Bucci was named to the Journal-Every Evening all-state football team twice in his career, and was the first two-time selection. His coach described him as "the best running back I ever had," and Claymont's "best blocker, one of our best tacklers, our best passer, and a fair punter."[3] As a senior, he helped the team compile an undefeated record, scoring 149 of their 250 points (including 23 touchdowns) and leading the state in scoring. For this, he was named the first "Delaware Athlete of the Year," but did not receive the award due to rules of the Delaware Association of School Administrators which declared that high school athletes are ineligible to receive the award.[4]
After leaving the University of Delaware, Bucci joined the independent Marcus Hook Athletic Association in October 1951.[6][7] He returned to the team for their 1952 season, as a member of the Wilmington Football League, and helped them achieve an undefeated 7–0 record and the league championship title.[8][9] He also played for their 1953 championship team before being sent to the United States Navy.[10]
Later life and death
After serving three years in the Navy, Bucci worked for the Phoenix Steel Corporation for 36 years, and later at Sears and in the Philadelphia Phillies security. He also worked for the New Castle County crossing guards until his retirement at the age of 80.[1]
With his wife, Tina, Bucci had three children. His only son, Nick Jr., was described as the "direct opposite" of Nick Sr., never playing sports and instead being a musician.[11]