"New to You" marks the second time Harris has teamed up with Tinashe, following their song "Dollar Signs" from his fourth studio album Motion (2014); he also previously teamed up with Normani on the 2018 extended play Normani x Calvin Harris, which contains the songs "Checklist" and "Slow Down"; and previously joined Offset on the Frank Ocean–assisted single "Slide" from his album Funk Wav Bounces Vol. 1 (2017).[1]
Composition
The song was composed by Harris, alongside Normani, Tinashe, Offset, and singer-songwriter Jessie Reyez.[2]
Musically, "New to You" is a bubbly R&B-inspired post-disco song.[3]Billboard referred to it as "classy orchestral arrangements with glittery disco vibes".[4] The track has also been described as having "a swaying groove, punchy stings and synths leading the way over a slick bass line".[5] It sees Normani singing about seducing a potential love interest with the lyrics "This might be news to you / This thing might feel new to you / But if you like everything / I think you might love me, baby" in the chorus;[5] and Offset rapping about "the effervescent feeling of finding the right person" with lyrics like "I was dead on relationships / You made me feel like living."[3]