In 2004, Rinehart left the band to pursue other non-musical interests. The remaining members started a new band, no shows are recordings were ever made.
The Refine album was well-reviewed[by whom?] for its honest, no-frills metal approach. The band performed live gigs, including a show at the Stryper Expo, but Rinehart received an injury soon after the album release which meant Oil did not perform for nearly a year. Once recovered, Rinehart and Oil returned to performing, being announced as special guests to Disciple in April[when?].[citation needed]
The band recorded the live album Choice Cuts Off the Chopping Block at the First Baptist Church in Downey, California, in November 2002 through Roxx Records.[3] The record included two new acoustic songs, "This Is My Prayer" and "Medicine Man".[3] When bass guitarist Matthew Joy opted out in May 2003, Oil recruited Jonathan Thiemens of Blind Sacrifices as a temporary replacement. This became permanent in July.
In July 2004, Oil announced that they were to disband. The group undertook one last show on August 14 alongside Recon, East West, Trauma and Terrestrial Harvest at The Lighthouse in Long Beach.[4]
Blake Nelson of Oil is now[when?] in the band Blake Nelson's BLAKENSTEIN. Blakenstein's new album 13th Hour was to be released in early 2014.