Politics of memory

Politics of memory is the organisation of collective memory by political agents; the political means by which events are remembered and recorded, or discarded. Eventually, politics of memory may determine the way history is written and passed on, hence the terms history politics or politics of history. The politics of history is the effects of political influence on the representation or study of historical topics, commonly associated with the totalitarian state which use propaganda and other means to impose a specific version of history with the goal of eliminating competing perspectives about the past.[1] In order to achieve this goal, memory regimes resort to different means such as narrating (the construction of a seemingly coherent narrative), strategic silencing (the masking-out of historical facts that contradict one's own interpretation), performing (ritualized forms of reifying the narrative) or renaming/remapping (inscribing the narrative into the monumental and toponymic landscape).[2]

Nevertheless, the term is contested and there is no common agreement on its meaning which is often a matter of contextual use.[3][4] Some authors have suggested that memory debates can be ordered by an Ethics of Political Commemoration, a framework similar to Just War theory.[5]

Memories are also influenced by cultural forces, e.g. popular culture, as well as social norms. It has also been connected with the construction of identity.[6]

By country

Australia

Armenia and Turkey

Armenia and Turkey maintain strongly divergent official narratives on the events of 1915, known as the Armenian Genocide.[7] While Armenian official historiography sees in it a deliberate attempt to irrevocably cleanse the Eastern provinces of the Ottoman Empire of its indigenous Armenian populations that stands in continuity of a longer history of Anti-Armenian pogroms, Turkish official historiography denies the extent of state violence and sees in the events of 1915 merely a resettlement campaign (tehcir) provoked by hostilities of Armenian nationalist organizations backed by Tsarist Russia.[8] In contrast to Turkish official historiography, the Kurdish political movement within Turkey widely recognizes the events as a genocide, though marginalizing the role of Kurdish complicity in the killings.[9][10]

Cyprus

The two sides in the conflict in Cyprus maintain widely divergent and contrasting memories of the events that split the island. The term selective memory is applied by psychologists to people suffering from head injuries who retain some memories, but have amnesia about others. Societal trauma, such as war, seems to have a similar effect. Recollections that are shaped out of a phenomenon common to many countries traumatized by war and repression, may be remembered in radically different ways by people who experienced similar events.

The selectivity may also serve a political purpose, for example to justify the claims of one group over a competing group. Cyprus is a poignant case for this phenomenon. The longstanding conflict on the island reflects deep roots in the "motherlands" of the Greek Cypriot and Turkish Cypriot peoples.[11]

Germany

In Germany, the term "politics of history"/"history politics" (Geschichtspolitik) was propounded by German historian Christian Meier in 1986 during the Historikerstreit discussion on how to memorialise Nazi Germany and World War II.[12]

Speeches by politicians often deal with issues of how to memorialize the past. Richard von Weizsäcker as Bundespräsident identified two modes of memorializing the unconditional surrender of Nazi Germany in 1945 in his famous 1985 speech: this date can be seen as defeat or liberation. Weizsäcker backed the latter interpretation. In this regard, such moments as the first official "Day of Commemoration for Victims of National Socialism", on January 20, 1996, led to Bundespräsident Roman Herzog remarking in his address to the German Parliament that "Remembrance gives us strength, since it helps to keep us from going astray."[13] In similar, but somewhat opposing measure, Gerhard Schröder sought to move beyond this in saying the generation that committed such deeds has passed, and a new generation does not have the same fault because they simply weren't there to be responsible.[citation needed]

Good examples for politics of memory could be seen in national monuments and the discourses surrounding their construction. The construction of a Holocaust memorial in memory of the murdered Jews of Europe at a central location in Berlin was met with protests but also with strong support. Likewise the National Memorial to the Victims of War and Tyranny was deemed inappropriate by some onlookers and a discussion revolved around the question whether the lack of a differentiation between victims and perpetrators is adequate or not.[14]

The question if and how to memorise Germans expelled from Poland in the aftermath of World War II has been constantly debated in both West Germany and Poland. Such questions are so difficult because it requires a moral judgement of these events. These judgements differ remarkably. For instance, the Federation of German Expellees called on Poland to pay compensation for lost property to Germans from what after 1945 became Polish territory, a claim that is consistently declined by Poland.[15]

Similarly there have been debates in Germany whether the legacy of World War II implies that Germany's military should be confined to purely defensive measure like peacekeeping or, contrary to this, this legacy can be a justification of an active enforcement of human rights which also might involve preemptive strikes.[16]

Poland

In Poland, the issue of history politics have risen to the state level when in 2015 it was announced that the works had started on the "Strategy of Polish Political Policy" ("Strategia Polskiej Polityki Historycznej"). President Andrzej Duda announced that "carrying out the historical policy is one of the most important activities of the president".[17]

Russia

The history in Russia has been highly politicized since the times of the Soviet Union. in the 2000s Vladimir Putin's regime undertook a new revision of history under the pretext of the defense of the national past against the alleged slanderers. As a first step of this defense was the establishment of the commission to handle "the attempts to falsify history to the detriment of Russia's interests" in May 2009.[18]

The central topic of the new "history politics" has become World War II.[18]

The 2018 book of Mariëlle Wijermars Memory Politics in Contemporary Russia Television, Cinema and the State analyses the effects of various actors, such as the government, the Russian Orthodox Church, cultural figures, and radical thinkers, such as Aleksandr Dugin, on Russian memory politics, and its usage in legitimizing the government and discrediting the opposition.[19]

Ukraine

According to historian Georgiy Kasianov, the Ukrainian Institute of National Memory from 2015 was under control of Ukrainian nationalist forces.[20]

Yugoslavia

Croatian researcher Snježana Koren analyzed the history politics in Yugoslavia by analyzing teaching of history at school during 1945-1960, an immediate aftermath of World War II. She traced both internal and external influences on the state's politics of history, in particular how it was affected by the affiliation with the Soviet Union and the subsequent Soviet-Yugoslav split. She also analyzed the differences in the narratives in different Yugoslav republics.[21]

Monuments

Spatial markers of memory such as monuments play a crucial role in inscribing a historical narrative into the landscape, an act described by Herfried Münkler as the monumentalization of the landscape.[22] When successor states inherit the monumental landscape of the ancien régime often heated debates errupt on the fate of such monuments. New regimes of memory may neglect, appropriate or physically remove monuments. However, their removals may be controversial: in Estonia the removal of a Soviet era statue from the capital evoked strong reaction from Russia.[23]

Efficacy and moral relativity

W. G. Sebald underlines German amnesia surrounding the Allied carpet bombings of 131 German cities and towns which turned many German cities into vast necropolises, and resulted in an estimated 600,000 primarily civilian deaths, with millions of internal refugees.

In literature

Milan Kundera's opening story in the Book of Laughter and Forgetting is about a Slovak official posing with other officials for a photograph in winter. The man gives his fur hat to cover his superior's bald head and the photo is taken. Later, when he falls out of favour and is denounced and removed from official records and documents, he is even air-brushed out of photographs; all that remains of him is his fur hat.[24]

Winston Churchill is purported to have said that "history is written by the victors." The accuracy and significance of this statement is still debated.[25]

Raul Hilberg's autobiography is titled The politics of memory.

See also

References

  1. ^ Rafał Stobiecki (2008). "Historians Facing Politics of History: The Case of Poland". In Michael Kopeček (ed.). Past in the Making: Historical Revisionism in Central Europe After 1989. CEUP collection. Central European University Press. pp. 179–192. ISBN 9786155211423. commonly associated with the totalitarian state, where the authorities use mass propaganda and various forms of repression and pressure to try to impose their own version of history on society, with the aim of eliminating any competitive discourse about the past
  2. ^ Leupold, David (2020). Embattled dreamlands : the politics of contesting Armenian, Kurdish and Turkish memory. New York. p. 73. ISBN 978-0-429-34415-2. OCLC 1130319782.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  3. ^ Michael Goebel (2011). "Introduction". Argentina's Partisan Past Nationalism and the Politics of History. Liverpool University Press. p. 1. ISBN 9781846312380.
  4. ^ Erkki Tuomioja (2017-07-25). "History and conflict: How can historians contribute to conflict resolution and conflict prevention". historianswithoutborders.fi. Retrieved October 25, 2020.
  5. ^ Gutbrod, Hans; Wood, David (2023). Ethics of Political Commemoration. London: Palgrave MacMillan. doi:10.1007/978-3-031-31594-7. ISBN 978-3-031-31594-7. S2CID 260889390. Retrieved 31 August 2023.
  6. ^ Nasrallah, Laura (Autumn 2005). "The Politics of Memory". Harvard Divinity Bulletin. 33 (2). Retrieved 17 September 2021.
  7. ^ Suny, Ronald Grigor (2015). "They can live in the desert but nowhere else" : a history of the Armenian genocide. Princeton. ISBN 978-0-691-14730-7. OCLC 903436214.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  8. ^ Leupold, David (2020). Embattled dreamlands : the politics of contesting Armenian, Kurdish and Turkish memory. New York. pp. 76–86. ISBN 978-0-429-34415-2. OCLC 1130319782.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  9. ^ Leupold, David (2020). Embattled dreamlands : the politics of contesting Armenian, Kurdish and Turkish memory. New York. pp. 76–86, 91–92. ISBN 978-0-429-34415-2. OCLC 1130319782.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  10. ^ Utanç ve onur : 1915-2015 Ermeni Soykırımı'nın 100. yılı. Aydın Çubukçu (Birinci basım ed.). Beyoğlu, İstanbul. 2015. pp. 98–107. ISBN 978-605-331-348-9. OCLC 950682786.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: others (link)
  11. ^ "The Politics of Memory and Forgetting". Archived from the original on 2008-07-24. Retrieved 2008-11-08.
  12. ^ Troebst, Stefan (4 August 2014). "Geschichtspolitik". Docupedia-Zeitgeschichte (in German). Retrieved 12 August 2024.
  13. ^ "Divided Memory: The Nazi Past in the Two Germanys. - The Nation | HighBeam Research". highbeam.com. Archived from the original on 2012-10-22. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  14. ^ "Berlin Memorial Bibliography". utexas.edu. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  15. ^ "Eurozine - The burden of history and the trap of memory - Philipp Ther". eurozine.com. Archived from the original on 2015-02-27. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  16. ^ Huyssen, A. (2003). Present Pasts: Urban Palimpsests and the Politics of Memory. Stanford University Press. p. 73. ISBN 9780804745611. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  17. ^ "Polityka historyczna służy budowaniu potencjału państwa", November 17, 2015
  18. ^ a b Nikolay Kolosovsky (2011). ""The Armored Train of Memory": The Politics of History in Post-Soviet Russia". Perspectives on History. 49 (1): 1–7. ISSN 1940-8048. Retrieved August 13, 2024.
  19. ^ Mariëlle Wijermars Memory Politics in Contemporary Russia Television, Cinema and the State , 2018, ISBN 1351007181
  20. ^ Kasianov, Georgiy (8 June 2022). ""Ukrainian Nazis" as an invented enemy". Russia.Post.
  21. ^ A review of the book by Snježana Koren, Politika povijesti u Jugoslaviji (1945–1960) (Politics of History in Yugoslavia (1945–1960)), Southeastern Europe, Volume 38: Issue 2-3, -pp. 289-303, doi:10.1163/18763332-03802008
  22. ^ Münkler, Herfried (2010). Die Deutschen und ihre Mythen. Reinbek bei Hamburg. p. 12. ISBN 978-3-499-62394-3. OCLC 646159171.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  23. ^ Myers, Steven Lee (2007-04-27). "Russia Rebukes Estonia for Moving Soviet Statue". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2019-06-28.
  24. ^ Kakutani, Michiko (1982-01-18). "MILAN KUNDERA: A MAN WHO CANNOT FORGET". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2023-02-25.
  25. ^ "Finding a roadmap to teach kids about Mideast". NBC News. 6 May 2005. Retrieved 2023-02-25.

Further reading

Read other articles:

Building of the Israel Museum in Jerusalem Shrine of the Bookהיכל הספר31°46′24″N 35°12′10″E / 31.77333°N 35.20278°E / 31.77333; 35.20278LocationJerusalemDesignerArmand Bartos and Frederick KieslerTypeMuseumMaterialblack basaltCompletion date1965Website[1] The Shrine of the Book (Hebrew: היכל הספר, Heikhal HaSefer) is a wing of the Israel Museum in the Givat Ram neighborhood of Jerusalem that houses the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Aleppo Co...

Non-governmental chamber of commerce in China All-China Federation of Industry and Commerce中华全国工商业联合会ACFIC headquartersAbbreviationACFICFormation1953FounderChen ShutongTypeBusiness associationLegal statusPeople's organizationLocationBeijing, ChinaMembership 4.71 millionKey peopleGao Yunlong(Chairman)Xu Lejiang(Executive Vice Chairman)Websitewww.chinachamber.org.cn (in English)www.acfic.org.cn (in Chinese) Politics of China Leadership Leadership generations Succession of po...

لمزيد من المعلومات، طالع طب. المقالات في هذا التصنيف يجب نقلها إلى التصنيفات الفرعية عندما لا تكون مقالات أساسية. يحتاج هذا التصنيف لمتابعة دائمة لتجنب امتلائه بعدد كبير من المقالات. يستحسن أن يحتوي هذا التصنيف على تصنيفات فرعية فقط. طب في المشاريع الشقيقة: صور وملفات صوتية

هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (مارس 2019) إحسان أرسلان معلومات شخصية الميلاد 1 يناير 1948 (75 سنة)  ساسون، محافظة بطمان،  تركيا مواطنة تركيا  الحياة العملية المهنة سياسي  الحزب حزب العدالة والتنم

Ara

  「Ara」重定向至此。关于其他用法,请见「Ara (消歧义)」。 此條目可参照英語維基百科相應條目来扩充。若您熟悉来源语言和主题,请协助参考外语维基百科扩充条目。请勿直接提交机械翻译,也不要翻译不可靠、低品质内容。依版权协议,译文需在编辑摘要注明来源,或于讨论页顶部标记{{Translated page}}标签。 Project Ara研發商Google类型模組化智慧型手機发布日期已...

Miêu tả Phù hiệu các quân, binh chủng Quân đội nhân dân Việt Nam theo Nghị định 82/2016/NĐ-CP của Chính phủ Việt Nam. Nguồn: Sách giáo khoa Giáo dục Quốc phòng - An ninh 12 (Nhà xuất bản Giáo dục Việt Nam) Giấy phép Phạm vi công cộngPhạm vi công cộngfalsefalseHình này không phù hợp để giữ bản quyền và do đó nó thuộc phạm vi công cộng, vì nó chỉ chứa thông tin là tài sản chung hoặc không ch�...

Untuk atlet golf, lihat Harry Todd (atlet golf). Harry ToddIklan untuk The Jack-Knife Man (1920) dengan Harry Todd sebagai Booge (kanan bawah)Lahir(1863-12-13)13 Desember 1863Allegheny, Pennsylvania, Amerika SerikatMeninggal15 Februari 1935(1935-02-15) (umur 71)Glendale, California, Amerika SerikatNama lainWilliam ToddTahun aktif1909-1935Suami/istriMargaret Joslin Harry Todd (13 Desember 1863 – 15 Februari 1935) adalah seorang pemeran asal Amerika Serikat.[1...

Solvolisis Tert-butil bromida dalam pelarut etanol Solvolisis adalah suatu tipe dalam reaksi substitusi nukleofilik (SN1) atau reaksi eliminasi di mana nukleofilnya merupakan suatu molekul pelarut.[1] Mekanisme Solvolisis secara umum merupakan reaksi dengan suatu pelarut di mana satu atau lebih ikatan kimia diputuskan dalam partikel yang terlarut dalam reaktan. Tidak hanya dengan pelarut, tetapi juga berlangsung dengan salah satu dari ion berikut, reaksi solvolisis mungkin dapat terja...

Indian film actor (born 1992) Zahan KapoorZahan Kapoor, Karan Kapoor and Kunal Kapoor at Armaan Jain's wedding receptionBorn (1992-03-11) 11 March 1992 (age 31)Mumbai, Maharashtra, IndiaOccupationActorParentsKunal Kapoor (father)Sheena Sippy (mother)FamilyKapoor family Zahan Prithviraj Kapoor (Hindi pronounced [zəˈɦəːɳ kəˈpuːɾ], born 11 March 1992) is an Indian actor who primarily works in Hindi films and theater plays.[1] A member of the Kapoor family, he is so...

Regent of Awadh, 1857–1858 Begum Hazrat MahalBegum of Nawab of AwadhBegum Hazrat MahalBornMuhammadi Khanum1820[citation needed]Faizabad, AwadhDied7 April 1879 (aged 59)Kathmandu, Kingdom of NepalHusbandNawab Wajid Ali ShahReligionShia Islam[1] Begum Hazrat Mahal (c. 1820 – 7 April 1879), also known as the Begum of Awadh, was the second wife of Nawab of Awadh Wajid Ali Shah, and the regent of Awadh in 1857–1858. She is known for the leading role she had in th...

American medical physicist The topic of this article may not meet Wikipedia's notability guideline for biographies. Please help to demonstrate the notability of the topic by citing reliable secondary sources that are independent of the topic and provide significant coverage of it beyond a mere trivial mention. If notability cannot be shown, the article is likely to be merged, redirected, or deleted.Find sources: E. Theo Agard – news · newspapers · books · sc...

屯門市中心公共運輸交匯處Tuen Mun Central Public Transport Interchange其他名称屯門市中心總站位置屯門區屯門鄉事會路 屯門文娛廣場底途经线路 作为首末站: 九巴52X、60X、61X、62P、260B、868龍運巴士E33 作为中途站: 九巴60M、62X、259S、261X、263、263A、263B、263C、N260城巴B3港鐵巴士506、K51、K51A、K52、K53、K54、K58過海隧道巴士960B、961、961P龍運巴士A33X、E36A、E37C、N30、NA33、R33專線小巴43...

German ice hockey player (born 1991) Ice hockey player Philipp Grubauer Grubauer with the Hershey Bears in 2015Born (1991-11-25) 25 November 1991 (age 32)Rosenheim, GermanyHeight 6 ft 2 in (188 cm)Weight 185 lb (84 kg; 13 st 3 lb)Position GoaltenderCatches LeftNHL teamFormer teams Seattle KrakenWashington CapitalsColorado AvalancheNational team  GermanyNHL Draft 112th overall, 2010Washington CapitalsPlaying career 2011–present Philipp Grubaue...

Big data analysis and visualization tool used by the NSA National Security Agency surveillanceMap of global NSA data collection as of 2007[update], with countries subject to the most data collection shown in red Programs Pre-1978 ECHELON MINARET SHAMROCK PROMIS Since 1978 Upstream collection BLARNEY FAIRVIEW Main Core ThinThread Genoa Since 1990 RAMPART-A Since 1998 Tailored Access Operations Since 2001 OAKSTAR STORMBREW Trailblazer Turbulence Genoa II Total Information Awareness Pres...

This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: JumpStart Adventures 3rd Grade: Mystery Mountain – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (October 2023) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) 1996 video gameJumpStart Adventures 3rd Grade: Mystery MountainThe current (2007) cover of JumpSta...

У этого термина существуют и другие значения, см. Рожава (значения). Автономная администрация северной и восточной Сириикурд. Rêveberiya Xweser a Bakur û Rojhilatê Sûriyeyêараб. فدرالية الديمقراطية لشمال سوريا‎ассир. ܡܕܰܒܪܳܢܘܬ݂ܳܐ ܝܳܬ݂ܰܝܬܳܐ ܠܓܰܪܒܝܳܐ ܘܡܰܕܢܚܳܐ ܕܣܘܪܝܰܐтур. Kuzey ve Doğu Suriye �...

Villa Lindenhof mit den „friedens räumen“ Das Friedensmuseum Lindau (heutige Eigenbezeichnung: friedens räume) in Lindau (Bodensee) ist ein Friedensmuseum der Bistumsstelle Augsburg der Pax Christi. 1980 wurde das Friedensmuseum auf Initiative des Architekten und Pax-christi-Mitglieds Thomas Wechs aus Augsburg gegründet. Nach einer Phase der Neuorientierung eröffneten 2001 die friedens räume – museum in Bewegung ihre Türen. Das neue Konzept des Friedensmuseums wurde gemeinsam mit ...

Salah satu bentuk pemanfaatan mikroorganisme yang dilukiskan pada dinasti ke-18 di Mesir. Interaksi manusia dengan mikroorganisme adalah hubungan baik berupa praktik maupun simbolik dalam memanfaatkan mikroorganisme, atau dalam bentuk interaksi negatif berupa penyakit pada manusia, hewan peliharaan, dan tanaman. Pemanfaatan mikroorganisme telah dilakukan oleh manusia sejak zaman dahulu. Bahkan sebelum mikroskop ditemukan yaitu saat keberadaan mikroorganisme belum diketahui. Delapan ribu tahun...

For other uses, see Mariette. Mariette History France Name Mariette Kebyar Janeen Gee Gee IV Cleopatras Barge II' Le Voyageur Guinevere Evening Star Mariette[1] BuilderHerreshoff, Bristol Launched1916 StatusIn service General characteristics Displacement165 tonnes Length 33.50 m (total) [2] 24.30 m (hul) [2] Beam7.20 m [2] Draught4.20 m [2] Propulsion 786/1033 m² of sail [2] 2 Caterpillar engines (180 shp) [2] Boats & landing craft ...

Single by Chance the Rapper I Might Need SecuritySingle by Chance the RapperReleasedJuly 19, 2018Length4:01Songwriter(s)Chancelor BennettProducer(s)Peter CottonTale, Bennett, Smoko OnoChance the Rapper singles chronology Wala Cam (2018) I Might Need Security (2018) No Brainer (2018) I Might Need Security is a song written by American rapper Chance the Rapper. It was released as a single on July 19, 2018, and was produced by Chance, Peter CottonTale and Smoko Ono. Background and composition Th...