Born in Laconia, Indiana, May threw and batted right-handed, stood 5 feet 11 inches (1.80 m) tall and weighed 165 pounds (75 kg). His nickname stemmed from his reddish hair. Tommy John, who played under May in the minor leagues, recalled "Pinky was a short man with glasses, a ruddy face, and a sunny disposition."[4]
Finally, on October 4, 1938, May was drafted out of the Yankee system—but by the Phillies, the worst team in the National League in 1938 with a dismal outlook for their immediate future. During May's five seasons in Philadelphia, the Phils averaged 104 losses a season; they finished eighth and last four times, and seventh once.
May held down the Phillies' regular job at the "hot corner" for all five campaigns. In 1941, he led all National League third basemen in putouts, assists, double plays turned, and range factor; he was consistently among the NL's four top third basemen in those defensive categories throughout his MLB tenure.[1] At the plate, May connected for 610 career hits, including 102 doubles, 11 triples and four home runs, batted .275, and was credited with 215 runs batted in.
Elected to the Indiana Baseball Hall of Fame, he died in Corydon at age 89 on September 4, 2000.
Tommy John recalled that "He knew the game. Pinky was a good field manager, and could scream and yell at the umps with the best of them. But he never blasted his players. He could get into a player when the situation called for it, but he never did so vindictively. He was a family man who knew how to handle young men."[4]
