North Shore City Council v Auckland Regional Council

North Shore City Council v Auckland Regional Council'
CourtEnvironment Court of New Zealand
Full case name North Shore City Council v Auckland Regional Council
Decided1 October 1996
Citation[1997] NZRMA 59
TranscriptJudgment
Case history
Prior action[1995] NZRMA 424 (PT)
Subsequent action[1995] 3 NZLR 18 (CA)
Court membership
Judges sittingSheppard J, P A Catchpole and I G C Kerr
Keywords
Resource Management, Regional Policy Statement, Metropolitan Urban Limit

North Shore City Council v Auckland Regional Council was a case in the Environment Court of New Zealand concerning the proper interpretation of section five of the Resource Management Act 1991 by planning bodies.

Background

The Auckland Regional Council had publicly notified its proposed regional policy statement in early 1994 which would have restricted urban development with a line of metropolitan urban limits.

The appellants, the North Shore City Council and the owners of land in the area around Long Bay and Okura River sought to modify the metropolitan urban limits so that an area of some 700 hectares in the area would be zoned within the urban limit [1]

Judgment

The Environment Court allowed the appeals in part, "to the extent that the regional council is directed to alter the line of metropolitan urban limits in the proposed regional policy statement so that instead of following Glenvar Road, the line follows the watershed or catchment boundary between the Long Bay and Okura catchments."[2]

In coming to this determination the Court had decided that,

"We have concluded that urbanisation of the part of the subject land in the Okura catchment would necessarily have significant adverse effects on the environment of the Okura Estuary, and that the estuary, its high quality waters and ecosystem, possesses life supporting capacity which deserve to be safeguarded. However we have not accepted that there would necessarily be significant adverse effects of urbanisation on the environment of the Long Bay coast, or on the marine life of the marine reserves."[3]

In coming to its decision the Court had regard to section 5 of the Resource Management Act which states the Act's purpose as promoting sustainable management. The Court held:

"The method of applying s 5 then involves an overall broad judgment of whether a proposal would promote the sustainable management of natural and physical resources. That recognises that the [RMA] has a single purpose. Such a judgment allows for comparison of conflicting considerations and the scale or degree of them, and their relative significance or proportion in the final outcome."[4]

Significance

The case established the "overall board judgment" approach to interpretation of section 5 of the Resource Management Act.[5]

In the 2014 decision, Environmental Defence Society v New Zealand King Salmon the Supreme Court declined to follow the "overall broad judgment" approach.

References

  1. ^ North Shore City Council v Auckland Regional Council [1997] NZRMA 59 at 63.
  2. ^ At 96.
  3. ^ At 92.
  4. ^ At 94.
  5. ^ Warnock, Ceri; Baker-Galloway, Maree (2015). Focus on Resource Management Law. Wellington: LexisNexis NZ Ltd. p. 67. ISBN 978-1-927248-74-4.

Read other articles:

Air One

Artikel ini bukan mengenai Air 1. Air One IATA ICAO Kode panggil AP ADH HERON Didirikan1983; 41 tahun lalu (1983)Berhenti beroperasi30 Oktober 2014 (2014-10-30)[1][2]Pusat operasi Bandar Udara Catania-Fontanarossa Bandar Udara Palermo Falcone–Borsellino Bandar Udara Pisa Bandar Udara Marco Polo Venesia Bandar Udara Verona Villafranca Program penumpang setiaMilleMigliaArmada10SloganAir One, my number one.Perusahaan indukAlitaliaKantor pusatFiumicino, ItaliaSitus web...

 

Khanty-Mansiysk

Town in Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug, RussiaKhanty-Mansiysk Ханты-МансийскTown[1] From top down, left to right: Church of the Resurrection, Boris Losev Park, Khanty-Mansiysk Airport,Khanty-Mansiysk Biathlone Center, Archaeopark FlagCoat of armsLocation of Khanty-Mansiysk Khanty-MansiyskLocation of Khanty-MansiyskShow map of RussiaKhanty-MansiyskKhanty-Mansiysk (Khanty–Mansi Autonomous Okrug)Show map of Khanty–Mansi Autonomous OkrugCoordinates: 61°00′N 69°00′E&...

 

KMXJ-FM

Radio station in Amarillo, TexasKMXJ-FMAmarillo, TexasBroadcast areaAmarillo, TexasFrequency94.1 MHzBrandingMix 94.1ProgrammingFormatAdult contemporaryOwnershipOwnerTownsquare Media(Townsquare License, LLC)Sister stationsKATP, KIXZ, KPRF, KXSS-FMHistoryFirst air date1978 (as KBUY-FM)Former call signsKBUY-FM (1978-1987)KDJW-FM (1987-1990)KBUY-FM (1990-1999)Call sign meaningK MiX JTechnical informationFacility ID31463ClassCERP100,000 wattsHAAT330 metersLinksWebcastListen LiveWebsitemix941kmxj.c...

Triangulasi (pengukuran)

Triangulasi oleh Abbé Réginald Outhier untuk area Britania dan Normania Triangulasi (pengukuran) atau penyegitigaan merupakan proses penentuan lokasi suatu titik dengan mengukur sudut yang terbentuk atas sudut dalam segitiga, berdasarkan data titik-titik tetap yang diketahui di kedua ujung segitiga yang disebut dengan titik kontrol. Menggunakan metode trigonometri dan data hasil pengukuran panjang dari salah satu sisi segitiga tersebut, maka jarak lain dalam segitiga dapat diketahui menggun...

 

Princess Antoinette of Saxe-Altenburg

Duchess consort of Anhalt Antoinette of Saxe-AltenburgDuchess consort of AnhaltBorn(1838-04-17)17 April 1838Bamberg, Kingdom of BavariaDied13 October 1908(1908-10-13) (aged 70)Berchtesgaden, Kingdom of Bavaria, German EmpireSpouseFriedrich I, Duke of AnhaltIssueLeopold, Hereditary Prince of AnhaltFriedrich II, Duke of Anhalt Elisabeth, Grand Duchess of Mecklenburg-Strelitz Eduard, Duke of Anhalt Prince Aribert of AnhaltAlexandra, Princess of SchwarzburgNamesAntoinette Charlotte Marie Jos...

 

Temple in Jerusalem

Former places of Israelite and Jewish worship Part of a series onJerusalem History Timeline City of David Second Temple Period Aelia Capitolina Middle Ages Early Muslim period Kingdom of Jerusalem Mutasarrifate British Mandate Israeli takeover of West Jerusalem Jordanian annexation of East Jerusalem Israeli annexation of East Jerusalem Sieges Before Common Era 701 BCE 597 BCE 587 BCE 63 BCE 37 BCE Common Era 70 614 637 1099 1187 1244 1834 1917 1948 Places East West Old City Temple Mount/Al-Aq...

Isabelle Faust

German violinist (born 1972) Isabelle FaustFaust in 2012Born (1972-03-19) 19 March 1972 (age 52)EsslingenOccupationsClassical violinistAcademic teacherOrganizationsBerlin University of the ArtsAwardsGramophone AwardCannes Classical AwardDiapason d'Or Isabelle Faust (born 19 March 1972) is a German violinist who has worked internationally as a soloist and chamber musician. She has received multiple awards. Life and career Faust was born in Esslingen am Neckar, Baden-Württemberg on 12 Mar...

 

1872 Danish Folketing election

Politics of Denmark Constitution Fundamental laws Act of Succession Freedom of Speech Freedom of the Press The Crown Monarch Frederik X Crown Prince Christian Royal family Privy Council Purveyors to the Royal Court The unity of the Realm Denmark proper Faroe Islands Greenland Executive Government Frederiksen II Prime Minister (list) Mette Frederiksen Government Offices Ministries High Commissioners Faroe Islands Greenland Legislature Folketinget (parliament) Speaker: Søren Gade Members Judic...

 

2020年夏季奧林匹克運動會波蘭代表團

2020年夏季奥林匹克运动会波兰代表團波兰国旗IOC編碼POLNOC波蘭奧林匹克委員會網站olimpijski.pl（英文）（波兰文）2020年夏季奥林匹克运动会（東京）2021年7月23日至8月8日（受2019冠状病毒病疫情影响推迟，但仍保留原定名称）運動員206參賽項目24个大项旗手开幕式：帕维尔·科热尼奥夫斯基（游泳）和马娅·沃什乔夫斯卡（自行车）[1]闭幕式：卡罗利娜·纳亚（皮划艇）&#...

Record of Youth

Record of YouthPoster promosiNama alternatifThe MomentHangul청춘기록 Hanja青春紀錄 GenreMasa muda RomansaPengembangStudio DragonDitulis olehHa Myung-heeSutradaraAhn Gil-hoPemeranPark Bo-gumPark So-damByeon Woo-seokKwon Soo-hyunNegara asalKorea SelatanBahasa asliKoreaJmlh. episode16ProduksiRumah produksiStudio Dragon Pan EntertainmentDistributortvN Netflix (internasional)Rilis asliJaringantvNFormat gambar1080i (HDTV)Format audioDolby DigitalRilis7 September (2020-09-07) –2...

 

Pertempuran Isonzo Kesembilan

Pertempuran Isonzo KesembilanBagian dari blok Italia selama Perang Dunia IPertempuran Isonzo ke-9Juni 1915 — September 1917Tanggal31 Oktober—4 November 1916LokasiLembah Sungai Isonzo, SloveniaHasil Desakan Italia terbatasPihak terlibat Italia  Austria-HungariaTokoh dan pemimpin Luigi Cadorna Jenderal Svetozar BoroevićKekuatan 225 batalyon, 1,390 artileri 170 batalyon, 990 artileriKorban 39.000 33.000 lbsBlok Italia Isonzo I Isonzo II Isonzo III Isonzo IV Isonzo V Asiago Isonzo VI Is...

 

2007–08 Iowa State Cyclones men's basketball team

American college basketball season 2007–08 Iowa State Cyclones men's basketballConferenceBig 12 ConferenceRecord14-18 (4-12 Big 12)Head coachGreg McDermott (2nd season)Assistant coaches T.J. Otzelberger Jeff Rutter Jean Prioleau Home arenaHilton ColiseumSeasons← 2006–072008–09 → 2007–08 Big 12 men's basketball standings vte Conf Overall Team W   L   PCT W   L   PCT No. 7 Texas 13 – 3   .813 31 – 7   .816 No. 4 K...

خط طول 115° شرق

يفتقر محتوى هذه المقالة إلى الاستشهاد بمصادر. فضلاً، ساهم في تطوير هذه المقالة من خلال إضافة مصادر موثوق بها. أي معلومات غير موثقة يمكن التشكيك بها وإزالتها. (ديسمبر 2018) 115° خط طول 115 شرق خريطة لجميع الإحداثيات من جوجل خريطة لجميع الإحداثيات من بينغ تصدير جميع الإحداثيات من ك...

 

赵家村西无铭阙

渠县汉阙－赵家村汉阙赵家村西无铭阙由法国人谢阁兰摄于1914年全国重点文物保护单位中华人民共和国国务院公布地址四川省渠县坐标31°1′21.76″N 107°2′29.15″E / 31.0227111°N 107.0414306°E / 31.0227111; 107.0414306分类古建筑时代汉编号合并项目第13项认定时间2001年6月25日保护历史 1956年8月16日：四川省第一批历史及革命文物保护单位（赵家坪第一无铭阙及第二无�...

 

South African Class 19E

Type of electric locomotive South African Class 19ENo. 19-009, 19-054 and 19-067 at the Richards Bay Locomotive Depot, 8 December 2013Type and originPower typeElectricDesignerMitsuiBuilderUnion Carriage & WagonModelMitsui 19EBuild date2007-2011Total produced110SpecificationsConfiguration:​ • AARB-B • UICBo'Bo' • CommonwealthBo-BoGauge3 ft 6 in (1,067 mm) Cape gaugeWheel diameter1,250 mm (49.2 in)Length:​ ...

Tulip Siddiq

Tulip Siddiq Shadow Minister for Early YearsPetahanaMulai menjabat 7 Januari 2020PemimpinJeremy CorbynSir Keir StarmerPendahuluTracy BrabinPenggantiPetahanaMasa jabatan9 Oktober 2016 – 26 Januari 2017PemimpinJeremy CorbynPendahuluLowongPenggantiTracy BrabinAnggota Parlemenuntuk Hampstead dan KilburnPetahanaMulai menjabat 7 Mei 2015PendahuluGlenda JacksonPenggantiPetahanaMayoritas14,188 (24.7%)Camden London Borough Councilloruntuk Regent's ParkMasa jabatan6 Mei 2010 –...

 

Tiuna

Tiuna UR-53AR50 Тип Внедорожник Страна  Венесуэла История службы Годы эксплуатации 2004 - Настоящее время История производства Производитель CENARECA Годы производства 2004 – настоящее время Стоимость экземпляра $69.767,44 (USD) / BsF. 142.857,00 (VEF) Характеристики Масса, кг 2 тонны Тип и модель д...

 

Governo Moro II

Governo Moro II Stato Italia Presidente del ConsiglioAldo Moro(DC) CoalizioneDC, PSI, PSDI, PRI LegislaturaIV Legislatura Giuramento23 luglio 1964 Dimissioni21 gennaio 1966 Governo successivoMoro III24 febbraio 1966 Moro I Moro III Il Governo Moro II è stato il ventesimo esecutivo della Repubblica Italiana, il terzo della IV legislatura. È rimasto in carica dal 23 luglio 1964[1][2][3] al 24 febbraio 1966[4] per un totale di 581 giorni, ovvero 1 anno, 7 m...

Roberto Venturato

Roberto VenturatoNazionalità Italia Calcio RuoloAllenatore (ex centrocampista) Termine carriera1996 - giocatore CarrieraSquadre di club1 1980-1982 Montebelluna29 (0)1982-1983 Cremonese0 (0)1983-1984 Pergocrema0 (0)1984-1987 Giorgione68 (7)1987-1990 Pergocrema87 (8)1990-1991 Venezia31 (5)1991-1993 Pergocrema65 (6)1993-1994 Treviso24 (0)1994-1996 Pizzighettone33 (1) Carriera da allenatore 1996-2002 PizzighettoneGiovanili2002-2007 Pizz...

 

تيرك (قرية)

تيرك    شعار الاسم الرسمي (بالقبردينية: Тэрч къалэ)‏(بالروسية: Муртазово)‏  الإحداثيات 43°29′00″N 44°08′00″E / 43.483333333333°N 44.133333333333°E / 43.483333333333; 44.133333333333   تاريخ التأسيس 1876  تقسيم إداري  البلد روسيا[1]  خصائص جغرافية  المساحة 12 كيلومتر مربع  ا...