Upon leaving the Amawalk Reservoir via a spillway in the Amawalk Dam at the reservoir's southern end, the Muscoot is shortly joined by Hallocks Mill Brook from the west. Less than two miles later it flows into the northwestern reaches of the Muscoot Reservoir west of Whitehall Corners and northwest of Katonah, New York. The waters of Muscoot Reservoir then join with those of the New Croton Reservoir before either being carried to New York City via the New Croton Aqueduct or, in times of surplus, over the spillway at the New Croton Dam and into the Croton River, then carried into the Hudson River at Croton-on-Hudson at Croton Point about 30 miles (50 km) north of New York City.