On January 27, 2021, Evelyn Magley, CEO of The Basketball League (TBL), announced that Omaha's Finest, owned by Tra-Deon Hollins, was joining the league for the 2021 season.[3][4] On January 28, 2021, Eric Behrens was announced as the head coach.[5] Ryan Stubbe was named the general manager, while Agau was the director of basketball operations.[6] It was announced on March 15, 2021, that the team would play its home games at Millard North High School and the season opener was on April 9 against the Enid Outlaws.[7]
The team's initial roster featured Thurman, SWAC player of the year Devonte Patterson, former Mississippi State player Craig Sword, as well as several local Omaha players.[6] Omaha's Finest reached the playoffs in their first season before losing to Enid.[8]