Neaton played for the Detroit Country Day Yellowjackets in high school, scoring 222 goals in four seasons, three shy of the national record.[3] She was also an All-State basketball player for the Yellowjackets. In college, she played for the William & Mary Tribe. In total, she scored 81 goals and recorded 28 assists during her career with the Tribe, making her the school's record goalscorer.[4] She also has the second most career points (goals and assists) for the school, with 190.[5] She was ISAA Player of the Year in 1995, NSCAA and Soccer America First-Team All-American in 1994, and NSCAA Second-Team All-American in 1992, 1993, and 1995.[6] She was included in the Soccer America All-Rookie Team in 1992,[7] and was a finalist for the Hermann Trophy in 1994.[8]
Neaton made her international debut for the United States on January 23, 1995 in a friendly match against Australia. In total, she made six appearances for the U.S. and scored four goals, earning her final cap on December 16, 1998 in a friendly match against Ukraine.[2]
Neaton later played club soccer in Japan for two years,[9] having received multiple offers from Japanese teams to join once she graduated from college.[10] She was inducted into the William & Mary Athletic Hall of Fame in 2008.[8]
^"Degree Candidates, May 1996 – August 1996: Bachelor of Business Administration". Commencement 1996. Williamsburg, Virginia: College of William & Mary. May 12, 1996. p. 19.
^Farnsworth, Ed (March 12, 2019). "USWNT Results, 1995–1999". Society for American Soccer History. Archived from the original on August 17, 2019. Retrieved August 17, 2019.