Peter Leo Gerety (July 19, 1912 – September 20, 2016) was an American Catholic prelate who served as Archbishop of Newark from 1974 to 1986. He previously served as Bishop of Portland in Maine from 1969 to 1974. Gerety was the oldest living Catholic bishop in the world at the time of his death at age 104.[1]
On June 29, 1939, Gerety was ordained a priest for the Diocese of Hartford at the Cathedral of Notre Dame in Paris.[5] Following his return to Connecticut, he was assigned as a curate at St. John the Evangelist Parish in New Haven, Connecticut.[3] In addition to his duties at St. John's, he served as a chaplain at Grace-New Haven Hospital in New Haven.[3] In 1942, Gerety was appointed a curate at St. Brendan Parish and the director of Blessed Martin de Porres Center, both in New Haven.[4] The center was an interracial social and religious organization that ministered to the African American Catholic community.[3] In 1956, the center became St. Martin de Porres Parrish and Gerety was named its first pastor.[6]
During his tenure at St. Martin's, Gerety became an outspoken advocate for the American Civil Rights Movement and supported programs to eliminate poverty.[7] In 1963, he was chosen as coordinator and director of the Diocesan Priests' Conference on Interracial Justice.[7]
Due to the failing health of Bishop Feeney, Gerety became apostolic administrator of the diocese on February 18, 1967, assuming responsibility for the daily activities of the diocese.[7] Upon the death of Bishop Feeney on September 15, 1969, Gerety succeeded him as the eighth Bishop of Portland.[5]
During his 12-year tenure in Newark, Gerety created the Office of Pastoral Renewal and began a ministry to divorced Catholics.[10] The Office of Pastoral Renewal evolved into RENEW International, an organization now based in Plainfield, New Jersey, that provides resources for small Christian communities in the United States, Canada, Latin America, and South Africa. Gerety established the Archbishop's Annual Appeal in 1975, and supported the charismatic and ecumenical movements.[10] He also established the Archbishop Gerety Fund for Ecclesiastical History to advance studies in ecclesiastical history, especially the history of Catholicism in the United States.[2]
A year prior to his resignation, the Archbishop addressed the charismatic covenant community known as the People of Hope, a branch of the Sword of the Spirit. In 1984, the Archbishop had asked People of Hope to submit statutes to bring them into a canonical relationship with the Archdiocese. The community responded positively. On December 8, 1985, Gerety addressed the People of Hope at length, informing them of the process they would be involved in over the next year to bring them into compliance with his expectations of a 'Catholic' organization, approved by the Archdiocese. The People of Hope however claimed they were not subject to his authority as they were members of the Sword of the Spirit, an umbrella organization of Covenant Communities out of Ann Arbor, MI. Robert Gallic, a 'coordinator' for the People of Hope, withdrew the 1984 statutes. Gerety's retirement in 1986 was viewed by many of us in the Sword of the Spirit as a victory. See the collection of official correspondence between the Archbishop, his delegate, the People of Hope and the Sword of the Spirit at https://www.scribd.com/document/76728560[11][self-published source]
Later life
Gerety submitted his letter of resignation as Archbishop of Newark to Pope John Paul II on June 3, 1986.[5] At that time, he declared,
"It is well known that a bishop must resign at the age of 75. I will be 74 years old next month and I told the Holy Father in my letter of resignation that for the good of God's Church and for my own peace of mind, I believe it is time of a younger man to take over the reins of office here in Newark. I have done my best and I am very happy now to step aside."[3]
On May 11, 2013, the Archdiocese of Newark settled two lawsuits by men who were abused as children by Carmen Sita, a priest at St. Aloysius Parish in Jersey City, New Jersey. Five men were abused in the 1970s by Sita, who in 1982 pleaded guilty to sexual assault. Gerety then allowed Sita to legally change his name to Gerald Howard and move to Missouri. Gerety never notified the Diocese of Jefferson City about Sita's name change or his conviction. Sita then abused at least three more children in Missouri. The Archdiocese of Newark agreed to pay $650,000 to the five New Jersey victims and $225,000 to one Missouri victim.[14][15]
On May 11, 2021, a woman filed a $50 million lawsuit against the Archdiocese of Newark. The plaintiff claimed that Gerety had sexually abused her starting in 1976 three or four times when she was five years old. Gerety had been bringing extra food to the family and babysitting the young girl. The New Jersey Independent Victim Compensation Program had investigated her claims, but did not find them credible. The program had offered her a $5,000 settlement, which she rejected.[16][17]
