Toogood was the leading amateur in the 1950, 1952, 1955, and 1957 Australian Opens, and in 1954 was leading amateur in The Open Championship.[6] Earlier in 1954 he reached the last-16 of the Amateur Championship before losing to Joe Carr at the 20th hole.[7] He defeated his brother John in the final of the 1954 Australian Amateur, leading to the famous headline "Toogood Was Too Good For Toogood".[8] He was selected in 1958 for Australia's team for the first Eisenhower Trophy at St Andrews, where they beat the United States by two strokes in a playoff. His third round of 71 was the only sub-par round of the competition.[9]
His father, Alf Toogood, son of Alfred Toogood, Sr., was born in England in 1895 and had arrived in Australia in about 1919. He moved to Tasmania from South Australia in 1936 as professional at the Kingston Beach Club,[11] and won two Tasmanian Opens, in 1938 and 1950. Peter Toogood finished runner-up behind his father in the 1950 event.[12]
^"Grange Golf Club". The News (Adelaide). Vol. XIV, no. 2, 075. South Australia. 11 March 1930. p. 3. Retrieved 30 June 2018 – via National Library of Australia.
^"Boy's notable feat". Daily Mercury. Vol. 73, no. 28. Queensland, Australia. 2 February 1939. p. 10. Retrieved 7 June 2019 – via National Library of Australia.