep. 11, 2010.
  19. ^ a b Bill Summary & Status Search Results, in THOMAS website of The Library of Congress[permanent dead link‍], as accessed Sep. 11, 2010.
  20. ^ Bill Summary & Status Search Results, in THOMAS website of The Library of Congress[permanent dead link‍], as accessed Sep. 11, 2010.
  21. ^ Pornographer Liability For Physical Harms Caused by Obscenity and Child Pornography: A Tort Analysis, in Georgia Law Review, vol. 27, no. 3 (Spring, 1993), [§] Notes, p. 850 & n. 9 and see nn. 10–11 ISSN 0016-8300.
  22. ^ Bill Summary & Status Search Results, in THOMAS website of The Library of Congress[permanent dead link‍], as accessed Sep. 11, 2010.
  23. ^ Strossen, Nadine, A Feminist Critique of "the" Feminist Critique of Pornography, in Virginia Law Review, vol. 79, no. 5 (Aug., 1993), p. 1099 ff. (essay), esp. p. 1188 ff. (appx.), in DOI link accessing JStor (or direct JStor link), both as accessed Sep. 7, 2010 (former leading to latter).
  24. ^ Greco, Albert N., The First Amendment, Freedom of the Press, and the Issue of "Harm", op. cit., p. 48 & nn. 35–36.
  25. ^ Greco, Albert N., The First Amendment, Freedom of the Press, and the Issue of "Harm", op. cit., p. 48 (Times editorial published April 13, 1992).

Further reading

  • Torrey, Morrison, The Resurrection of the Antipornography Ordinance, in Texas Journal of Women and the Law, vol. 2, issue 1, p. 113 (Winter 1993) (author assoc. prof., De Paul Univ. Coll. of Law), comparing the bill to the Dworkin-MacKinnon model proposal and their histories, discussing state legislation in Illinois and Massachusetts and developments in Canada and the United Nations, and outlining judicial recognition of pornography in workplaces as sexually harassing under a Federal civil rights statute.

Read other articles:

العلاقات البوليفية الفنزويلية

العلاقات البوليفية الفنزويلية بوليفيا فنزويلا   بوليفيا   فنزويلا تعديل مصدري - تعديل   العلاقات البوليفية الفنزويلية هي العلاقات الثنائية التي تجمع بين بوليفيا وفنزويلا.[1][2][3][4][5] مقارنة بين البلدين هذه مقارنة عامة ومرجعية للدولتين: وجه ...

 

Henri Becquerel

Antoine Henri BecquerelHenri Becquerel pada tahun 1905Lahir(1852-12-15)15 Desember 1852 Paris, PrancisMeninggal25 Agustus 1908(1908-08-25) (umur 55) Le Croisic, Bretagne, FranceKebangsaan PrancisAlmamaterPoliteknikSekolah Teknik SipilDikenal atasPenemuan RadioaktifPenghargaanNobel Fisika (1903)Karier ilmiahBidangFisika, KimiaInstitusiConservatori Nasional Seni dan KerajinanPoliteknikMuseum Nasional Sejarah AlamMahasiswa doktoralMarie Curie Tanda tanganCatatan Perhatikan bahwa dia adalah...

 

Terjemahan mesin

Artikel ini sudah memiliki daftar referensi, bacaan terkait, atau pranala luar, tetapi sumbernya belum jelas karena belum menyertakan kutipan pada kalimat. Mohon tingkatkan kualitas artikel ini dengan memasukkan rujukan yang lebih mendetail bila perlu. (Pelajari cara dan kapan saatnya untuk menghapus pesan templat ini) Bahasa Tionghoa yang keliru 沒有 進入 dari hasil terjemahan mesin di Bali, Indonesia. Kalimat bahasa Tionghoa yang terputus ini maknanya kurang lebih tidak ada entri atau b...

Caste system in India

Social classification practiced in India This article is about socio-political stratification in Indian society. For socio-religious Hindu stratification, see Varna (Hinduism). Castes in India redirects here. For the book, see Castes in India: Their Mechanism, Genesis and Development. Mahatma Gandhi visiting Madras (now Chennai) in 1933 on an India-wide tour for Dalit (he used Harijan) causes. His writings, and speeches during such tours, discussed the discriminated-against castes of India. T...

 

2016–17 Saint Peter's Peacocks men's basketball team

American college basketball season This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: 2016–17 Saint Peter's Peacocks men's basketball team – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (February 2024) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) 2016–17 Saint Peter's Peacocks men's basketballCIT cha...

 

Kegubernuran Shabwah

Shabwah شبوةKegubernuranNegaraYamanIbu kotaAtaqLuas • Total47.728 km2 (18,428 sq mi)Populasi (2011)[1] • Total568.000 • Kepadatan0,012/km2 (0,031/sq mi) Shabwah (Arab: شبوةcode: ar is deprecated Šabwa) adalah sebuah kegubernuran di Yaman, yang beribu kota di Ataq. Distrik Distrik Ain Distrik At-Talh Distrik Ar-Rawdah Distrik Arma Distrik As-Said Distrik Ataq Distrik Bayhan Distrik Dhar Distrik Habban Distrik Hatib D...

Persatuan supranasional

Persatuan supranasional adalah sejenis persatuan politik multinasional yang menyerahkan kuasa tiap negara anggotanya kepada pemerintah yang berada di atasnya. Konsep persatuan supranasional kadang digunakan untuk menyebut Uni Eropa (UE) sebagai jenis badan politik baru.[1] UE adalah satu-satunya badan yang melaksanakan pemilihan umum internasional dan mendobrak integrasi politik yang normalnya diatur dalam perjanjian internasional. Istilah supranasional biasanya digunakan dalam makna ...

 

Cherchez La Femme

This article is about the song performed by Dr. Buzzard's Original Savannah Band and later by Gloria Estefan. For the French phrase, see Cherchez la femme. Whispering/Cherchez La Femme/Se Si BonSingle by Dr. Buzzard's Original Savannah Bandfrom the album Dr. Buzzard's Original Savannah Band A-sideWhispering/Cherchez La Femme/Se Si BonB-sideSunshower (U.S.)Released1976RecordedHouse of Music, West Orange, New Jersey, 1976GenreDisco, pop, big bandLength5:46 (album version) 3:33 (7 single)LabelRC...

 

Walls of Ávila

UNESCO World Heritage Site in Spain Walls of ÁvilaMuralla de ÁvilaÁvila, Spain Ávila's defensive wallsCoordinates40°39′23″N 4°42′0″W / 40.65639°N 4.70000°W / 40.65639; -4.70000TypeMedieval fortification UNESCO World Heritage SiteOfficial nameMuralla y PuertasTypeCulturalCriteriaiii, ivDesignated1985 (9th session)Part ofOld Town of Ávila with its Extra-Muros ChurchesReference no.348bis-001RegionEurope and North America Spanish Cultural HeritageOffi...

Battle of Turtle Gut Inlet

First privateer battle of the American Revolutionary War Battle of Turtle Gut InletPart of the American Revolutionary WarLocation of Turtle Gut Inlet on 1777 mapDateJune 29, 1776 (1776-06-29)LocationTurtle Gut Inlet, off Wildwood Crestnear Cape May, New Jersey38°57′30″N 74°50′30″W / 38.95833°N 74.84167°W / 38.95833; -74.84167Result American victoryBelligerents  Great Britain United ColoniesCommanders and leaders Charles Hudson Alexander ...

 

约翰斯顿环礁

此條目可参照英語維基百科相應條目来扩充。 (2021年5月6日)若您熟悉来源语言和主题，请协助参考外语维基百科扩充条目。请勿直接提交机械翻译，也不要翻译不可靠、低品质内容。依版权协议，译文需在编辑摘要注明来源，或于讨论页顶部标记{{Translated page}}标签。 约翰斯顿环礁Kalama Atoll 美國本土外小島嶼 Johnston Atoll 旗幟颂歌：《星條旗》The Star-Spangled Banner約翰斯頓環礁�...

 

Anita Malfatti

Pour les articles homonymes, voir Malfatti. Si ce bandeau n'est plus pertinent, retirez-le. Cliquez ici pour en savoir plus. Certaines informations figurant dans cet article ou cette section devraient être mieux reliées aux sources mentionnées dans les sections « Bibliographie », « Sources » ou « Liens externes » (octobre 2016). Vous pouvez améliorer la vérifiabilité en associant ces informations à des références à l'aide d'appels de notes. Anita...

內閣總理大臣

  关于与「內閣總理大臣」標題相近或相同的条目页，請見「內閣總理大臣 (消歧義)」。 日本國內閣總理大臣內閣總理大臣紋章現任岸田文雄自2021年10月4日在任尊称總理、總理大臣、首相、阁下官邸總理大臣官邸提名者國會全體議員選出任命者天皇任期四年，無連任限制[註 1]設立法源日本國憲法先前职位太政大臣（太政官）首任伊藤博文设立1885年12月22日，...

 

Ferdinando Bertoni

Italian composer and organist (1725–1813) Ferdinando Gasparo BertoniBorn15 August 1725 (1725-08-15)SalòDied1 December 1813(1813-12-01) (aged 88)Desenzano del GardaNationalityItalianOccupation(s)Composer and organist.Notable work Composed 70 operas Composed 200 sacred works Ferdinando Gasparo Bertoni (15 August 1725 – 1 December 1813) was an Italian composer and organist. Early years He was born in Salò, and began his music studies in Brescia, not far from his birthplace. Aroun...

 

Carlo Montano

Artikel ini sebatang kara, artinya tidak ada artikel lain yang memiliki pranala balik ke halaman ini.Bantulah menambah pranala ke artikel ini dari artikel yang berhubungan atau coba peralatan pencari pranala.Tag ini diberikan pada November 2022. Carlo MontanoInformasi pribadiLahir25 September 1952 (umur 71)Livorno, Italia OlahragaOlahragaAnggar Rekam medali Anggar putra Mewakili  Italia Olimpiade 1976 Montréal Floret tim Carlo Montano (lahir 25 September 1952) adalah seorang atlet ...

The Pyramid (Antarctica)

Antarctica mountain For the mountain in the Trinity Peninsula, see Dimaryp Peak. For the mountain in the Quartermain Mountains in Victoria Land, see Pyramid Mountain (Antarctica). The PyramidThe PyramidThe Pyramid Highest pointCoordinates78°21′S 163°30′E / 78.350°S 163.500°E / -78.350; 163.500 (The Pyramid)GeographyContinentAntarcticaRegionVictoria Land The Pyramid (78°21′S 163°30′E / 78.350°S 163.500°E / -78.350; 16...

 

Кунен, Ян

В Википедии есть статьи о других людях с фамилией Кунен. Ян Куненнидерл. Jan Kounen Дата рождения 2 мая 1964(1964-05-02) (60 лет) Место рождения Утрехт, Утрехт, Нидерланды[1] Гражданство  Франция Профессия кинорежиссёр, сценарист, кинооператор, актёр, кинопродюсер, клипмей...

 

Methuselah Foundation

U.S. nonprofit organization This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) A major contributor to this article appears to have a close connection with its subject. It may require cleanup to comply with Wikipedia's content policies, particularly neutral point of view. Please discuss further on the talk page. (June 2022) (Learn how and when to remove this message) This article contains con...

Mission: Impossible (serie di film)

Logo della serie Mission: Impossible è una serie cinematografica statunitense, ispirata all'omonima serie televisiva, che dal 1996 vede protagonista (nonché produttore) Tom Cruise nel ruolo di Ethan Hunt, affiancato da personaggi ricorrenti come Benji Dunn (Simon Pegg) e Luther Stickell (Ving Rhames). La serie ha riscosso successo di critica e pubblico avendo guadagnato un totale di oltre 4 miliardi di dollari in tutto il mondo.[1] Il sesto film (Mission: Impossible - Fallout), publ...

 

Franz Wöhrer

Questa voce sull'argomento arbitri di calcio è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Franz WöhrerInformazioni personaliArbitro di Calcio Federazione Austria ProfessioneInsegnante Attività nazionale AnniCampionatoRuolo 1957-1987BundesligaArbitro Attività internazionale AnniConfederazioneRuolo 1969-1987UEFA e FIFAArbitro Franz Wöhrer (5 giugno 1939) è un ex arbitro di calcio austriaco. Carriera Wöhrer esordisce come arbitro nella Bund...