My Big Fat Independent Movie was a box-office bomb, earning only $4,655 in box office receipts during its world-wide run[2] with an estimated budget of around $3,000,000.[3] The film was poorly received by the consensus of critics who reviewed the film, receiving a low 23% rotten rating over at Rotten Tomatoes.[4] Internet debate soon erupted over the film's lowbrow treatment of independent film classics and caused backlash from die-hard independent film fans.[5] Chris Parry, entertainment journalist and film critic for efilmcritic.com, found that the movie targeted films that were too well liked by its intended audience, and a larger (more mainstream) audience wouldn't recognize the referenced films.[5]
Controversy over the film ensued after the producer's former publication "Filmthreat" (who co-produced the film) gave the movie a perfect 5 star review. In light of the controversy and public backlash, the company distanced itself from the movie. Before its limited domestic release, the film had been pre-screened on the festival circuit[5] including Cinequest, South by Southwest,[6] San Diego Film Festival, Sidewalk Moving Picture Festival, Newport Beach Film Festival, Worldfest Houston, and the Temecula Valley Film Festival.[1][7][8][9]
^"'My Big Fat' is a big fat joke and a parody". The Detroit News. November 4, 2005. Retrieved January 28, 2010. Crude, dumb, mean-spirited and occasionally very funny, [it] takes swipe after swipe at the pretensions of the independent film industry and, as with most crude, dumb and mean-spirited comedies, it can't help but connect here and there.
^Newton, Robert (January 24, 2006). "New on DVD". Cinematical.com. Retrieved January 28, 2010. This occasionally hilarious spoof...has its share of things that make you go "d'oh!", but it moves fast enough to forget most of them.