The Indians finished as the runner up in the 1936 overall Northeast Arkansas League regular season standings, ending regular season with a 58–37 record, playing the season under manager Royce Williams.[4] Osceola ended their first season of play in second place overall, finishing 8.0 games behind the first place Newport Cardinals in the overall standings.[5]
Despite their second place overall finish, Osceola did not qualify for the 1936 playoffs as the Northeast Arkansas League played a split–season schedule and Osceola did not win either of the half–seasons. The Caruthersville Pilots won the championship playoff against Newport.[6][7] Osceola pitcher Ernest Bingham of Osceola led the Northeast Arkansas League with 23 wins. Teammate Paul Rucker scored 90 runs to lead the league.[5]
In their second season of play, the 1937 Osceola Indians became an affiliate of the St. Louis Browns.[8] The Indians ended the 1937 season with a record of 49–60, placing fifth in the standings, playing the season under manager Elmer Kirchoff.[9][5]
Future major league All-Star pitcher Johnny Sain pitched for Osceola in 1936 and 1937.[10] Sain would become a three-time MLB All-Star, six-time world series champion and earn induction into the Braves Hall of Fame. After graduating from Havana High School in Arkansas, Sain reportedly approached Doc Prothro, who was managing the minor league Little Rock Travelers and signed a contract for $5.00, before reporting to play for Osceola.[11][12]
After drawing 7,830 total fans for their 1937 home games, the Osceola franchise folded after the 1937 season, replaced by the Batesville White Sox in the 1938 Northeast Arkansas League.[5] Osceola, Arkansas has not hosted another minor league team.[13][3]
The ballpark
The Osceola Indians were noted to have played minor league home games at the High School Ballpark. The ballpark was located at Osceola High School, 2800 West Semmes Avenue, in Osceola.[14]
(2014) Ballpark in the background Osceola, Arkansas
